Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Is it fraud to claim unemployment if I can’t work full-time? Frislie v. Department of Workforce Services

2011 UT App 114No. 20110080-CADecided Apr 14, 2011Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

Substantial evidence supported the Workforce Board of Appeals’s fraud finding under Utah Admin. Code R994-406-401. The claimant reported that she was able and available for full-time work despite medical conditions she knew limited her ability to work, and she was chargeable with the Claimant Guide’s instructions to report them.

Key takeaways

The Department of Workforce Services won, and the Court of Appeals upheld the finding that Frislie committed unemployment benefits fraud.

  • To get unemployment benefits in Utah, a claimant must be able and available for full-time work each week claimed.
  • Reporting that you can work full-time when a medical condition prevents it can support a fraud finding, even if you are actively applying for jobs.
  • The fraud rule used here does not require proof that the claimant specifically meant to cheat.

What happened?

Kathleen Frislie collected unemployment benefits. When she filed her claims, she said she was able and available for full-time work and that no condition kept her from accepting it.

At a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge, Frislie admitted that, although she was actively applying for jobs, she was not physically capable of doing the work those jobs would require. The Workforce Board of Appeals (the agency board that reviews these decisions) found that she had committed fraud. Frislie asked the Utah Court of Appeals to review that decision.

Why does a fraud finding matter?

Under Utah law, a claimant who gets benefits through false information must pay them back. On top of that, the claimant owes a civil penalty equal to the benefits obtained through the fraud. The court noted that the Board has no power to reduce or waive that penalty once fraud is shown.

What did Frislie argue?

She argued there was not substantial evidence (enough evidence that a reasonable person could rely on it) to support the fraud finding. She also said she did not knowingly submit incorrect information.

What did the court decide?

The court affirmed the Board’s decision. It explained that an agency’s findings stand if enough evidence supports them, even if someone could reach a different conclusion from the same evidence.

Under the Department’s rules, fraud has three parts, and the court found evidence for each:

  • Materiality. The false statement mattered because it got her benefits she was not entitled to. Frislie said she could work full-time when she could not, and she did not tell the Department of Workforce Services about her limits.
  • Knowledge. This means she knew, or should have known, the information was wrong. The Claimant Guide told claimants they must be physically and mentally able to work full-time and must report whether they are. The Board found she knew she had several medical conditions that limited her ability to work. The court said she was responsible for what the guide told her.
  • Willfulness. Under the rule, this is shown simply by filing claims that contain false statements. Frislie filed claims with false information about her ability to work.

The court also pointed out that the rule does not require proof that the claimant specifically intended to cheat.

How did the case get decided?

The court decided the case on its own motion for summary disposition, a short-form ruling without full proceedings. The decision was issued “per curiam,” meaning by the panel as a whole rather than by one named judge.

What happens now?

The Board’s January 20, 2011 decision stands. Nothing goes back to the agency.

What should people take from this?

Looking for work is not the same as being able to do it. A person claiming benefits must answer honestly about whether they can work full-time. Under this decision, a claimant is expected to know what the Claimant Guide says.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, McHugh and Voros, JJ.), on the court’s sua sponte motion for summary disposition (¶ 1). Substantial evidence supported each element of fraud under Utah Admin. Code R994-406-401, so the Board’s January 20, 2011 decision stands (¶¶ 6–9).

Issue 1: Substantial evidence for the fraud finding (mixed, ¶ 2): affirmed (no error)

The Board’s finding that Frislie committed fraud was supported by substantial evidence on materiality, knowledge and willfulness. The court stated two standards. Findings of fact stand if based on substantial evidence, citing Hurley v. Board of Review of Indus. Comm’n, 767 P.2d 524, 526-27 (Utah 1988). The Board’s application of law stands unless it “exceeds the bounds of reasonableness and rationality,” citing Johnson v. Department of Emp’t Sec., 782 P.2d 965, 968 (Utah Ct. App. 1989) (¶ 2).

Framework. A claimant who obtains benefits on false information must repay them under Utah Code § 35A-4-405(c). The claimant also owes a civil penalty equal to the benefits obtained “by direct reason of his fraud” under § 35A-4-405(5)(c)(ii). The Board has no discretion to reduce or waive that penalty (¶ 3, citing Utah Admin. Code R994-406-403(1)). Fraud requires materiality, knowledge and willfulness, and no specific intent to defraud is required (¶ 4, citing R994-406-401). Eligibility requires that the claimant be able and available for work each week claimed, and for full-time work (¶ 5, citing Utah Code § 35A-4-403(1)(c) and R994-403-112c(1)).

Materiality. Frislie reported she was able and available for full-time work. At the ALJ hearing, she admitted that, although she was applying for jobs, she was not physically capable of doing the work. She received benefits she was not entitled to (¶ 6).

Knowledge. Frislie was chargeable with the Claimant Guide, which requires claimants to be physically and mentally able to work full-time and to report whether they are. The Board found she knew of medical conditions limiting her ability to work, and she should have known from the guide that she had to report them (¶ 7).

Willfulness. Filing claims that contained false information established willfulness. The court noted the Board found clear and convincing evidence on this element (¶ 8).

Takeaways

  • Under R994-406-401(3), the fraud penalty requires no specific intent to defraud. Materiality, knowledge and willfulness are enough (¶ 4).
  • A claimant is chargeable with the Claimant Guide’s instructions, which supports the “should have known” form of knowledge (¶ 7).
  • Actively applying for jobs does not cure a false report of being able to work full-time when the claimant admits being physically incapable of the work (¶ 6).
  • Once fraud is shown, the Board cannot reduce or waive the penalty (¶ 3).
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Frislie v. Department of Workforce Services
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 114
Case no.
20110080-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
April 14, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A Board finding of unemployment benefits fraud, which carries repayment of benefits received and a civil fraud penalty

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Workforce Board of Appeals

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyAmanda B. McPeck

Practice Tip

In contesting an unemployment fraud finding, a lack of intent to defraud is not a defense under R994-406-401(3). A claimant is also chargeable with what the Claimant Guide tells claimants to report (¶¶ 4, 7).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.