Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can I be found neglectful before my baby leaves the hospital? In re S.J.C.

2026 UT App 173No. 20251310-CADecided Nov 13, 2026Juvenile & Child WelfareAffirmed

Holding

A parent’s inability to provide a safe, sterile home for a medically fragile infant at the time of hospital discharge is present neglect under Utah Code § 80-1-102(59)(a)(iii), which requires a causal nexus but not parental fault, even when DCFS takes custody directly from the hospital.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld the juvenile court’s ruling that the mother neglected her newborn, over one judge’s dissent.

  • On these facts, a parent who had no suitable place to take a medically fragile baby at hospital discharge could be found to have neglected the child, even though the child went straight from the hospital to DCFS.
  • Agreeing that a child is “dependent” (without proper care through no fault of the parent) meant the mother conceded the child lacked proper care, which satisfied part of the neglect test.
  • One judge dissented, reading the statute to require that the parent actually failed to provide care.

What happened?

S.J.C. (the Child) was born fifteen weeks premature with serious medical conditions. He spent more than five months in the newborn intensive care unit. His mother, S.C. (Mother), stayed at his bedside for nearly all of that time.

Hospital and DCFS workers (the Division of Child and Family Services, Utah’s child welfare agency) worried that Mother had nowhere to live after discharge. Mother believed she could move back in with her own mother (Grandmother). Grandmother had told the workers no, but did not tell Mother until the day the Child was discharged.

On that day, DCFS served a removal warrant at the hospital and took custody of the Child. After a trial, the juvenile court found by clear and convincing evidence (a higher bar than “more likely than not”) that the Child was neglected as to Mother.

What did Mother argue?

Mother agreed the Child was “dependent,” meaning without proper care through no fault of the parent. But she said “neglect” requires something the parent did or failed to do in the past or present, and the Child was never in her care, so she never had a chance to neglect him. She also challenged four of the court’s factual findings.

What did the court decide about neglect?

The court affirmed. The neglect definition it applied covers a parent’s “action or inaction” causing a failure to provide proper or necessary care. The court said proper care means the care the child reasonably needs under the circumstances.

First, by conceding dependency, Mother conceded the Child was without proper care at discharge. Second, the court treated the whole discharge process as the “present” moment. At that time Mother had no stable housing, sterile setting or reliable electricity, and the Child had to go somewhere. DCFS did not need to hand the Child to Mother and then take him back.

Under this part of the statute, the court did not need to decide whether the housing problem was Mother’s fault. It was enough that her failure to arrange a suitable home caused the lack of care.

What about the challenged findings?

The court upheld the findings that Mother said the Child did not need a feeding tube and that she did not engage in discharge planning. For the findings about breastfeeding and substance use, the court assumed they lacked support but held they made no difference, because the neglect ruling rested mainly on Mother having no housing.

Did all the judges agree?

No. Judge Tenney dissented. He read the statute to require that the parent herself caused a failure of care, and he saw no moment when the Child was in Mother’s care. He also noted Mother was misled about Grandmother’s home, and that DCFS could have relied on dependency or alleged abuse based on threatened harm instead.

What happens now?

The neglect ruling stands, and the Child remains in DCFS custody. The court noted that a neglect finding, unlike dependency alone, can be a ground in any later case to end parental rights.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Harris, J., joined by Mortensen, J.; Tenney, J., dissenting). The juvenile court did not err in adjudicating Child neglected as to Mother under subsection (iii) of Utah Code § 80-1-102(59)(a), because her inability to provide a safe and sterile environment at discharge “represented present neglect” (¶ 46). The court noted the appeal is not moot under the collateral consequence exception, since dependency alone is not a termination ground (¶ 27 n.3).

