Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I win because the company’s affidavits didn’t deny my story? Barnhart v. Labor Commission

2011 UT App 87No. 20110071-CADecided Mar 24, 2011Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

A challenge not raised in a motion for review before the Labor Commission is waived under Esquivel v. Labor Comm’n, 2000 UT 66, ¶ 34, 7 P.3d 777, and a party opposing summary judgment cannot rely on the movant’s affidavits’ failure to deny its account but must set forth specific facts under Utah R. Civ. P. 56(e).

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with Orson H. Gygi Co. and left the Labor Commission’s dismissal of Barnhart’s charges in place.

  • An objection not raised in the person’s request for review by the Labor Commission is generally treated as given up and will not be considered on appeal.
  • A party opposing summary judgment must answer the other side’s evidence with specific facts, not just its own allegations.
  • The other side’s affidavits do not have to deny the opposing party’s version of events.

What happened?

Donald Allen Barnhart filed discrimination and retaliation charges against Orson H. Gygi Co. (Gygi) with the Labor Commission, the state agency that hears these charges. An administrative law judge (ALJ), the agency’s hearing officer, dismissed the charges on summary judgment. Summary judgment means a case is decided without a hearing because there is no real dispute about the important facts.

The Labor Commission upheld the dismissal. Barnhart, who represented himself, asked the Utah Court of Appeals to review the Commission’s order. The court took up the case on its own motion for “summary disposition,” a quick ruling used when an appeal raises no substantial question.

What did Barnhart argue?

He made two arguments. First, he said the ALJ was wrong to hold that his fraud, perjury, and misrepresentation claims were outside the Labor Commission’s power to decide. Second, he said that “non-denials” in Gygi’s affidavits (sworn written statements) were enough to support his claims.

What did the court decide about the fraud claims?

The court would not consider this argument. When Barnhart asked the Labor Commission to review the ALJ’s decision, he objected to several statements in it, but he never mentioned the ruling on his fraud-related claims.

The court explained that objections not raised in the agency proceeding are generally “considered waived,” meaning given up. It relied on Esquivel v. Labor Comm’n, 2000 UT 66, ¶ 34, 7 P.3d 777.

What about the affidavits that did not deny his story?

The court held that Barnhart misunderstood his burden. Once Gygi supported its request for summary judgment with affidavits, Barnhart could not just rest on his own allegations. He had to respond with specific facts showing a real dispute that needed a hearing.

Gygi’s affidavits set out facts about Barnhart’s work performance and the reason for his termination. The court said those affidavits were not meant to, and did not have to, deny Barnhart’s version of events. It also noted that Gygi’s first response to Barnhart’s claims had specifically denied his factual allegations, so there was no blanket “non-denial.”

Barnhart offered no real evidence of his own, only his own unsupported allegations and conclusions. The court held that was not enough to defeat summary judgment.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The court affirmed, so the Labor Commission’s order dismissing the charges stands.

What should people take from this?

When asking an agency to review a hearing officer’s decision, every objection a person wants a court to consider later should be raised at that stage. And when the other side asks for summary judgment backed by evidence, the person opposing it must point to specific facts, not to what the other side failed to deny.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, P.J., Voros and Roth, JJ.) on the court’s own motion for summary disposition for lack of a substantial question (¶¶ 1, 5). Barnhart, pro se, sought review of the Labor Commission’s order affirming the dismissal of his discrimination and retaliation charges against Orson H. Gygi Co. (Gygi), the respondent. One argument was waived (¶ 2); the other failed because Barnhart did not meet his burden under rule 56(e) (¶¶ 3–4).

Issue 1: Jurisdiction over fraud, perjury, and misrepresentation claims (none stated, ¶ 2): not reached

Barnhart waived his challenge to the ALJ’s ruling that these claims were outside the Labor Commission’s jurisdiction. His motion for review to the Commission took issue with several statements in the ALJ’s decision but did not identify this jurisdictional issue (¶ 2). Under Esquivel v. Labor Comm’n, 2000 UT 66, ¶ 34, 7 P.3d 777, objections not raised in the agency proceeding are “considered waived and will not be considered by a court on review” (¶ 2).

Issue 2: “Non-denials” in Gygi’s affidavits (none stated, ¶¶ 3–4): affirmed (no error)

Barnhart did not meet his burden to show a genuine issue of material fact. Under Utah R. Civ. P. 56(e), once a motion is supported by affidavits, the adverse party “may not rest upon the mere allegations or denials of the pleadings” and must set forth specific facts (¶ 3). “A party disputing a summary judgment motion has the burden of disputing the motion with material facts.” Overstock.com v. SmartBargains, Inc., 2008 UT 55, ¶ 16, 192 P.3d 858 (¶ 3). Gygi’s affidavits set out affirmative facts about Barnhart’s work performance and the reason for his termination; they were not meant to, and were not obligated to, deny his version of events (¶ 4). The court added that Gygi’s initial response to Barnhart’s statement of claims specifically denied the factual allegations, so there was no blanket “non-denial” (¶ 4 n.1). Barnhart relied only on his own unsubstantiated allegations and conclusions, which is insufficient (¶ 4).

Takeaways

  • In Labor Commission proceedings, an issue omitted from the motion for review is waived on judicial review (¶ 2).
  • A movant’s affidavits need only set out affirmative facts; they need not rebut the nonmovant’s account (¶ 4).
  • The nonmovant must respond to supported summary judgment evidence with specific facts; unsubstantiated allegations and conclusions do not suffice (¶¶ 3–4).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Barnhart v. Labor Commission
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 87
Case no.
20110071-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
March 24, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Barnhart
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Barnhart's discrimination and retaliation charges against Orson H. Gygi Co., dismissed on summary judgment by the Labor Commission

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Utah Labor Commission

Parties & counsel

Barnhart — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Labor Commission — AppelleeOtherJames W. Stewart

Practice Tip

When seeking Labor Commission review of an ALJ decision, identify every ruling to be challenged in the motion for review, because omitted objections are waived on judicial review (¶ 2).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.