Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Is reporting net pay instead of gross pay benefits fraud? Morris v. WFSV

2012 UT App 361No. 20120698-CADecided Dec 20, 2012Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

Substantial evidence supported the Board’s determination that the claimant fraudulently obtained benefits under Utah Admin. Code R994-406-401, and the Board properly declined to consider evidence that was reasonably available at the ALJ hearing under Utah Admin. Code R994-508-305.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the Department of Workforce Services and left the fraud determination against Morris in place.

  • A claimant must report all gross earnings for the week the work is done, even before being paid, as the Claimant Guide instructs.
  • Fraud under the Department’s rule requires materiality, knowledge and willfulness, but no specific intent to defraud.
  • The Board will not consider new evidence that was reasonably available at the hearing unless there are unusual or extraordinary circumstances.

What happened?

Russell Morris received benefits from the Department of Workforce Services, the state agency on the other side of this case. The Workforce Board of Appeals (the Board), which hears appeals within the Department, decided that he had fraudulently obtained benefits to which he was not entitled.

Morris asked the Utah Court of Appeals to review the Board’s July 20, 2012 decision. He represented himself. The court took up the case on its own motion for summary disposition, a quick ruling without full proceedings.

What did Morris argue?

He made two arguments. First, he challenged the finding that he committed fraud. Second, he argued the Board was wrong to refuse new evidence, including bank records, that he had not given to the administrative law judge (the hearing officer who first heard his case).

Was the fraud finding supported?

Yes. The court asked whether “substantial evidence” supported the Board, meaning enough evidence that a reasonable decision-maker could rely on it, even if another conclusion was possible.

The Claimant Guide tells claimants to report all gross earnings (pay before deductions) for the week the work is done, whether or not they have been paid yet. Claimants are held to what the guide says, as the court noted, citing Frislie v. Department of Workforce Servs., 2011 UT App 114, ¶ 7, 256 P.3d 229.

Under the Department’s rule, fraud needs three things: materiality, knowledge and willfulness. No specific intent to defraud is required. The court found all three supported:

  • Materiality: Morris did not report working when he worked, reported net pay instead of gross pay, and chose to report his earnings when he felt it was appropriate.
  • Knowledge: based on the Claimant Guide, he knew or should have known he had to report work when it was performed and to report gross earnings.
  • Willfulness: he chose to answer the Department’s questions inaccurately and filed claims with false statements or omissions.

Could Morris add new evidence on appeal?

No. Before his hearing, the Department told Morris the hearing would be his only chance to present evidence. The Board’s rule says it will not consider new evidence that was reasonably available at the time of the hearing, unless there are unusual or extraordinary circumstances.

His bank records were available at the time of the hearing. He gave no reason for not presenting them and did not claim any special circumstances. So the court held he had not shown the Board erred.

What happens now?

The court declined to disturb the Board’s decision, so the fraud determination stands.

What should people take from this?

This decision shows how the court applied the Department’s reporting rules to one claimant. It treated reporting net pay, and reporting work late, as supporting a fraud finding. It also shows that the hearing before the administrative law judge is the place to present evidence.

Bottom line

Board decision left in place (per curiam; Davis, McHugh and Voros, JJ.), decided on the court’s sua sponte motion for summary disposition (¶ 1). Substantial evidence supported the Board’s determination that Morris, who appeared pro se, fraudulently obtained benefits (¶¶ 3–7), and the Board did not err in excluding evidence he never offered to the ALJ (¶¶ 8–9). The court “decline[d] to disturb” the July 20, 2012 decision (¶ 10).

Issue 1: Fraud determination (mixed, ¶¶ 2–7): affirmed (no error)

Substantial evidence supported each element of fraud. The court stated two standards: findings stand if supported by substantial evidence, and the Board’s application of law to facts stands unless it exceeds the bounds of reasonableness and rationality (¶ 2). The Claimant Guide requires reporting gross earnings for the week the work is performed, regardless of when paid, and claimants are held to the guide, following Frislie v. Department of Workforce Servs., 2011 UT App 114, ¶ 7, 256 P.3d 229 (¶ 3). Under Utah Admin. Code R994-406-401, fraud requires materiality, knowledge and willfulness, with no specific intent to defraud (¶ 4).

  • Materiality: Morris failed to report working during the period he worked, reported net rather than gross earnings, and reported earnings when he felt it appropriate (¶ 5).
  • Knowledge: under the Claimant Guide he knew or should have known to report work when performed and to report gross earnings (¶ 6).
  • Willfulness: he elected to answer the Department’s questions inaccurately and filed claims with false statements, responses or deliberate omissions (¶ 7).

Issue 2: New evidence before the Board (none stated, ¶¶ 8–9): affirmed (no error)

Morris failed to show the Board erred by excluding his new evidence, including bank records. The Department’s hearing instructions told him the ALJ hearing was his only chance to present evidence and later appeals would be limited to that record (¶ 8). Under Utah Admin. Code R994-508-305, the Board will not consider evidence reasonably available at the ALJ hearing absent unusual or extraordinary circumstances; Morris offered no explanation and asserted no extenuating circumstances (¶ 9).

Takeaways

  • Fraud under R994-406-401 needs no specific intent to defraud; materiality, knowledge and willfulness suffice (¶ 4).
  • Reporting net instead of gross earnings, and reporting work when the claimant felt it appropriate rather than when performed, supported the fraud elements here (¶¶ 5–7).
  • Evidence reasonably available at the ALJ hearing will not be considered by the Board absent unusual or extraordinary circumstances, so the claimant must explain any omission (¶ 9).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Morris v. WFSV
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 361
Case no.
20120698-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
December 20, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
The Board's determination that Morris fraudulently obtained benefits to which he was not entitled.

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Workforce Board of Appeals

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyAmanda B. McPeck

Practice Tip

Present all available evidence, such as bank records, at the ALJ hearing; the Board will not take evidence that was reasonably available then unless the claimant shows unusual or extraordinary circumstances (¶ 9).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.