Issue 1: Neglect under § 80-1-102(59)(a)(iii) (correctness, ¶ 21): affirmed (no error)

Both elements of subsection (iii) were met: Child lacked proper or necessary care at discharge, and Mother’s action or inaction caused that failure (¶ 38). The court affirmed on subsection (iii), which the GAL pointed to, since one basis suffices (¶ 24, following In re G.H., 2023 UT App 132, ¶ 28, 540 P.3d 631). It held that “proper or necessary . . . care” means “the level of care and attention that the child reasonably needs under the circumstances” (¶ 25), drawing on In re A.S., 2024 UT App 52, ¶ 32, 548 P.3d 181, and In re B.D., 2024 UT App 104, ¶ 43, 556 P.3d 86.

Mother’s concession of dependency, which is equally present-tense, conceded that Child was without proper care at discharge (¶¶ 27–30). Separately, the “present moment” is the whole discharge process, a unitary event; DCFS need not stage a momentary release to Mother (¶¶ 31–32). Subsection (iii), unlike (ii), requires no fault, only a nexus between the parent’s conduct and the lack of care; assuming without deciding Mother was not at fault, her failure to arrange a home was that nexus (¶¶ 34–37). The court distinguished Division of Child Prot. & Permanency v. B.P., 313 A.3d 905 (N.J. 2024) (¶ 29 n.4) and In re A.B., 2022 UT 39, 523 P.3d 168 (¶ 37 n.6), and held that the State’s choice not to plead threatened-harm abuse does not defeat neglect (¶ 31 n.5).

Issue 2: Feeding-tube finding (clearly erroneous, ¶ 22): affirmed (no error)

The finding that Mother said Child did not need a feeding tube was not clearly erroneous. Her “No” when asked whether the hospital recommended he remain on it supported that reasonable inference (¶ 41).

Issue 3: Discharge-planning finding (clearly erroneous, ¶ 22): affirmed (no error)

The finding that Mother disengaged from discharge planning was not clearly erroneous. Mother conceded it was “not necessarily erroneous,” and the court applied Traco Steel Erectors, Inc. v. Comtrol, Inc., 2009 UT 81, ¶ 17, 222 P.3d 1164 (¶ 43). On the merits, Caseworker’s testimony that Mother never followed up on housing resources supported the inference, even though Mother did not know Grandmother’s decision (¶ 43).

Issue 4: Breastfeeding and substance-use findings (clearly erroneous, ¶ 22): affirmed (harmless error)

Assuming these findings lacked support, they did not affect Mother’s substantial rights under Utah R. Civ. P. 61 (¶ 44). The neglect ruling rested largely on Mother being unhoused at discharge (¶¶ 44–45).

Separate opinion

Judge Tenney dissented. He read “causing” and “failure or refusal of a parent” to require past or present neglect by the parent, not anticipated neglect (¶ 49). The dependency concession, which includes “no fault,” does not establish that Mother caused a failure of care (¶ 54 n.7). He disagreed that discharge is an extended period and noted that DCFS could have relied on dependency or threatened-harm abuse (¶¶ 55–57).

Takeaways

  • Under subsection (iii), the State need not prove parental fault, only that the parent’s action or inaction caused the failure of care (¶¶ 34, 36).
  • Conceding dependency concedes that the child is without proper care, which can satisfy the first neglect element (¶¶ 27–30).
  • Hospital discharge may be treated as a single “present” event for assessing neglect (¶ 31).
  • Findings that did not drive the neglect ruling will not support reversal even if unsupported (¶ 44).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
In re S.J.C.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 173
Case no.
20251310-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
November 13, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A juvenile court adjudication that a medically fragile newborn, removed by DCFS at hospital discharge, was neglected as to his mother rather than only dependent.

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
Ryan D. TenneyDissented
David N. MortensenConcurred
Trial court
Third Juvenile Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge David L. Johnson

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Kirstin NormanAlexandra MareschalJason B. Richards
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyDerek E. BrownDeborah A. WoodJohn M. Peterson
Guardian ad litemOtherMartha PierceAlisha GilesHeath Haacke

Practice Tip

A parent who concedes dependency to head off a neglect finding concedes that the child is without proper care, which the court held satisfied the first element of neglect under subsection (iii) (¶¶ 27–30).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.