Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I challenge my workers’ comp medical exam for the first time on appeal? French v. Labor Commission

2011 UT App 120No. 20100456-CADecided Apr 14, 2011Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

A claimant who only generally disagreed with medical examinations before the Labor Commission waived her challenge to how they were performed, see Esquivel v. Labor Comm’n., 2000 UT 66, ¶ 34, 7 P.3d 777, and a thorough medical panel report finding no work causation was substantial evidence supporting the Commission’s denial of additional benefits.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals upheld the Labor Commission’s denial of additional workers’ compensation benefits to Cyndi French.

  • The court would not consider objections to the medical examinations that French first raised on appeal.
  • Saying in general that you disagree with a medical exam’s conclusions is not the same as arguing that the exam was done improperly.
  • A thorough medical panel report finding that the symptoms were not work-related was enough to support the Commission’s decision.

What happened?

Cyndi French worked for Advanta Bank Corp. until 2009, when she was laid off in a large reduction in force. She sought additional workers’ compensation benefits, arguing that her continuing symptoms of overuse syndrome were caused by that job.

The Labor Commission, the state agency that decides workers’ compensation claims, affirmed the denial of additional benefits. French, who represented herself, asked the Utah Court of Appeals to review the Commission’s final order. The other side was the Commission, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. (as receiver for Advanta Bank Corp.), and Pacific Employers Insurance Company.

What did French argue?

She made two arguments. First, she said two independent physical examinations done during the case were not good enough because neither used X-rays or MRIs to check for physical damage. Second, she said evidence in the record contradicted the Commission’s findings.

Why didn’t the court consider the X-ray and MRI argument?

As a general rule, objections not raised before the agency are treated as given up and will not be considered by a court on review. French raised this complaint for the first time in the Court of Appeals, so the court declined to address it.

The court noted that, before the Commission, French had expressed general disagreement with the exams’ conclusions. But she never claimed the exams were not properly performed. To keep an issue alive for appeal, a party must raise that specific issue in the earlier proceedings.

What about the evidence?

The court will undo an agency’s factual findings only if they are not supported by “substantial evidence,” meaning enough evidence that a reasonable person could accept it as support. After reviewing the record, the court said it was clear that standard was met.

A medical panel had concluded that French’s symptoms were not caused by her employment. The court described the panel’s report as thorough, well reasoned and clear about its basis and conclusions. That report supported the Commission’s findings, even though French pointed to other evidence.

What happens now?

Nothing more. The court affirmed the Commission’s order, so the denial of additional benefits stands. The case was not sent back.

What should people take from this?

In a workers’ compensation case, specific objections to how a medical exam was done need to be made before the Commission, not saved for the appeal. And when a medical panel’s report is thorough and clear, the fact that other evidence points the other way does not mean the court will overturn the Commission’s findings.

Bottom line

Affirmed, per curiam (Davis, P.J., McHugh, A.P.J., and Voros, J.) (¶ 4). French, a pro se petitioner, sought review of the Labor Commission’s final order affirming the denial of additional benefits for overuse syndrome she attributed to her employment with Advanta Bank Corp. (¶ 1). Her objections to the medical examinations were unpreserved (¶ 2), and the medical panel report was substantial evidence for the Commission’s findings (¶ 3).

Issue 1: Adequacy of the independent medical examinations (none stated, ¶ 2): not reached

The court would not consider French’s claim that two independent physical examinations were insufficient for lack of X-rays or MRIs, because she raised it for the first time on review. Objections not raised before the agency are “considered waived and will not be considered by a court on review,” quoting Esquivel v. Labor Comm’n., 2000 UT 66, ¶ 34, 7 P.3d 777 (¶ 2). In the agency proceedings French expressed general disagreement with the exams’ conclusions but never asserted the exams were improperly performed. An issue must be specifically raised to be preserved, see 438 Main St. v. Easy Heat, Inc., 2004 UT 72, ¶ 51, 99 P.3d 801 (¶ 2 n.1).

Issue 2: Substantial evidence for the Commission’s findings (substantial evidence, ¶ 3): affirmed (no error)

Substantial evidence supports the Commission’s findings. The medical panel concluded French’s symptoms were not caused by her employment, and the court called its report “thorough, well-reasoned, and clear regarding its basis and conclusions” (¶ 3). Contrary evidence in the record did not change the result under the deferential standard (¶ 3).

Not reached

The examination-adequacy objections were waived as unpreserved (¶ 2 & n.1).

Takeaways

  • General disagreement with a medical examination’s conclusions does not preserve a challenge to how the examination was performed (¶ 2 n.1).
  • Objections not raised in the agency proceeding are treated as waived on review of a Labor Commission order (¶ 2).
  • A thorough, well-reasoned medical panel report can by itself supply substantial evidence for causation findings, despite contrary record evidence (¶ 3).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
French v. Labor Commission
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 120
Case no.
20100456-CA
Filed
2010
Decided
April 14, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
French
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Additional workers' compensation benefits for overuse syndrome symptoms French attributed to her employment with Advanta Bank Corp.

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Utah Labor Commission

Parties & counsel

French — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Labor Commission — AppelleeOtherEric K. Jenkins

Practice Tip

In a Labor Commission proceeding, object specifically to how a medical examination was performed (for example, the lack of imaging); general disagreement with its conclusions does not preserve that challenge for review (¶ 2 n.1).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.