Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I get unemployment if I’m fired for fixing fees on my own bank account? Nicol v. WFSV

2012 UT App 360No. 20120176-CADecided Dec 20, 2012Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

The Workforce Appeals Board reasonably found culpability for a just-cause discharge where a bank employee deliberately reversed fees on her own account in breach of a known policy after a supervisor’s warning, and her balancing-test argument was not timely presented to the Board and would fail on the merits anyway.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Workforce Appeals Board and left the denial of Ranae Nicol’s unemployment benefits in place.

  • A worker fired for “just cause” cannot get unemployment benefits, and one part of just cause is that the conduct was serious enough to threaten the employer’s legitimate interests.
  • Arguments not presented to the Workforce Appeals Board in time are generally treated as given up, and a request for reconsideration is limited to a change in conditions or a mistake about the facts.
  • Here, a good but short work record did not outweigh a deliberate breach of a known bank policy.

What happened?

Ranae Nicol worked at a bank. Bank policy barred employees from handling transactions on their own accounts, and the handbook said breaking that rule could mean immediate firing. Nicol knew the policy.

She believed some fees on an account she shared with her son were a mistake. She asked a supervisor, who told her that if she reversed the fees, she would do so at her own risk. She reversed them anyway. A routine audit caught it, she admitted it was a mistake, and the bank fired her.

Why was she denied unemployment?

Under Utah law, a person fired for “just cause” cannot get unemployment benefits. Just cause has three parts: culpability (the conduct was serious), knowledge (the worker knew the rule), and control (the worker could have avoided the conduct).

The Workforce Appeals Board, the agency body that hears unemployment appeals, found all three. Nicol challenged only culpability.

What did Nicol argue?

She argued the Board should have used a balancing test, weighing her side (her work record, how long she worked there, and whether it would happen again) against how serious the conduct was and the bank’s interests.

What did the court decide?

The court gave two reasons for rejecting her argument.

First, the argument came too late. Nicol appealed on time to the Board but did not file her supporting memorandum on time, so the Board decided her appeal without it. She then attached it to a request for reconsideration. Reconsideration is limited to a change in conditions or a mistake about the facts, and her argument was neither. Issues not raised before the agency are generally treated as given up.

Second, even if the court considered the argument, the balance did not favor her. She had worked there just over a year and had a good record. But she broke a known rule on purpose after being warned, in a job that gave her access to accounts and funds. The court said this did not look like a “good faith error in judgment.”

The court asks only whether the Board’s decision was reasonable and rational. It found that it was.

What happens now?

Nothing more happens in this case. The Board’s decision stands, and Nicol remains ineligible for benefits.

What should people take from this?

For this kind of misconduct, a short, positive work history did not outweigh deliberately breaking a known policy after a warning. The case also shows that missing a filing deadline before the Board can keep an argument from being heard later.

Bottom line

Board decision affirmed (“we decline to disturb the Board’s decision”) (per curiam; Orme, Davis, and Christiansen, JJ.). Nicol reversed fees on an account she shared with her son, in breach of a known policy and after a supervisor’s warning (¶ 5). She challenged only the culpability element of just cause (¶ 3). The Board’s culpability determination was reasonable and rational (¶¶ 4, 9).

Issue 1: Culpability for just-cause discharge (mixed, ¶ 2): affirmed (no error)

The Board reasonably found culpability, and Nicol’s balancing-test argument fails both because it was not preserved and on the merits. Just cause is a mixed question of law and fact, and the Board’s application of law to facts stands if “within the realm of reasonableness and rationality” (¶ 2). Culpability requires conduct “so serious that continuing the employment relationship would jeopardize the employer’s rightful interest” under Utah Admin. Code R994-405-202(1) (¶ 4).

Preservation (¶¶ 6–7). Nicol relied on R994-405-202(1) and Gibson v. Department of Employment Security, 840 P.2d 780 (Utah Ct. App. 1992), for a balancing test. She timely appealed the ALJ decision but filed her memorandum after the Board had decided. Filing it with her reconsideration request did not help: reconsideration under R994-508-401(2) covers a change in conditions (including a change in law) or a mistake of fact, not error in applying the statute or rules. Issues not raised in agency proceedings are generally waived, citing Esquivel v. Labor Comm’n, 2000 UT 66, ¶ 34, 7 P.3d 777.

Merits (¶¶ 8–9). Even if preserved, the balance did not favor her. Just over one year of employment and a positive record did not outweigh a deliberate breach of a policy against manipulating one’s own account, done after a warning, in a position with access to accounts and funds. The conduct was not a “good faith error in judgment” (¶ 9).

Takeaways

  • A memorandum filed after the Board decides, then attached to a reconsideration request, does not preserve a legal argument that is not a change in conditions or a mistake of fact (¶¶ 6–7).
  • Error in applying the statute or rules is not a “mistake as to facts” for reconsideration under R994-508-401(2)(b) (¶ 7).
  • A deliberate breach of a known account-handling policy after a supervisor’s warning supported culpability despite a positive, roughly one-year work record (¶¶ 8–9).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Nicol v. WFSV
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 360
Case no.
20120176-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
December 20, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Nicol
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Unemployment benefits denied after a bank employee was discharged for reversing fees on her own account

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Workforce Appeals Board (Department of Workforce Services)

Parties & counsel

Nicol — AppellantIndividual(s)Sam N. Pappas
WFSV — AppelleeGovernment agencyJaceson R. Maughan

Practice Tip

File the supporting memorandum before the Workforce Appeals Board decides; a legal argument first raised with a reconsideration request falls outside Utah Admin. Code R994-508-401(2) and may be treated as waived (¶¶ 6–7).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.