Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal a conviction because the victim wasn’t believable? State v. Nacey

2013 UT App 125No. 20110622-CADecided May 16, 2013Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Directed-verdict motions challenging only evidence of penetration did not preserve a claim that the victim was too unreliable to support attempted rape, and the district court did not plainly err because generalized credibility attacks do not show inherent improbability under State v. Robbins, 2009 UT 23, 210 P.3d 288, particularly where the victim’s testimony was corroborated.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Nacey’s conviction for attempted rape.

  • A motion at trial that challenges one part of the evidence does not save a different challenge to the evidence for appeal.
  • General doubts about a witness’s honesty do not make her testimony “inherently improbable.”
  • When other evidence backs up a witness, deciding whether to believe her is left to the jury.

What happened?

Patrick Robert Nacey was tried before a jury and convicted of attempted rape. He appealed to the Utah Court of Appeals, arguing that there was not enough evidence to convict him.

What did Nacey argue?

He argued that the victim’s testimony was too unreliable to prove attempted rape beyond a reasonable doubt. He called her a “schizophrenic liar” and pointed to several witnesses who questioned her reputation for telling the truth.

Did he raise this argument at trial?

Not in the same form. A defendant usually has to raise a challenge to the evidence in the trial court first, so the judge has a chance to rule on it. Nacey twice asked for a directed verdict, which is a request that the judge end the case without sending it to the jury.

But those requests argued only that there was no evidence of penetration, which went to the rape charge. They did not argue that the victim was too unreliable to support attempted rape. So the court held his appeal argument had not been raised below.

What did that mean for his appeal?

He had to show “plain error.” That means he had to prove two things: that the evidence really was not enough to convict, and that this was so obvious the trial judge should have stopped the case on his own instead of sending it to the jury.

Nacey did not argue that any “exceptional circumstances” justified looking at the issue another way.

What did the court decide?

It held there was no plain error and affirmed the conviction. Appeals courts do not decide again whether a witness was believable. They can overturn a verdict only if testimony is “inherently improbable,” meaning its falsity is obvious without having to draw inferences.

Nacey’s attack was about the victim’s credibility in general, which is not enough. And her testimony was supported by her husband and by circumstantial physical evidence. So whether to believe her was a question for the jury.

What happens now?

Nothing further in this appeal. The conviction for attempted rape stands.

What should people take from this?

A challenge to the evidence at trial should cover each argument the defendant may later want to make on appeal. And an appeal that rests on a witness’s general reputation for dishonesty will rarely overcome a jury’s decision to believe her, especially when other evidence supports what she said.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme, McHugh, and Roth, JJ.). Nacey’s sufficiency claim was unpreserved, and he failed to show that the district court plainly erred in submitting the attempted rape charge to the jury (¶¶ 2, 5).

Issue 1: Sufficiency of the evidence, unpreserved (plain error, ¶¶ 2–3): affirmed (no error)

The district court did not plainly err in sending the case to the jury, because Nacey’s attack on the victim’s testimony rested on generalized credibility concerns and her testimony was corroborated (¶ 5).

Preservation. A defendant generally must raise sufficiency “by proper motion or objection,” citing State v. Holgate, 2000 UT 74, ¶ 16, 10 P.3d 346 (¶ 2). Nacey’s two directed-verdict motions argued only the lack of evidence of penetration on the rape charge. His appellate argument, that the victim was too unreliable to establish attempted rape, was not presented so the trial court could rule on it, see State v. Maese, 2010 UT App 106, ¶ 13, 236 P.3d 155 (¶ 2). Nacey did not argue exceptional circumstances (¶ 2 n.1).

Plain error test. Under Holgate, 2000 UT 74, ¶ 17, the defendant must show the evidence was insufficient and that the insufficiency was “so obvious and fundamental” that submitting the case was error; the evidence is viewed in the light most favorable to the verdict (¶ 3).

Inherent improbability. The court may not reassess credibility, State v. Workman, 852 P.2d 981, 984 (Utah 1993), but may reverse when evidence is “sufficiently inconclusive or inherently improbable,” State v. Mead, 2001 UT 58, ¶ 65, 27 P.3d 1115 (¶ 4). Under State v. Robbins, 2009 UT 23, 210 P.3d 288, that doctrine does not permit challenges based on “generalized concerns about a witness’s credibility” (¶ 19); testimony is inherently improbable only if its falsity is apparent without inferences or deductions (¶ 17) (¶ 4).

Application. Nacey called the victim a “schizophrenic liar” and relied on reputation-for-truthfulness testimony. Because her husband and circumstantial physical evidence corroborated her, her testimony’s falsity was not inherent, and credibility was for the jury (¶ 5).

Takeaways

  • A directed-verdict motion aimed at one element of the charged offense does not preserve a different sufficiency theory aimed at a lesser offense of conviction (¶ 2).
  • Reputation-for-truthfulness evidence and labels attacking a witness’s credibility are “generalized concerns” that do not establish inherent improbability under State v. Robbins, 2009 UT 23, ¶ 19, 210 P.3d 288 (¶¶ 4–5).
  • Corroboration by another witness and circumstantial physical evidence defeated the inherent-improbability claim here (¶ 5).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
State v. Nacey
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 125
Case no.
20110622-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
May 16, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Nacey
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A jury conviction for attempted rape

The panel

Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Robert P. Faust

Parties & counsel

Nacey — AppellantIndividual(s)Peter A. DainesScott A. Wilson
State — AppelleeState of UtahJohn E. SwallowBrett J. DelPorto

Practice Tip

When moving for a directed verdict, state each sufficiency theory you may raise on appeal, including theories aimed at lesser included offenses; a motion limited to one element left the defendant here to plain error review (¶ 2).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.