Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can a judge stack my sentences if the presentence report says otherwise? State v. Gardner

2012 UT App 368No. 20111031-CADecided Dec 28, 2012Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

The district court did not abuse its discretion in imposing consecutive sentences, because the PSI showed it considered the Utah Code section 76-3-401(2) factors and the defendant’s criminal history and probation record supported the decision despite the PSI’s probation recommendation.

Practice areaCriminal Appeals

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals upheld Gardner’s consecutive sentences and ruled for the State.

  • A sentencing judge does not have to follow the sentencing recommendation in a presentence report.
  • If the report discusses the factors the law requires, that is generally enough to show the judge considered them.
  • Gardner’s consecutive sentences, stayed in favor of probation, stand.

What happened?

James Arnold Gardner pleaded guilty to two counts of theft by receiving and one count of attempted theft. All three were third degree felonies.

The district court gave him prison terms of zero to five years and ordered them to run consecutively, meaning one after another rather than at the same time. It then stayed the prison terms, meaning it put them on hold, and placed Gardner on probation.

What did Gardner argue?

Gardner, who appealed, argued that the district court should have sentenced him based on the recommendation in the presentence investigation report. That report was prepared by Adult Parole and Probation (AP&P) and recommended probation. The State defended the sentences on appeal.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals affirmed. It reviewed the sentence for abuse of discretion, which means it would reverse only if no reasonable person would have taken the view the district court took.

Utah Code section 76-3-401 lists what a judge must consider before deciding whether sentences run together or one after another: the seriousness and circumstances of the crimes, the number of victims, and the defendant’s history, character and rehabilitative needs. The judge does not have to make findings on the record. It is up to the defendant to show the judge failed to consider those factors.

Because Gardner relied on the presentence report, the court said he seemed to accept that the report contained all the relevant factors. A factor discussed in the report is generally enough to show the judge considered it. So his real disagreement was with how the judge weighed those factors.

Why did the sentences stand?

The record showed Gardner had a significant criminal history. He had been on probation several times before and finished it successfully only once. He committed these crimes while on probation in an earlier case. And even though the report recommended probation, it called him “a very marginal candidate for probation.”

The court also noted that a judge is not bound by AP&P’s recommendation. Given all this, the court could not say no reasonable person would agree with the district court.

What happens now?

Nothing changes. The consecutive sentences stand, still stayed in favor of probation.

What should people take from this?

A presentence report’s recommendation is advice to the judge, not a limit on the sentence. A defendant who challenges consecutive sentences has to show the judge failed to consider the required factors or imposed a sentence no reasonable person would choose.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; McHugh, Voros, and Roth, JJ.). The district court did not abuse its discretion by running Gardner’s three zero-to-five-year terms consecutively, stayed in favor of probation, even though the PSI recommended probation (¶¶ 3–4).

Issue 1: Consecutive sentences (abuse of discretion, ¶ 2): affirmed (no error)

The district court acted within its discretion in imposing consecutive rather than concurrent sentences. Utah Code section 76-3-401(2) requires consideration of the gravity and circumstances of the offenses, the number of victims, and the defendant’s history, character, and rehabilitative needs (¶ 3). Under State v. Helms, 2002 UT 12, ¶ 11, 40 P.3d 626, the decision is upheld whenever it is reasonable to assume the court considered those factors, even without findings on the record, and the defendant bears the burden of showing otherwise (¶ 3). Because Gardner argued for the PSI’s recommendation, he seemed to concede the PSI contained the relevant factors, and a factor discussed in the PSI generally shows the court considered it (¶ 3, citing Helms, ¶ 13). His complaint was thus with how the factors were applied (¶ 3).

On that point, the record showed a significant criminal history, several prior probations with only one successful completion, offenses committed while on probation, and a PSI calling him “a very marginal candidate for probation” (¶ 4). Cf. State v. Moreau, 2011 UT App 109, ¶ 11, 255 P.3d 689 (court not bound by AP&P’s recommendations). The court could not say no reasonable person would take the district court’s view (¶ 4, citing State v. Valdovinos, 2003 UT App 432, ¶ 14, 82 P.3d 1167).

Takeaways

  • Relying on the PSI’s recommendation can concede that the PSI put the section 76-3-401(2) factors before the court, narrowing the appeal to how they were weighed (¶ 3).
  • Silence on the record does not show the court failed to consider the statutory factors; the defendant must show it (¶ 3).
  • Prior probation failures and offenses committed while on probation support consecutive sentences despite a probation recommendation (¶ 4).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
State v. Gardner
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 368
Case no.
20111031-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
December 28, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Gardner
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether three zero-to-five-year prison terms, stayed in favor of probation, should run consecutively rather than concurrently

The panel

J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Robin W. Reese

Parties & counsel

Gardner — AppellantIndividual(s)Debra M. NelsonJohn K. West
State — AppelleeState of UtahMark L. ShurtleffKris C. Leonard

Practice Tip

A challenge to consecutive sentences that rests on the PSI's recommendation may concede that the court considered the statutory factors in the PSI, leaving only a hard-to-win argument about how they were weighed (¶ 3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.