Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I add new evidence when I appeal a denial of unemployment benefits? Hoskins v. Department of Workforce Services

2012 UT App 221No. 20110531-CADecided Aug 9, 2012Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

The Workforce Appeals Board did not abuse its discretion under Utah Admin. Code R994-508-305(2) in refusing to consider records that were available to the claimant at the ALJ hearing when he showed no unusual or extraordinary circumstances, and his argument not raised before the agency could not be reviewed.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Department of Workforce Services and left the denial of unemployment benefits and the fraud penalties in place.

  • The Board will not normally consider new evidence that was reasonably available at the hearing before the administrative law judge, unless there are unusual or extraordinary circumstances.
  • Hoskins gave no reason for not presenting records that he alone controlled, so the Board could refuse them.
  • An argument never raised before the judge or the Board could not be considered for the first time in the Court of Appeals.

What happened?

Joshua Hoskins was denied unemployment benefits, and penalties for fraud were imposed on him. The Workforce Appeals Board (the Board), the agency body that hears appeals in benefit cases, upheld that result in its final decision.

Hoskins represented himself and asked the Utah Court of Appeals to review the Board’s decision. The Department of Workforce Services was on the other side.

What did Hoskins argue?

He said the Board should have looked at personal records he says he kept about his attempts to find work. He had not given those records to the administrative law judge (a hearing officer who takes the evidence first) at his hearing.

He also said he has “ADHD and dyslexia,” which make reading very hard for him, and that he was harmed because most of the information about the terms for receiving benefits was given to him in writing.

What did the court decide about the records?

The court sided with the Board. A Board rule says that, without a showing of “unusual or extraordinary circumstances,” the Board will not consider new evidence on appeal if it was reasonably available at the time of the hearing.

The Board found the records were available to Hoskins at his hearing and that he showed no unusual or extraordinary circumstances. The court could not say the Board abused its discretion, meaning it did not make a choice outside the range of reasonable ones.

The court noted that Hoskins gave the Board no reason why he did not or could not present the records, even though he alone had them. It also noted the records would have contradicted his own testimony to the judge about how many job contacts he made in the weeks in question.

What about his reading difficulties?

The court did not decide that argument. The record did not show he raised it before the administrative law judge or the Board. Issues not raised before an agency generally cannot be reviewed in court except in exceptional circumstances.

What happens now?

Nothing more. The court declined to disturb the Board’s decision, so the denial of benefits and the fraud penalties stand.

What should people take from this?

In this case, the hearing before the administrative law judge was the time to present evidence and arguments. Records that were available then, and arguments not made to the agency, did not help Hoskins later in the appeal.

Bottom line

Board decision affirmed (per curiam; McHugh, P.J., Davis and Christiansen, JJ.). The Board permissibly refused new evidence that the claimant controlled and that was available at the ALJ hearing, where he showed no unusual or extraordinary circumstances (¶¶ 3–5).

Issue 1: Refusal to consider new evidence (mixed, ¶¶ 2–4): affirmed (no error)

The Board did not abuse its discretion in refusing Hoskins’s personal job-search records. The court quoted two standards: substantial evidence for the agency’s findings, from EAGALA, Inc. v. Department of Workforce Servs., 2007 UT App 43, ¶ 8, 157 P.3d 334, and “within the realm of reasonableness and rationality” for its application of law to the facts, from Autoliv ASP, Inc. v. Department of Workforce Servs., 2001 UT App 198, ¶ 16, 29 P.3d 7 (¶ 2). Its conclusion was framed as abuse of discretion (¶ 4). Utah Admin. Code R994-508-305(2) bars new evidence on appeal that was “reasonably available and accessible” at the ALJ hearing, absent unusual or extraordinary circumstances (¶ 3). The Board found the records were available and that no such circumstances were shown (¶ 3). Hoskins gave the Board no reason for not presenting evidence “in sole control” of him, and the records would have contradicted his own testimony to the ALJ about the number of job contacts during the weeks in question (¶ 4).

Issue 2: Disability-based prejudice (none stated, ¶ 4 n.1): not reached

The court did not consider Hoskins’s claim that his “ADHD and dyslexia” left him prejudiced by written notice of benefit terms, because the record did not show he raised it before the ALJ or the Board. It relied on Brown & Root Indus. Serv. v. Industrial Comm’n, 947 P.2d 671, 677 (Utah 1997): issues not raised before an agency are not reviewable “except in exceptional circumstances” (¶ 4 n.1). Hoskins did not argue an exception, and the court did not apply one.

Takeaways

  • Under R994-508-305(2), the Board may refuse evidence a claimant held and could have offered to the ALJ when no unusual or extraordinary circumstances are shown (¶¶ 3–4).
  • The court treated the fact that the new records would have contradicted the claimant’s own ALJ testimony as further support for the Board’s refusal (¶ 4).
  • An argument must be raised before the ALJ or the Board to be reviewed on judicial review, absent exceptional circumstances (¶ 4 n.1).

Utah cases relied on

  • Brown & Root Indus. Service v. Industrial Comm'n947 P.2d 671, 677 (Utah 1997)

Case details

Case name
Hoskins v. Department of Workforce Services
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 221
Case no.
20110531-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
August 9, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Hoskins
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
The Workforce Appeals Board's decision denying Hoskins unemployment benefits and imposing penalties for fraud

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Workforce Appeals Board (Department of Workforce Services)

Parties & counsel

Hoskins — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Department of Workforce Services — AppelleeGovernment agencyAmanda B. McPeck

Practice Tip

Put all available evidence before the ALJ in an unemployment case; the Board may refuse evidence that was available at that hearing when no unusual or extraordinary circumstances are shown, and an argument not raised before the agency may not be reviewed (¶¶ 3–4 & n.1).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.