Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal a judge’s refusal to dismiss a suit against me? Ronald McDonald House Charities v. Holgerson

2011 UT App 312No. 20110585-CADecided Sep 9, 2011Contracts & Business DisputesDismissed

Holding

An order denying a defendant’s demand for dismissal and requiring him to answer the complaint is not a final, appealable order under Utah R. App. P. 3(a), and a filing within the appeal that does not comply with rule 19 will not be construed as a petition for extraordinary relief.

Practice areaCivil Appeals

Key takeaways

Ronald McDonald House Charities came out ahead because the Court of Appeals dismissed Holgerson’s appeal and left the lawsuit against him pending.

  • An order refusing to dismiss a lawsuit and requiring an answer is not a final order, so the Court of Appeals could not hear a direct appeal from it.
  • A filing made inside an appeal that does not follow rule 19 of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure will not be treated as a petition for extraordinary relief.
  • The dismissal does not end the lawsuit, which stays pending in the district court, and Holgerson may appeal on time after a final judgment.

What happened?

Ronald McDonald House Charities, the plaintiff, sued Gregory Holgerson and PHROG, Inc. to recover damages for alleged breach of a lease agreement. After the complaint was served, Holgerson moved to Idaho. The charity found him in Pocatello and served him with its first amended complaint in April 2011.

Holgerson then filed a document he called a “Notice and Demand” asking the court to dismiss the case for lack of jurisdiction, meaning the court’s power to hear it. He argued that the district court was a foreign state, that he was not a corporation, and that the Eleventh Amendment made him immune from suit.

What did the district court do?

On June 6, 2011, it denied his request to dismiss and ordered him to answer the complaint within twenty days. On June 28, Holgerson filed an “Appeal” and another “Notice and Demand,” both challenging the district court’s jurisdiction. He filed nearly identical papers in the Court of Appeals, asking it to dismiss the case against him.

Could the Court of Appeals hear his appeal?

No. Under the appellate rules, an appeal generally may be taken only from a final order, one that resolves every claim against every party. The order Holgerson challenged was interlocutory, meaning it came in the middle of a case that was still going. It denied dismissal and told him to answer, so nothing had been finally decided.

An appeal from an order that is not final must be dismissed, so the court dismissed it for lack of jurisdiction.

Could his filing count as a different kind of request?

The court considered whether to read his “Notice and Demand” generously as a petition for extraordinary relief, which is a special request asking the appellate court to step in outside the normal appeal process. It declined. Such a petition must be filed as its own case under rule 19 of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure, served on the other side, and filed with a fee.

When it targets a mid-case order, the petition must also say whether a petition for interlocutory appeal, a request for permission to appeal early, has been filed, or explain why that route is not an adequate remedy. Holgerson’s filing did none of this, so the court said any such request “must be denied.”

What happens now?

The lawsuit against Holgerson and PHROG Inc. stays pending in the Third District Court. The court stressed that its dismissal has no effect on that case. Holgerson may still file a timely appeal once a final judgment resolves the whole case.

What should people take from this?

In general, a ruling that keeps a case going cannot be appealed right away just because a party disagrees with it. A party who wants early review has to use the proper procedure, and following its rules matters.

Bottom line

Appeal dismissed for lack of jurisdiction (per curiam; Orme, Voros, and Roth, JJ.). Gregory Holgerson, the pro se defendant and appellant, appealed a June 6, 2011 district court ruling that denied his demand for dismissal and ordered him to answer the complaint of Ronald McDonald House Charities, the plaintiff and appellee, in a suit for breach of a lease (¶ 2). The order was interlocutory, so the court lacked jurisdiction (¶ 3). The dismissal is without prejudice to a timely appeal from a final judgment and does not affect the pending district court case (¶ 5).

Issue 1: Appeal from a non-final order (none stated, ¶ 3): not reached

The court lacked jurisdiction over the direct appeal because the order denying dismissal and requiring an answer was not final. Under Utah R. App. P. 3(a), appeals lie from “all final orders and judgments,” and an order is final when it disposes of all claims against all parties on the merits (¶ 3; see also Loffredo v. Holt, 2001 UT 97, ¶ 12, 37 P.3d 1070; Houston v. Intermountain Health Care, 933 P.2d 403, 406 (Utah Ct. App. 1997)). An appeal from a non-final order must be dismissed (¶ 3, see Bradbury v. Valencia, 2000 UT 50, ¶ 8, 5 P.3d 649).

Issue 2: Filing treated as a petition for extraordinary relief (none stated, ¶ 4): Holgerson’s request denied

Even read liberally as a petition for extraordinary relief, Holgerson’s notice and demand had to be denied. It was filed within the pending appeal rather than as a separate proceeding under rule 19 and did not invoke or comply with that rule (¶ 4). A rule 19 petition must fully comply with the rule, be served on the named respondents, and come with a filing fee. A petition aimed at an interlocutory order must also say whether a petition for interlocutory appeal was filed or why that route “is not a plain, speedy or adequate remedy” under Utah R. App. P. 19(b)(10) (¶ 4). Because the filing met none of rule 19’s requirements, the court did not construe it as a petition for extraordinary relief (¶ 4).

Disposition

The appeal is dismissed without prejudice to a timely appeal after entry of a final judgment fully resolving the case. The suit against Holgerson and PHROG Inc. stays pending in the Third District Court (¶ 5).

Takeaways

  • An order denying a motion to dismiss and requiring an answer is not final under rule 3(a), and an appeal from it will be dismissed (¶ 3).
  • A filing made within an appeal will not be converted into a rule 19 petition when it does not comply with rule 19’s filing, service, fee, and content requirements (¶ 4).
  • A petition attacking an interlocutory order must address whether interlocutory appeal was sought or why it is not an adequate remedy, per rule 19(b)(10) (¶ 4).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Ronald McDonald House Charities v. Holgerson
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 312
Case no.
20110585-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
September 9, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Holgerson
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
A suit by Ronald McDonald House Charities for damages for alleged breach of a lease agreement; the appeal challenged the denial of the defendant's demand for dismissal.

The panel

J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Deno G. Himonas

Parties & counsel

Holgerson — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Ronald McDonald House Charities — AppelleeBusiness

Practice Tip

To seek review of an order denying dismissal before final judgment, do not file a direct appeal; a petition for extraordinary relief must be a separate rule 19 proceeding that is served, paid for, and addresses rule 19(b)(10) (¶¶ 3-4).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.