Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Does asking the judge to reconsider pause my time to appeal? Duran v. Baksh and John

2011 UT App 159No. 20101051-CADecided May 12, 2011Personal Injury & TortsDismissed

Holding

A motion to reconsider filed after an unsigned minute entry but before the final order is a prejudgment motion, not a rule 60(b) motion, and the final order of dismissal disposes of it, so the time for appeal runs from that order (Ron Shepard Insurance, Inc. v. Shields, 882 P.2d 650 (Utah 1994)).

Practice areaCivil Appeals

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the State Defendants and dismissed Duran’s appeal because he did not appeal on time from the final order.

  • A request to reconsider filed after an unsigned minute entry but before the final order is not a motion after judgment.
  • In this case, the final order dismissing the complaint also disposed of that earlier request, and the time to appeal began on the date of the final order.
  • A later ruling on the same request did not restart the time to appeal, so the court dismissed the appeal.

What happened?

John M. Duran sued Abdul M. Baksh and Meredith John, whom the court calls the State Defendants. They asked the district court to dismiss the complaint. They argued that Duran had not followed the notice of claim provisions of the Utah Governmental Immunity Act, the law that sets rules for suing government defendants.

On April 22, 2010, the court announced in an unsigned minute entry, a short note of its ruling, that it would grant the dismissal. It told the State Defendants’ lawyer to prepare a final order. On May 4, 2010, before any final order, Duran filed a motion asking for relief and reconsideration.

On May 26, 2010, the court entered its Ruling and Order of Dismissal with Prejudice. Dismissal with prejudice means the case cannot be filed again. Duran did not file a timely notice of appeal from that order.

In December 2010, the court denied Duran’s reconsideration motion in another minute entry. It said the motion only raised matters it had already decided on May 26, 2010.

What did each side argue?

The State Defendants asked the Court of Appeals to dismiss the appeal because it came too late. Duran asked the court to strike their motion.

What did the court decide?

The court denied Duran’s motion to strike and granted the State Defendants’ motion.

It explained that the April 22 minute entry was not a final judgment. So Duran’s motion was not a proper request under rule 60(b) of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure, which covers relief from a final judgment. It was a request to reconsider made before judgment.

Relying on Ron Shepard Insurance, Inc. v. Shields, 882 P.2d 650 (Utah 1994), the court said a trial judge is free to reassess its decision until a final order is entered. When the district court dismissed the case on May 26, 2010, that order also disposed of Duran’s request to reconsider. The December minute entry said the same thing.

That meant Duran’s time to appeal began on May 26, 2010. Because he did not appeal on time from that order, the Court of Appeals had no jurisdiction, meaning no legal power to hear the appeal.

What happens now?

The appeal is dismissed. The court did not decide whether the district court was right to dismiss Duran’s complaint. It also said it did not need to consider its own motion to dismiss the appeal.

What should people take from this?

In this case, a request to reconsider filed before the final order did not keep the appeal deadline open. The final order disposed of the request, and the time to appeal ran from that order. A later ruling denying the same request did not change the date.

Bottom line

Appeal dismissed for lack of jurisdiction (per curiam; Davis, P.J., McHugh, A.P.J., and Thorne, J.). Duran moved for reconsideration after an unsigned minute entry announced the dismissal of his complaint but before the final order was entered. The final Ruling and Order of Dismissal with Prejudice, entered May 26, 2010, also disposed of that prejudgment motion. The time for appeal therefore ran from May 26, 2010, and Duran did not appeal on time (¶ 6).

The court denied Duran’s motion to strike the State Defendants’ motion for summary disposition (¶ 1).

Issue 1: Timeliness of the appeal (none stated, ¶¶ 4–6): the State Defendants’ motion for summary disposition granted

The court lacked jurisdiction because Duran did not timely appeal from the May 26, 2010 final order. The April 22, 2010 unsigned minute entry directed preparation of a further order, so it was not a final judgment (¶ 4, citing Utah R. Civ. P. 54(b)). Rule 60(b) reaches only a “final judgment, order, or proceeding.” Duran’s May 4 motion was therefore a prejudgment motion seeking reconsideration, not a rule 60(b) motion (¶ 4).

Under Ron Shepard Insurance, Inc. v. Shields, 882 P.2d 650 (Utah 1994), such a motion is reargument the trial court may consider any time before final judgment (¶ 5, citing id. at 653-54). See also Gillett v. Price, 2006 UT 24, ¶ 7 n.2, 135 P.3d 861 (¶ 5). The final order of dismissal therefore disposed of the motion. The December 2010 minute entry confirmed this when it said the motion raised only matters decided on May 26 (¶ 6). Citing Varian-Eimac, Inc. v. Lamoreaux, 767 P.2d 569, 570 (Utah Ct. App. 1989), the court dismissed the appeal (¶ 6).

Not reached

The court found it unnecessary to consider its own sua sponte motion for summary disposition (¶ 1). Because it lacked jurisdiction, it did not review the dismissal under the Governmental Immunity Act.

Takeaways

  • A motion to reconsider filed after an unsigned minute entry that directs a further order, but before that order is entered, is a prejudgment motion and not a rule 60(b) motion (¶ 4).
  • The final order disposing of all claims also disposes of a pending prejudgment motion to reconsider, and the appeal time runs from that order (¶ 6).
  • A later minute entry denying the same motion did not restart the appeal clock (¶¶ 3, 6).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Duran v. Baksh and John
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 159
Case no.
20101051-CA
Filed
2010
Decided
May 12, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Duran
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
Dismissal with prejudice of Duran's complaint against the State Defendants for failure to comply with the notice of claim provisions of the Utah Governmental Immunity Act.

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
William A. Thorne Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Second District Court, Farmington Department · Judge Glen R. Dawson

Parties & counsel

Duran — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Baksh and John — AppelleeGovernment agencyMark L. ShurtleffPeggy E. Stone

Practice Tip

If a reconsideration motion is pending when the final order is entered, measure the appeal deadline from the final order, not from any later ruling on the motion (¶ 6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.