Can I challenge my murder conviction’s jury instructions after appeal? Todd v. State
Holding
Because jurors in a Utah murder case need not unanimously agree on which of the three mens rea formulations was proved under State v. Saunders, 1999 UT 59, 992 P.2d 951, counsel was not ineffective for failing to raise a “patchwork verdict” claim, and claims absent from the petition or decided on direct appeal were precluded.
Key takeaways
The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld the dismissal of Shayne E. Todd’s petition for post-conviction relief.
- Under the Utah cases the court relied on, jurors in a murder case need not all agree on which of the three listed mental states was proved, as long as all agree at least one was.
- Because that challenge lacked merit, Todd’s lawyers were not ineffective for not raising it.
- Arguments left out of the post-conviction petition, or already decided on direct appeal, could not be raised in this appeal.
Utah cases relied on
Case details
- Case name
- Todd v. State
- Court
- Utah Court of Appeals
- Citation
- 2011 UT App 313
- Case no.
- 20110555-CA
- Filed
- 2011
- Decided
- September 15, 2011
- Opinion type
- Per curiam
- Who appealed
- Todd
- Disposition
- Affirmed
The panel
Parties & counsel
Practice Tip
On appeal from a post-conviction dismissal, address the post-conviction court's actual reasoning; claims not in the petition, or already decided on direct appeal, will not be considered (¶ 6).
Need appellate counsel?
Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.
About these Decision Summaries
Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.


