Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal a stalking ruling I already won? McNeil v. Hone

2011 UT App 406No. 20110635-CADecided Dec 1, 2011Family LawDismissed

Holding

Because the civil stalking injunction against Hone was dismissed, her challenge to the district court’s finding that she committed one act of stalking was moot, and a ruling on it would be an advisory opinion about a hypothetical future proceeding.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals dismissed Hone’s appeal as moot, leaving in place the district court’s dismissal of the stalking injunction she had already won.

  • Hone won below because the district court dismissed the stalking injunction, so the court of appeals would not review the finding she objected to.
  • Any future civil stalking injunction would still require proof of two or more acts of stalking.
  • The court declined to give what it called an advisory opinion about evidence in a possible future case.

What happened?

Shawna L. McNeil asked the district court for a civil stalking injunction against Ruth Elizabeth Hone. A civil stalking injunction is a court order telling a person to stay away from or stop contacting someone. An ex parte injunction, meaning one entered before Hone was heard, was in place.

After a hearing, the court found that Hone had engaged in only one act of stalking. Utah law requires a “course of conduct,” which means two or more acts aimed at a specific person. Because McNeil did not prove two acts, the court dismissed the injunction.

The judge also told Hone at the hearing that she was “on notice” that, if she kept doing the kinds of things discussed, the McNeils could come back to court “having already proved one act of civil stalking.”

Why did Hone appeal if she won?

Hone challenged the finding that she had committed one act of stalking. According to Hone, the finding left her under a “constant threat” of an injunction, because one more act could be enough. She said the act in question was a Facebook comment to a third party.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal as moot. A case is moot when the court’s ruling could not change the parties’ rights. Hone had already gotten what she wanted: the injunction was dismissed.

The court noted that the written order simply dismissed the injunction on a preprinted form. The hearing transcript showed the judge explained that McNeil would have to start a new case, which would be decided on its own terms. The judge also said the law did not let the court keep the case going once McNeil had failed to prove a course of conduct.

The court said Hone was essentially asking for an advisory opinion, meaning a ruling about a situation that has not happened and may never happen. Courts generally refuse to give those. If McNeil ever sought a new injunction, she would have to prove two or more acts of stalking in that case.

What happens now?

Nothing more happens in this case. The dismissal of the injunction stands, and the court did not decide whether the one-act finding was right. The court took the step of dismissing on its own motion for summary disposition, a quick ruling without full argument.

What should people take from this?

A party who wins in the trial court generally cannot appeal just to change the reasons the judge gave. Here, the court held that any future request for a stalking injunction would have to be proved on its own, with two or more acts.

Bottom line

Appeal dismissed as moot (per curiam; Davis, P.J., McHugh, A.P.J., and Christiansen, J.). The appeal came before the court “on a sua sponte motion for summary disposition” (¶ 1). The district court dismissed an ex parte civil stalking injunction because McNeil proved only one act, not a course of conduct, but told Hone she was “on notice” that one act had been proved (¶ 2). Because Hone prevailed below, her challenge to that one-act finding is moot (¶¶ 5–6).

Issue 1: Challenge to the one-act stalking finding (none stated, ¶ 5): not reached

The court declined to reach Hone’s claims of error in the district court’s reasoning because the dismissal of the injunction made them moot (¶¶ 5–6). A civil stalking injunction requires a stalking offense under Utah Code section 76‐5‐106.5(2), and a “course of conduct” requires “two or more acts” (¶ 3, citing Coombs v. Dietrich, 2011 UT App 136, ¶ 2, 253 P.3d 1121; see Allen v. Anger, 2011 UT App 19, ¶ 22, 248 P.3d 1001). The written order merely dismissed the injunction on a preprinted form, and the transcript showed the district court told the parties that McNeil would have to start a new proceeding considered on its own terms (¶ 4).

Hone “essentially requests an advisory opinion” (¶ 5). Any future injunction would require proof of a course of conduct, and Hone did not show why, having prevailed, she was entitled to a decision limiting evidence in a hypothetical proceeding (¶ 5). The court relied on see Murray City v. Maese, 2011 UT App 73, ¶ 2, 251 P.3d 843; see also Ellis v. Swenson, 2000 UT 101, ¶ 25, 16 P.3d 1233; and Merhish v. H.A. Folson & Assoc., 646 P.2d 731, 732 (Utah 1982). It added that a decision on sufficiency of proof in a future case would be advisory, see Pett v. Autoliv ASP, Inc., 2005 UT 2, ¶ 4, 106 P.3d 705 (unripe hypothetical application) (¶ 5).

Disposition

Appeal dismissed as moot (¶ 6). Nothing was remanded.

Takeaways

  • A party who obtained dismissal of a civil stalking injunction could not appeal to challenge a finding in the district court’s reasoning; those claims were moot (¶¶ 5–6).
  • A finding of one act of stalking does not lower the burden in a later proceeding: a new petitioner must still prove two or more acts (¶¶ 3, 5).
  • A transcript showing the trial court treated any future petition as a new proceeding supported the conclusion that the finding had no present effect (¶ 4).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
McNeil v. Hone
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 406
Case no.
20110635-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
December 1, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Hone
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
A civil stalking injunction the district court dismissed, and its statement that one act of stalking had been proved

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Silver Summit Department · Judge Keith A. Kelly

Parties & counsel

Hone — AppellantIndividual(s)Ronald D. Wilkinson
McNeil — AppelleeIndividual(s)Self-represented

Practice Tip

Before appealing a dismissal your client won, identify relief the appellate court can actually grant; disagreement with a finding that leaves the judgment in your client's favor was held moot here (¶¶ 5–6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.