Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

If I ask the agency to reconsider, can I still go to court? Rathmann v. Labor Commission

2011 UT App 110No. 20110076-CADecided Apr 7, 2011Employment & Workers' CompensationDismissed

Holding

Because Rathmann’s request for reconsideration of the Labor Commission’s order remained pending, there was no final agency action under Utah Code Ann. § 63G-4-401, and the court lacked jurisdiction over his petition for review, which it dismissed without prejudice (following Maverik Country Stores v. Industrial Comm’n, 860 P.2d 944, 951 (Utah Ct. App. 1993)).

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals dismissed Rathmann’s petition without deciding it because his request for reconsideration was still pending before the Labor Commission.

  • Once a person asks the Labor Commission to reconsider an order, they must wait for the Commission to rule on that request before asking a court to review the order.
  • A petition filed while reconsideration is still pending is dismissed because the court lacks jurisdiction.
  • This dismissal was without prejudice, so Rathmann may file a new petition after a final order is entered.

What happened?

John Rathmann had a claim for benefits before the Labor Commission. His claim was dismissed without prejudice, which means it was not decided for good and could be brought again. The Commission issued an order affirming that dismissal on December 27, 2010.

On January 18, 2011, Rathmann asked the Commission to reconsider its order. Six days later, on January 24, 2011, he asked the Utah Court of Appeals to review the order. He represented himself. The other parties were the Labor Commission, Haliburton Energy Services and ACE Property and Casualty Insurance.

Why did the court look at this on its own?

The court first took up the case on its own motion for summary disposition. That is a quick way to resolve a case when there is no substantial question to review. After looking at the record, the court saw a bigger problem: it did not have jurisdiction, meaning legal power, to hear the petition at all.

What did the court decide?

It dismissed the petition. Courts may review only “final agency actions.” Asking the agency to reconsider is optional. But once a person asks, they have to see that process through before going to court.

The court relied on an earlier decision, Maverik Country Stores v. Industrial Comm’n, 860 P.2d 944, 951 (Utah Ct. App. 1993). That case said a person who asks for reconsideration “no longer has a ‘final agency action’” to appeal from, and cannot go to court “until the agency acts on the request.”

Rathmann’s request for reconsideration was still pending, so the Commission’s order was not yet final.

What happens now?

The dismissal is without prejudice. Rathmann may file a new petition for review after the Commission enters a final order. The court did not decide anything about whether his benefits claim should succeed.

What should people take from this?

Asking an agency to reconsider and asking a court for review happen one after the other, not at the same time. When a reconsideration request is filed with the Labor Commission, a court will not review the order until the Commission has ruled on that request.

Bottom line

Petition dismissed without prejudice (per curiam; Davis, P.J., and Voros and Roth, JJ.). The court took up the petition on its own motion for summary disposition for lack of a substantial question. After reviewing the record, it concluded instead that it lacked jurisdiction, because Rathmann’s request that the Labor Commission reconsider its order was still pending (¶¶ 1–2).

Issue 1: Jurisdiction over the petition for review (none stated, ¶¶ 2–3): not reached

Acting on its own motion, the court held it lacked jurisdiction to review the Labor Commission’s order while Rathmann’s request for reconsideration remained pending, and it dismissed the petition. The Commission issued its order on December 27, 2010. Rathmann sought reconsideration on January 18, 2011, and petitioned for review on January 24, 2011 (¶ 2). Judicial review lies only from final agency action, and administrative remedies must be exhausted first, under Utah Code Ann. § 63G-4-401 (¶ 3). Reconsideration is optional under § 63G-4-302(1)(b). But once a party seeks it, the party must follow it through before seeking judicial review, as the court held in Maverik Country Stores v. Industrial Comm’n, 860 P.2d 944, 951 (Utah Ct. App. 1993). Footnote 11 of that opinion explains that the party “no longer has a ‘final agency action’” until the agency acts (¶ 3). The merits of the benefits claim were not reached.

Disposition

Dismissed without prejudice to filing a petition for review after a final order is entered (¶ 4).

Takeaways

  • A pending request for reconsideration before the Labor Commission defeats appellate jurisdiction over a petition for review filed in the meantime (¶¶ 2–3).
  • Reconsideration is optional, but once a party requests it, the party must wait for the agency to act before petitioning (¶ 3).
  • The court may raise the jurisdictional defect on its own, even when it first took up the case on its own motion for summary disposition on other grounds (¶ 1).
  • Dismissal on this ground is without prejudice to a later petition from a final order (¶ 4).

Case details

Case name
Rathmann v. Labor Commission
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 110
Case no.
20110076-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
April 7, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Rathmann
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
Rathmann's claim for benefits before the Labor Commission, which was dismissed without prejudice

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Utah Labor Commission

Parties & counsel

Rathmann — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Labor Commission — AppelleeOtherMark D. DeanKristy L. Bertelsen

Practice Tip

If a client has asked the Labor Commission to reconsider an order, the court held that a petition for review must wait until the Commission acts on that request; a petition filed earlier will be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction (¶¶ 2–3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.