Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Can grandparents adopt without showing termination is strictly necessary? Ross v. Kracht

2026 UT 22No. 20230389Decided Jul 29, 2026Juvenile & Child WelfareAffirmed

Holding

Termination of parental rights under Utah Code subsection 81-13-205(5)(e) incorporates the Termination Act’s requirement that termination be strictly necessary to promote the child’s best interest, but the district court’s failure to apply that analysis was harmless where unchallenged findings precluded alternatives such as a guardianship.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with the grandparents and upheld the end of both parents’ rights, even though it agreed with the parents on the legal rule.

  • When parental rights are ended as part of an adoption under the Utah Adoption Act’s Termination Provision, the court must find that ending them is strictly necessary for the child’s best interest.
  • That means the court must look at other options, such as a guardianship, and explain on the record why they would not protect the child as well.
  • Here the district court skipped that step, but its unchallenged findings showed the result would not have changed, so the termination was upheld.

What happened?

Denielle and Steven Kracht are the parents of two children, R.K. and J.K. The district court found a long history of drug use and danger to the children. In one incident Steven threw a car seat holding three-week-old R.K. across a yard, and in another he fired a gun into a wall after pointing it at Denielle and R.K. In 2017 both children tested positive for methamphetamines and amphetamines.

Julie and Gerald Ross, the children’s grandparents, have had full-time custody since July 2020. In 2022 they asked the district court to end both parents’ rights and let them adopt. After a one-day trial before the judge, the court ended the parents’ rights in March 2023.

What did each side argue?

The parents argued that before ending their rights, the court had to find that termination was “strictly necessary” for the children’s best interest. That test comes from a separate law, the Termination and Restoration of Parental Rights Act. It requires a court to ask whether something short of termination, like a guardianship (where someone else raises the child but the parent keeps some rights), would protect the child just as well.

The grandparents argued that this test applies only under the Termination Act, not in an adoption case under the Adoption Act. The district court never said whether the test applied, and its order did not mention it.

What did the court decide about the rule?

The Supreme Court agreed with the parents. The Adoption Act lets a court end a parent’s rights “on grounds described in” the Termination Act. The court read “described in” to include the language that comes right before the list of grounds, which contains the strictly necessary requirement.

The court also said a parent fighting an adoption is in much the same position as a parent facing a termination case, and both should face the same standard. So the district court erred by not doing this analysis.

Did the parents win, then?

No. An error is “harmless,” meaning it does not undo the decision, when there is no reasonable likelihood it changed the outcome. The parents did not challenge any of the district court’s findings.

Those findings said the parents were a danger to the children and that there was “no benefit and only potential danger” in further contact. The court found Denielle still struggled with drug use and had not protected the children from Steven. It found Steven had endangered R.K.’s life twice and missed or failed court-ordered visits in 2022. Given those findings, the Supreme Court held a guardianship would not have changed the result.

Did all the justices agree?

All five agreed the termination should be upheld. Associate Chief Justice Pohlman joined the harmless-error part but would not have decided whether the strictly necessary test applies, since the outcome was the same either way. She also pointed to a 2026 change to the Adoption Act that she thought could affect the question in a future case.

What happens now?

The termination of both parents’ rights stands, and the case does not go back to the district court.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Durrant, C.J., joined by Petersen and Nielsen, JJ., and Judge Luthy of the Court of Appeals, sitting by designation; Pohlman, A.C.J., concurring in part, dissenting in part, and concurring in judgment). The case came to the court on certification from the Court of Appeals (¶ 18). Termination under the Adoption Act’s Termination Provision requires a strictly necessary analysis (¶ 34). The district court’s failure to conduct one was error but harmless (¶ 46).

Issue 1: Strictly necessary analysis under the Adoption Act (correctness, ¶¶ 20–34): affirmed (harmless error)

Termination under Utah Code subsection 81-13-205(5)(e) requires a finding that termination is strictly necessary to promote the child’s best interest. The provision allows termination “on grounds described in” the Termination Act, and “described” most naturally takes in the qualifying language that precedes the grounds in section 80-4-301(1), including the strictly necessary requirement (¶¶ 24–28). Reading the two acts in harmony reinforces this. The court relied on In re Adoption of B.H., 2020 UT 64, ¶ 48, 474 P.3d 981, which held that “the same considerations apply whenever a termination is sought” (¶ 30). A parent contesting adoption under subsection (5)(e) stands largely in the same shoes as a parent in a Termination Act case (¶ 31).

The court rejected the grandparents’ surplusage argument. The Adoption Act’s own “best interests” language is a “point of emphasis,” following Meinhard v. State, 2016 UT 12, ¶ 31 n.5, 371 P.3d 37 (¶ 32). The grandparents’ reading would subject similarly situated parents to two standards depending on whether the petition is filed in juvenile or district court (¶ 33). The court chose to decide the question despite finding harmlessness because it was preserved, fully briefed and an open question (¶ 20).

Issue 2: Harmlessness of omitting the analysis (none stated, ¶¶ 35–46): affirmed (harmless error)

The district court erred by not making on-the-record findings about feasible alternatives, such as a guardianship, but there was no reasonable likelihood of a different outcome. The analysis requires exploring alternatives short of termination and finding on the record that none would equally protect the child, following In re B.T.B., 2020 UT 60, ¶ 67, 472 P.3d 827 (¶¶ 37–38). Harmlessness turns on whether the error “is sufficiently inconsequential that there is no reasonable likelihood that it affected the outcome,” quoting H.U.F. v. W.P.W., 2009 UT 10, ¶ 44, 203 P.3d 943 (¶ 39). The parents challenged none of the findings. Those findings, that the parents “constitute[d] a danger” and that further contact offered “no benefit and only potential danger,” effectively precluded a permanent custody and guardianship arrangement (¶¶ 40–41). Mother’s sobriety argument and Father’s claim that he could cooperate with the grandparents ignored those findings (¶¶ 42–45).

Separate opinion

Associate Chief Justice Pohlman joined Part II and the judgment but not Part I. She would not have decided whether subsection 81-13-205(5)(e) requires the analysis, because the harmless-error result would not change. She would also wait to interpret the provision until a case needs it, given the legislature’s 2026 amendment to subsection 81-13-202(1) (¶¶ 48–51).

Takeaways

  • In a contested adoption under subsection 81-13-205(5)(e), the petitioner must show statutory grounds and that termination is strictly necessary to promote the child’s best interest (¶ 36).
  • The order must address on the record why alternatives such as a guardianship would not equally protect the child; omitting this is error (¶¶ 37–38).
  • A parent who challenges only the missing analysis, and not the underlying findings, may lose on harmlessness when those findings rule out the alternatives (¶¶ 41, 46).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Ross v. Kracht
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2026 UT 22
Case no.
20230389
Filed
2023
Decided
July 29, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Kracht
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Termination of both parents' rights to their two children so the children's grandparents could adopt them

The panel

Matthew B. DurrantAuthor
Jill M. PohlmanConcurring in part, dissenting in part
John D. LuthyConcurred
NielsenConcurred
Paige PetersenConcurred
Trial court
Eighth District Court, Duchesne County · Judge Samuel P. Chiara

Parties & counsel

Kracht — AppellantIndividual(s)Emily AdamsAllison HerrAlexandra MareschalJason B. Richards
Ross — AppelleeIndividual(s)Taylor P. WebbErin B. Hull

Practice Tip

When a district court terminates rights in a contested adoption without the strictly necessary analysis, a parent who challenges only that omission, and not the court's findings, may lose on harmlessness if those findings rule out alternatives like guardianship (¶¶ 41, 46).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.