Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I challenge an old settlement in a new job discrimination claim? Desai v. Labor Commission

2014 UT App 293No. 20140524-CADecided Dec 18, 2014Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

The Labor Commission correctly dismissed Desai’s discrimination and retaliation claims because any challenge to the 2009 settlement agreement was untimely under Utah Code § 34A-5-107(1)(c) and he alleged no facts showing discriminatory or retaliatory conduct in the 2011 superintendent hiring.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the Labor Commission and the Garfield School District and left the dismissal of Desai’s discrimination claims in place.

  • A discrimination claim must be filed within 180 days of the challenged employment practice, and a challenge to a 2009 settlement came too late in this case.
  • Desai’s filings described no discriminatory or retaliatory conduct in the 2011 hiring, so the court held the claim was correctly dismissed.
  • The Labor Commission’s decision stands.

What happened?

In 2011, Harshad P. Desai applied to be superintendent of the Garfield School District (the District). He was not hired. He filed a claim with the Division of Antidiscrimination and Labor, a state agency, saying the District discriminated against him based on religion, national origin, color, and race, and retaliated against him for an earlier discrimination complaint.

The Division investigated and found “no reasonable cause” to support the claims. It found the District’s lawyer had advised it not to act on his application because of a 2009 settlement agreement between Desai and the District from an earlier case. It also found Desai lacked enough relevant experience and the person hired was considerably more qualified.

What happened next?

Desai asked for a fresh hearing before an administrative law judge, a judge who hears agency cases. There, he argued only that the release terms in the 2009 settlement were invalid or unconstitutional. The District asked the judge to dismiss the case because Desai gave no facts supporting discrimination or retaliation.

The judge dismissed it. Any claim about the 2009 agreement fell outside the 180-day filing deadline in the statute. Even treating the 2011 hiring as the event at issue, the judge said Desai had shown no discriminatory acts. The Utah Labor Commission (the Commission) agreed and later denied Desai’s request to reconsider.

What did Desai argue on appeal?

Desai, who represented himself, challenged only the validity and constitutionality of the 2009 settlement agreement. He claimed it was “created for malice, vendetta, retaliation, coercion [and] personal gains.”

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals declined to disturb the Commission’s decision. Desai had the first burden of showing a basic case of discrimination in the 2011 hiring. But his filings focused only on the 2009 agreement, not on anything the District did in 2011.

The court agreed that, even if the Commission had power to consider the 2009 agreement, that challenge was too late. And Desai did not allege any facts that, if proven, would show the District discriminated or retaliated against him when it did not hire him. The court noted that much of his brief was “clearly irrelevant” to that question.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The dismissal of Desai’s claims stands.

What should people take from this?

A discrimination claim has to describe what the employer did in the decision being challenged. Attacking an older agreement, years after it was signed, did not meet the 180-day deadline here and did not show discrimination in the later hiring.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Roth, Pearce, and Toomey, JJ.). Harshad P. Desai, the petitioner, sought review of the Labor Commission’s order denying reconsideration of the dismissal of his claims against the Garfield School District, the respondent (¶ 1). The claim was correctly dismissed because Desai challenged only a 2009 settlement agreement and alleged no facts about the 2011 hiring (¶ 5).

Issue 1: Dismissal of the discrimination and retaliation claims (correctness, ¶ 5): affirmed (no error)

The Commission correctly dismissed the case because Desai failed to plead a prima facie case of discrimination or retaliation in the 2011 superintendent hiring. Whether a party failed to establish a prima facie case is a question of law reviewed for correctness, quoting Kunej v. Labor Comm’n, 2013 UT App 173, ¶ 15, 306 P.3d 855 (¶ 5). Beginning with the de novo proceedings under Utah Code § 34A-5-107(4)(c), Desai bore the initial burden, yet his pleadings addressed only the release provisions of the 2009 settlement agreement (¶¶ 3, 5). Even if the Commission had jurisdiction to consider that challenge, it was untimely under the requirement that a request for agency action be filed within 180 days of the alleged practice, Utah Code § 34A-5-107(1)(c) (¶¶ 3, 5). Desai alleged no facts that, if proven, would show discriminatory or retaliatory conduct in the hiring, and much of his brief was “clearly irrelevant” (¶ 5).

Background: the Commission had also concluded it lacked authority to alter an agreement it was not involved in, and that the settlement agreement “is not evidence of a discriminatory animus” (¶ 4). The court did not separately rule on the Commission’s authority, resting instead on untimeliness “even if” jurisdiction existed (¶ 5).

Takeaways

  • A complainant in a de novo hearing under Utah Code § 34A-5-107 bears the initial burden of a prima facie case tied to the challenged employment decision (¶ 5).
  • Attacking a prior settlement agreement does not substitute for allegations about the later hiring decision, and a challenge to a 2009 agreement was outside the 180-day window (¶¶ 3, 5).
  • Failure to allege facts showing discrimination in the challenged decision supports dismissal without an evidentiary hearing (¶¶ 3, 5).
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Desai v. Labor Commission
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2014 UT App 293
Case no.
20140524-CA
Filed
2014
Decided
December 18, 2014
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Desai
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Desai's discrimination and retaliation claims against the Garfield School District after he was not hired as superintendent in 2011

The panel

John A. PearcePer curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Kate A. ToomeyPer curiam
Trial court
Labor Commission

Parties & counsel

Desai — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Labor Commission — AppelleeGovernment agencySean D. ReyesPeggy E. Stone

Practice Tip

In a Labor Commission discrimination proceeding, plead facts about the specific employment decision within the 180-day window; attacking an earlier settlement agreement did not establish a prima facie case here (¶ 5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.