Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I challenge my murder conviction’s jury instructions after appeal? Todd v. State

2011 UT App 313No. 20110555-CADecided Sep 15, 2011Post-Conviction ReliefAffirmed

Holding

Because jurors in a Utah murder case need not unanimously agree on which of the three mens rea formulations was proved under State v. Saunders, 1999 UT 59, 992 P.2d 951, counsel was not ineffective for failing to raise a “patchwork verdict” claim, and claims absent from the petition or decided on direct appeal were precluded.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld the dismissal of Shayne E. Todd’s petition for post-conviction relief.

  • Under the Utah cases the court relied on, jurors in a murder case need not all agree on which of the three listed mental states was proved, as long as all agree at least one was.
  • Because that challenge lacked merit, Todd’s lawyers were not ineffective for not raising it.
  • Arguments left out of the post-conviction petition, or already decided on direct appeal, could not be raised in this appeal.

What happened?

In 1999, Shayne E. Todd had an altercation with his estranged wife, Stephanie Todd, and shot and killed her. A jury convicted him of murder in 2001, and the Court of Appeals affirmed that conviction in 2007.

Todd then sought post-conviction relief, which is a separate civil case challenging a conviction after the direct appeal is over. His first petition, filed in April 2009, was dismissed because he did not pay the filing fee. He filed a substantially identical petition in March 2010.

What did the district court do?

It dismissed some claims as frivolous. It decided two claims on their merits: a “patchwork verdict” claim and a claim that his trial and appellate lawyers were ineffective for failing to raise thirteen listed claims.

Utah’s post-conviction law bars claims that were raised, or could have been raised, at trial or on direct appeal. It allows such a claim only if the failure to raise it was due to ineffective assistance of counsel, meaning the lawyer’s performance fell short. So the court looked at Todd’s claims only through that lens.

What was the “patchwork verdict” claim?

The jury was told that a killing is murder if the person acted in one of three ways: intentionally or knowingly causing death; intending serious bodily injury and doing an act clearly dangerous to life; or acting with depraved indifference to human life. Todd argued the jurors should have had to agree unanimously on which one applied.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed. The court on its own motion proposed deciding the appeal summarily, and Todd filed a response. Reading that response generously because Todd represented himself, the court found it raised the patchwork-verdict claim.

The court relied on State v. Saunders, 1999 UT 59, 992 P.2d 951, which describes a limited exception for the murder statute: the jury “need not unanimously agree” on which of the three mental states was proved, as long as all jurors agree that at least one was. Because the claim lacked merit under Utah law, Todd’s lawyers were not ineffective for failing to raise it.

What about Todd’s other arguments?

Todd mostly argued that the shooting was accidental. He had not raised that claim in his post-conviction petition, and it would have been barred anyway as a claim that should have been raised on direct appeal.

He also tried to repeat prosecutorial misconduct arguments from his direct appeal. Those were not in his petition either, and they were barred because they had already been raised and decided in State v. Todd, 2007 UT App 349, 173 P.3d 170.

What happens now?

Nothing further in this case. The dismissal of Todd’s petition stands, and his murder conviction remains in place.

What should people take from this?

A post-conviction appeal reviews what the district court decided on the petition. Arguments that were not in the petition, or that were already decided on direct appeal, were not considered here.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; McHugh, Thorne, and Christiansen, JJ.), on the court’s sua sponte motion for summary disposition (¶¶ 1, 7). Todd, pro se, appealed the dismissal of his second post-conviction petition challenging his 2001 murder conviction. The post-conviction court treated the non-frivolous claims as precluded under Utah Code § 78B-9-106(b) and (c) and reviewed them only as ineffective-assistance claims under § 78B-9-106(3) (¶ 4).

Issue 1: Patchwork-verdict ineffective assistance (none stated, ¶ 5): affirmed (no error)

Counsel was not ineffective for failing to raise the patchwork-verdict claim because it lacks merit under Utah law. Liberally construing Todd’s response, the court addressed his claim that jurors had to agree unanimously on one subsection of Utah Code § 76-5-203(2)(a)-(c) (¶¶ 3, 5). Under State v. Saunders, 1999 UT 59, 992 P.2d 951, at ¶ 59 n.3 (citing State v. Russell, 733 P.2d 162, 165-69 (Utah 1987)), a limited exception to jury unanimity applies to the murder statute, and jurors need not agree on which of the three mens rea formulations was proved if all agree at least one was (¶ 5). Saunders, at ¶ 61, explained that Russell addressed slight variations of mens rea that the common law treated as the single concept of “malice aforethought” (¶ 5).

Issue 2: Remaining arguments against dismissal of the post-conviction petition (none stated, ¶ 6): not reached

The court did not reach Todd’s remaining arguments because they were not raised in the post-conviction petition and were precluded under § 78B-9-106(1) (¶ 6).

Part 1: Accidental-shooting claim

Todd’s argument that the shooting was accidental was not raised in the post-conviction petition, and it would have been precluded as a claim that should have been raised on direct appeal under § 78B-9-106(1) (¶ 6).

Part 2: Prosecutorial misconduct

Todd’s renewed prosecutorial misconduct arguments were not asserted in the petition and are precluded under § 78B-9-106(1)(b) because they were raised and addressed in State v. Todd, 2007 UT App 349, 173 P.3d 170 (¶ 6).

Takeaways

  • Under State v. Saunders, 1999 UT 59, 992 P.2d 951, a murder jury need not unanimously agree on which of the three mens rea formulations was proved, so counsel is not ineffective for omitting that challenge (¶ 5).
  • An appeal from a post-conviction dismissal does not reach claims absent from the petition (¶ 6).
  • Claims raised and addressed on direct appeal are precluded under Utah Code § 78B-9-106(1)(b) (¶ 6).
  • The court liberally construed a pro se response but still measured it against the decision under review (¶¶ 5–6).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Todd v. State
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 313
Case no.
20110555-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
September 15, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Todd
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Todd's petition for post-conviction relief from his murder conviction

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
William A. Thorne Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Randall N. Skanchy

Parties & counsel

Todd — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
State — AppelleeState of UtahMark L. ShurtleffErin Riley

Practice Tip

On appeal from a post-conviction dismissal, address the post-conviction court's actual reasoning; claims not in the petition, or already decided on direct appeal, will not be considered (¶ 6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.