Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can alimony include my kids’ activity costs? Hensley v. Hensley

2026 UT App 172No. 20250255-CADecided Nov 13, 2026Family LawAffirmed

Holding

The trial court acted within its discretion in setting alimony, including counting extracurricular costs the parties’ own declarations listed, omitting a retirement line item the payor never requested, and limiting duration for the recipient’s fault, and in assigning each party the debt in their own name.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals upheld the divorce decree in full and rejected every challenge raised by the former husband and the former wife.

  • Children’s activity costs usually belong in child support, but a court may count them in alimony when the parties’ own financial declarations list them.
  • A judge who limits alimony because of one spouse’s affair does not have to cancel that out when the judge finds the other spouse’s claimed misconduct was not as serious as described.
  • A trial court has wide latitude to make each spouse pay the debts in their own name, especially when a claimed loan is poorly documented.

What happened?

Travis and Holli Hensley married in 2000. Holli filed for divorce in 2021 after Travis discovered she had been having an affair, and Travis filed his own divorce petition citing her infidelity. They have four children, one still a minor.

After a trial before a judge, the court found that Holli’s affair “substantially contributed to the breakdown” of the marriage. It ordered Travis to pay Holli alimony (ongoing support from one former spouse to the other) of $2,821 a month, plus $872 a month in child support. Because of Holli’s fault, the court limited alimony to nine years rather than the length of the marriage.

The court trimmed both parties’ claimed monthly budgets, finding they could not be kept up on the parties’ current incomes. It also made each party responsible for debt in their own name.

What did Travis argue?

Travis raised four complaints about alimony. He said the court should not have counted the child’s extracurricular costs, since those normally come out of child support. He said the court should have given him a monthly retirement savings amount like the one it gave Holli. He said matching some of his expenses to Holli’s punished him for her affair. And he objected to the court’s statement that alimony was needed to keep Holli and the child from becoming “public charges,” meaning dependent on public support.

What did the court decide on Travis’s appeal?

The Court of Appeals rejected each point. It reviewed for abuse of discretion, which means it would not step in unless the trial judge’s choice was outside the range of reasonable choices.

Extracurricular costs are presumed to be covered by child support, but that is only a presumption. Travis himself listed $50 a month for those costs and said the family spent $800 a month during the marriage, so the court could not fault the judge for “doing what the parties urged it to do.”

On retirement, Travis listed $0 for current contributions and never asked for a specific amount. Holli got one because she could not save during the divorce, while Travis could.

The trimmed budgets were based on the parties’ incomes, not on Holli’s fault. The court dealt with fault by shortening alimony. And the “public charges” remark only backed up an award the judge had already found proper.

What did the court decide on Holli’s cross-appeal?

Holli did not dispute the finding about her own fault. She argued that Travis’s conduct should cancel it out. But the trial judge heard her testimony about Travis and found the other problems “were not as serious or severe” as she claimed. The appeals court deferred to that finding.

On debt, the trial judge could not tell how much Holli owed her father or on what terms, since there was no written agreement. It instead valued the marital property at the date of the decree, which gave Holli the benefit of any growth in value to help pay her debts. The appeals court found no abuse of discretion.

What happens now?

Nothing changes. The divorce decree stands as written.

What should people take from this?

What a party puts in their own financial declarations can limit what they can argue later. And trial judges have wide room to decide alimony and divide debts.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Orme, J., joined by Harris and Tenney, JJ.). Travis appealed and Holli cross-appealed from a decree awarding Holli $2,821 a month in alimony for nine years, a duration the court shortened because of Holli’s fault (¶ 14). Every challenge failed under abuse-of-discretion review (¶¶ 16–17, 33).

