Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can a judge give me prison when the prosecutor asked for probation? State v. Gainer

2014 UT App 286No. 20140355-CADecided Dec 11, 2014Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

A within-range prison sentence imposed after review of a PSI was not an abuse of discretion, and the unpreserved due process challenge to the victim’s unsworn sentencing statements failed under plain error review because the statements were relevant, reasonably reliable and open to rebuttal.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Gainer’s prison sentence for aggravated robbery.

  • A sentencing judge may impose a prison term within the legal range even when the prosecutor recommends jail and probation, if the decision is not unreasonable.
  • A victim has a right to speak at sentencing, and the judge may consider those statements when they are relevant and reasonably reliable.
  • Objections to what is said at sentencing should be raised at the hearing; Gainer did not object, which limited his appeal.

What happened?

Gainer was stopped by two loss prevention employees as he left a Salt Lake City Walmart with merchandise he had not paid for. As he tried to get away, he bit one employee on the arm and stabbed him in the hip with a folding knife. A police officer stopped him as he fled on a bicycle.

Gainer pleaded guilty to aggravated robbery, a first degree felony. In his written plea statement he admitted he “fought with two loss prevention store employees” and used a knife to stab one of them. (The court noted that his name is actually spelled Ganier, but it used the spelling in the trial court record.)

What sentence did each side want?

In exchange for the plea, the State agreed to recommend jail and probation. Gainer’s lawyer asked for 365 days in jail, drug treatment and probation with mental health treatment. The presentence report, prepared by Adult Probation and Parole, recommended prison, citing the victim’s injury, Gainer’s criminal history score, and force that was “out of line.”

At sentencing, the victim said he identified himself, that Gainer reacted aggressively, and that Gainer tried to stab him in the stomach. The judge sentenced Gainer to prison.

What did Gainer argue on appeal?

He made two arguments. First, he said the judge did not properly consider his character, attitude and need for rehabilitation, and that prison was too harsh. Second, he said his right to due process (the right to fair procedures) was violated because the judge relied on the victim’s statements, which he called unreliable.

Was the prison sentence fair?

Yes. A judge has broad freedom in choosing whether to grant probation, and the appeals court will overturn a sentence only if it was so unfair that it was an abuse of discretion, meaning outside the range of reasonable choices. The sentence was within the legal range. The presentence report covered Gainer’s history, family, drug and alcohol use, and attitude, and the judge also heard from the lawyers, Gainer and the victim. The judge even noted Gainer had not taken his bipolar medication at the time.

Was it wrong to rely on the victim’s statements?

No. Gainer never objected to the victim’s statements at sentencing or tried to rebut them, so he did not preserve the claim. That meant the court looked only for “plain error,” an obvious and harmful mistake. It found none. Victims have a legal right to be heard at sentencing. The statements were relevant and reasonably reliable because the victim had personal knowledge, they also appeared in the presentence report, and Gainer had a chance to respond. Gainer cited no law showing that due process required the victim to be under oath or cross-examined.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The prison sentence stands.

What should people take from this?

A prosecutor’s recommendation does not bind the judge. If a defendant disagrees with what a victim says at sentencing, the time to object or respond is at the hearing itself.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme, Davis and Voros, JJ.). Gainer pleaded guilty to aggravated robbery after stabbing a Walmart loss prevention employee. The State recommended jail and probation, AP&P recommended prison, and the court imposed prison (¶¶ 2–4). The sentence was within the court’s discretion, and considering the victim’s sentencing statements was not plain error (¶¶ 5–8).

Issue 1: Prison sentence: abuse of discretion and due process (mixed, ¶ 5): affirmed (no error)

The court held that the prison sentence for aggravated robbery was not an abuse of discretion and did not violate due process, and affirmed it (¶¶ 5–8).

Part 1: Prison instead of probation (abuse of discretion, ¶ 5)

The district court did not abuse its discretion by imposing a prison term. Probation decisions involve “intangibles of character, personality and attitude” and rest in broad discretion, State v. Rhodes, 818 P.2d 1048, 1049 (Utah Ct. App. 1991) (¶ 5). The sentence was within the statutory range, the PSI evaluated criminal history, employment, education, family, substance use, emotional problems and attitude, and the court also heard counsel, Gainer and the victim and noted Gainer had not taken his bipolar medication (¶ 5). Reliance on a PSI shows appropriate consideration of the sentencing factors even when the court does not refer to each one (¶ 5). In a footnote the court remarked that Gainer’s claim he did not know the men were store employees was of unclear relevance (¶ 4 n.2).

Part 2: Due process and the victim’s statements (plain error, ¶¶ 6–7)

The due process claim was unpreserved and the court found no plain error in considering the victim’s statements. Gainer neither objected nor sought to rebut the statements when given the chance, so the claim was not preserved, citing State v. Patience, 944 P.2d 381, 389 (Utah Ct. App. 1997) (¶ 6). The victim had a right to be heard under Utah Code section 77-38-4(1)(b) (¶ 6). Under State v. Patience, 944 P.2d 381, 389 (Utah Ct. App. 1997), the sentencing judge must act on reasonably reliable and relevant information; the victim’s statements were relevant, came from a witness with personal knowledge, appeared in the PSI (so notice was adequate), and Gainer could challenge them (¶ 7). Gainer offered no authority that the lack of an oath or cross-examination violates due process, and Patience noted courts finding no violation where the defendant can refute the evidence (¶ 7, citing 944 P.2d at 389 n.12).

Takeaways

  • A PSI that addresses the relevant factors supports an inference that the court considered them, even without express findings on each (¶ 5).
  • Failing to object to or rebut a victim’s sentencing statement leaves a due process challenge unpreserved (¶ 6).
  • Victim statements based on personal knowledge, disclosed in the PSI and open to rebuttal, are reasonably reliable for sentencing; an unsworn, uncross-examined statement was not shown to violate due process (¶ 7).
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Gainer
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2014 UT App 286
Case no.
20140355-CA
Filed
2014
Decided
December 11, 2014
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Gainer
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A prison sentence for aggravated robbery, rather than the jail and probation Gainer sought, after a guilty plea

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Robin W. Reese

Parties & counsel

Gainer — AppellantIndividual(s)Joanna E. LandauMichael A. Peterson
State — AppelleeState of UtahSean D. ReyesTera J. Peterson

Practice Tip

If a victim's sentencing statement is disputed, object or offer rebuttal at the hearing; without that, the due process claim is unpreserved and reviewed only for plain error (¶¶ 6–7).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.