Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can a court call my child dependent because we never had contact? In re E.D.

2026 UT App 126No. 20260355-CADecided Aug 6, 2026Juvenile & Child WelfareReversed

Holding

A noncustodial father’s initial unawareness of his child’s removal and his lack of a relationship with the child do not, without more, show the child lacked proper parental care, so the dependency adjudication as to him was reversed.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the father and reversed the juvenile court’s ruling that his son was dependent as to him.

  • A father’s lack of a prior relationship with his child did not, without more, make the child “dependent” as to him.
  • The question is whether a parent, once told the child needs care, is ready, willing and able to give reasonable care in a timely way.
  • The required safety check before placing a child with a parent who was not living with the child does not by itself make the child dependent.

What happened?

When E.D. was born, his father and mother agreed that the father would pay child support but stay out of the boy’s life. For twelve years the father paid support and had no contact. The boy believed his mother’s boyfriend was his father.

In February 2026, E.D. and his four siblings were removed from their mother’s care and later found neglected as to her. The Utah Division of Child and Family Services (DCFS), the state child welfare agency, did not learn the father existed until two days after the removal. Once he got notice, the father joined the case and said he wanted to care for his son and build a relationship with him.

The father made admissions under rule 34(e), meaning he agreed to certain facts instead of having them proven. He admitted the agreement with the mother, that he met his son for the first time at the shelter hearing, and that he had been spending time with him since.

What did the juvenile court decide?

It ruled that E.D. was “dependent” as to the father. A child is dependent when the child is without proper care through no fault of the parent. The court reasoned that when the boy was removed, DCFS had not yet identified the father. It also said the boy could not have gone to the father “right off the bat,” because the court would first need to check him out.

What did each side argue?

The father argued nothing showed he was unfit or unable to meet the boy’s needs. He lived in the same city, had no criminal convictions, had paid support for over 12 years, and acted quickly once he learned of the removal.

The State and the guardians ad litem (lawyers appointed to represent the child’s interests) argued he could not give proper care because he had never parented the boy and had no relationship with him. They also pointed to the investigation the court must do before placing a child with a parent who was not living with the child.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It reversed. The opinion was issued by the three-judge panel as a whole, with no named author.

Relying on an earlier case, the court said the focus should have been on whether the father could give proper care in a timely way once he was told of the need, not on whether DCFS knew about him earlier. Nothing suggested he had reason to think the boy’s needs were not being met, and he joined the case soon after he was told.

The court also rejected the idea that having no relationship made the father unable to care for his son. Nothing showed the boy had unusual needs. If children’s needs can be met in foster care with strangers, the father was not unable to meet them just because he and his son had no ongoing relationship.

Finally, the required safety check does not make a child dependent. Otherwise, every noncustodial parent would face a dependency finding whenever a child was removed from the other parent.

What happens now?

The dependency ruling as to the father is reversed, and the case goes back to the juvenile court for further proceedings. The opinion does not say what those proceedings will be.

Bottom line

Reversed and remanded for further proceedings (per curiam; Mortensen, Tenney, and Luthy, JJ.). Child was removed from Mother for neglect. Father had paid child support but, by agreement with Mother, had no contact with Child for twelve years. DCFS learned of Father two days after removal, and he joined the case immediately (¶¶ 2–5). The juvenile court adjudicated Child dependent as to Father (¶ 6). The panel held that Father’s initial lack of awareness and his lack of a relationship with Child do not, “without more,” show a lack of proper parental care (¶ 14).

Issue 1: Dependency based on lack of relationship (correctness, ¶ 7): reversed

The stipulated facts did not establish as a matter of law that Child was dependent as to Father. A child is dependent when “without proper care through no fault of” the parent, Utah Code § 80-1-102(21), meaning the parent, through no fault of their own, cannot give the care the child reasonably needs. A child is not dependent if a parent stands “ready, willing, and able” to provide it (¶ 8, quoting In re B.D., 2024 UT App 104, ¶¶ 44, 47, 556 P.3d 86).

Timing and awareness. Under In re P.M., 2025 UT App 155, ¶ 15, 581 P.3d 159, a parent’s “temporary absence alone” does not show inability when the parent is unaware of the need and the child’s needs are otherwise met. A parent is temporarily absent when the parent’s unawareness of the emergency is short-lived, and no ongoing relationship is required (¶ 11). The court should have asked whether Father could give proper care in a timely way once informed, not whether DCFS knew of him earlier (¶ 11).

No relationship. Child had no unusual needs shown in the record and needed supervision and the necessities of life. If children’s needs can be met in foster care with strangers, Father was not “categorically unable” to meet them based solely on his lack of an ongoing relationship (¶ 12).

Pre-placement check. The assessment under Utah Code § 80-3-302(2), including the minimum steps in § 80-3-302(2)(c)(ii), does not render a parent unable to care. Otherwise all noncustodial parents would face dependency findings when children are removed from custodial parents (¶ 13). A noncustodial parent who can be located in relatively short order and is ready to take custody once the court makes the statutory findings can provide reasonable care in a timely way (¶ 13).

Takeaways

  • In a dependency adjudication as to a noncustodial parent, focus on the parent’s ability to give care in a timely way once informed, not on DCFS’s earlier knowledge of the parent (¶ 11).
  • The In re P.M. temporary-absence principle does not require an ongoing parent-child relationship (¶ 11).
  • Lack of a relationship alone did not establish inability to meet a child’s reasonable needs where no unusual needs were shown (¶ 12).
  • The need for the section 80-3-302(2) assessment does not itself support a dependency finding (¶ 13).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
In re E.D.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 126
Case no.
20260355-CA
Filed
2026
Decided
August 6, 2026
Opinion type
Per curiam
Disposition
Reversed
At stake
A juvenile court's adjudication that a thirteen-year-old child was dependent as to his father, who had no prior relationship with him.

The panel

John D. LuthyPer curiam
David N. MortensenPer curiam
Ryan D. TenneyPer curiam
Trial court
Third Juvenile Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Susan H. Eisenman

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Emily AdamsAllison Herr
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyDerek E. BrownJohn M. Peterson
Guardian ad litemOtherMartha PierceAlisha GilesHeath Haacke

Practice Tip

When defending a noncustodial parent against a dependency petition, build the record on how quickly the parent responded once informed and the parent's readiness to take custody after the section 80-3-302(2) assessment (¶¶ 11, 13).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.