Issue 1: Extracurricular costs in alimony (abuse of discretion, ¶ 16): affirmed (no error)

The court did not abuse its discretion by including the child’s extracurricular costs in both parties’ alimony budgets. Such costs are presumed to be covered by child support, Fox v. Fox, 2022 UT App 88, ¶ 28, 515 P.3d 481, but that is “only a presumption” (¶ 19, citing Bonham v. Bonham, 2026 UT App 141, ¶ 67). Travis listed a $50 line item in his final declaration and confirmed an $800 marital figure, so the court did what the parties urged (¶ 20, cf. Fox v. Fox, 2022 UT App 88, ¶ 30).

Issue 2: Payor’s retirement contribution (abuse of discretion, ¶ 16): affirmed (no error)

Omitting a retirement line item for Travis while allowing Holli $1,100 was within the court’s discretion. Travis’s final declaration listed “$0” and he never requested a specific amount at or after trial. Holli could not save during the divorce, while Travis could (¶ 22).

Issue 3: Mirrored expenses and standard of living (abuse of discretion, ¶ 16): affirmed (no error)

Equalizing some expenses did not penalize Travis for Holli’s fault. The court reduced both budgets because they could not be kept up on current incomes, did not tie the reductions to fault, and addressed fault by limiting duration to nine years (¶¶ 23–24, citing Jenkins v. Jenkins, 2026 UT App 86, ¶ 23, 593 P.3d 1193).

Issue 4: “Public charges” statement (abuse of discretion, ¶ 16): affirmed (no error)

The court’s statement that alimony was needed to keep Holli and the child from becoming public charges was not reversible error. The phrase invoked a purpose of alimony, Knight v. Knight, 2023 UT App 86, ¶ 29, 538 P.3d 601, and was used “loosely” to reinforce an award already found proper, not as an independent basis for it (¶ 26). The panel declined Travis’s request to adopt an objective public-charge test (¶¶ 25–26). See Petrzelka v. Goodwin, 2020 UT App 34, ¶ 42, 461 P.3d 1134.

Issue 5: Fault (abuse of discretion, ¶ 17): affirmed (no error)

The fault-based limit on alimony stands. Holli did not dispute the findings on her own fault and argued only that Travis’s conduct canceled it out (¶¶ 27, 29). The court considered her testimony about Travis but found his conduct “not as serious or severe” as claimed, a credibility call entitled to deference (¶ 29, citing Gardner v. Gardner, 2019 UT 61, ¶ 32, 452 P.3d 1134; see ¶ 28, Jenkins v. Jenkins, 2026 UT App 86, ¶ 40, 593 P.3d 1193).

Issue 6: Allocation of debt (abuse of discretion, ¶ 17): affirmed (no error)

Assigning each party the debt in their own name was within the court’s discretion. There is “no fixed formula” for dividing debts, Stonehocker v. Stonehocker, 2008 UT App 11, ¶ 46, 176 P.3d 476 (¶ 31). The court disallowed the claimed loan from Holli’s father for lack of a written agreement or terms, but valued the estate at the decree date to help her retire that debt (¶ 32).

Takeaways

  • A party’s own financial declaration can defeat a later objection to a line item the court adopted (¶¶ 20, 22).
  • Equalizing budgets for income reasons is distinct from penalizing fault; fault here was handled through duration (¶ 23).
  • A trial court’s “public charge” reference that merely reinforces an otherwise supported award is not reversible error (¶ 26).
  • Debt claims without documentation of amount and terms may be disallowed (¶ 32).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Hensley v. Hensley
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 172
Case no.
20250255-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
November 13, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Hensley · cross-appeal by Hensley
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Alimony of $2,821 per month for nine years, and whether the wife's debts, including a claimed $214,000 loan from her father, should be divided between the parties

The panel

Gregory K. OrmeAuthor
Ryan M. HarrisConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
Second District Court, Farmington Department · Judge Michael S. Edwards

Parties & counsel

Hensley — Appellant / Cross-appelleeIndividual(s)
Hensley — Appellee / Cross-appellantIndividual(s)Brian E. Arnold

Practice Tip

Make the financial declaration match the trial position: a party who lists an expense, or lists $0 and never asks for more, may be held to that figure on appeal (¶¶ 20, 22).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.