Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I raise a new claim against my HOA in a summary judgment response? Jensen v. Skypark Landowners Association

2013 UT App 48No. 20110756-CADecided Feb 22, 2013Real Property & Land UseAffirmed

Holding

Summary judgment for Skypark was proper because Jensen left Skypark’s facts uncontroverted and its challenge to Skypark’s validity was an unpleaded claim raised first in opposition; no claim remained for Jensen’s later partial summary judgment motion; and Jensen did not carry the burden of showing the fee provision was limited to lien foreclosure.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with Skypark Landowners Association on every issue and left the judgment and attorney fee award in place.

  • Facts a party does not dispute, with support from the record, are treated as admitted when the court decides a summary judgment motion.
  • A new claim raised for the first time in a response to a summary judgment motion was not considered, because it was not in the complaint.
  • The landowners lost their challenge to the fee award because they did not explain why the fee provision covered only lien foreclosure cases.

What happened?

Several landowners, including Jay and Eleanor Jensen and a company called Gas Busters, LLC, sued Skypark Landowners Association. The court calls the landowners “Jensen” as a group. Their complaint rested on the claim that the 1979 Declarations governing the development were not valid.

Skypark asked the trial court for summary judgment, meaning a ruling without a trial because the important facts are not really in dispute. In response, Jensen conceded that the 1979 Declarations were valid. Jensen then argued instead that Skypark was not properly incorporated under those declarations and so could not charge landowners maintenance fees.

The trial court granted summary judgment for Skypark, refused a later request for judgment on three wrongful lien claims, and awarded Skypark attorney fees. Jensen appealed.

Were there real factual disputes?

No, the court said. Under the court rules, each fact the moving party lists is treated as admitted unless the other side disputes it and points to support in the record. Jensen’s response left most of Skypark’s facts undisputed, and many of the ones it listed were actually admitted.

The main “dispute,” whether Skypark was a valid organization, was not a claim in the amended complaint. Jensen had tried to add it, but the trial court refused, and Jensen did not appeal that refusal. So the trial court was right not to consider a claim raised for the first time in response to the motion.

Jensen also argued on appeal that Skypark’s motion did not follow the summary judgment rule. Jensen first raised that in a motion for a new trial. The trial court denied that motion, except that it let Jay and Eleanor Jensen challenge the amount of the assessment on their property. Because Jensen did not appeal the denial, the court did not address those points.

What about the wrongful lien claims?

After summary judgment, Jensen asked for judgment on three wrongful lien claims. The trial court explained that its January 2011 order had already disposed of every claim. The Court of Appeals agreed: Skypark’s motion asked to dismiss all claims, and it was granted without exception. With nothing left pending, the later request was properly denied. Jensen’s argument that the order was unclear was waived, meaning given up, because Jensen never objected to the form of the order.

Why did the fee award stand?

Jensen admitted the parties’ agreement allowed fees but said it applied only to lien foreclosure cases. The court found that claim too bare. Jensen did not analyze the whole provision, which appeared to allow suits in law or equity to enforce payment of liens. An appealing party has the burden to persuade the court, and Jensen did not carry it.

What happens now?

Nothing more. The judgment for Skypark and the fee award stand. The court said any other arguments Jensen raised lacked merit.

What should people take from this?

A lawsuit is decided on the claims in the complaint. A response to a summary judgment motion has to dispute the other side’s facts directly, with record support, and a new theory raised there may not be considered.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme, Thorne and Roth, JJ.). Plaintiffs (collectively Jensen) appealed summary judgment for Skypark Landowners Association (Skypark), the denial of their motion for partial summary judgment, and an attorney fee award (¶ 1). The court affirmed all three (¶ 8).

Issue 1: Summary judgment (correctness, ¶ 2): affirmed (no error)

The trial court correctly held that Jensen raised no genuine issue of material fact. Under Utah R. Civ. P. 7(c)(3)(A)–(B), facts not controverted with record citations are deemed admitted; Jensen’s opposition left most facts uncontroverted and expressly admitted others despite “extra verbiage” (¶¶ 2–3). Only a genuinely controverted material fact precludes summary judgment, Heglar Ranch, Inc. v. Stillman, 619 P.2d 1390, 1391 (Utah 1980) (¶ 2).

Jensen’s main “dispute,” Skypark’s validity under the 1979 Declarations, was not pleaded in the amended complaint; the trial court denied leave to amend, and Jensen did not appeal that denial, so the issue is outside the appeal (¶ 4 & n.2). The court properly declined to consider claims raised for the first time in opposition, see Eldridge v. Farnsworth, 2007 UT App 243, ¶¶ 33, 40, 166 P.3d 639 (¶ 4). Disputes over assessment amounts failed for two plaintiffs, and the third’s was cured by an evidentiary hearing granted on the new trial motion (n.3). The rule 56 compliance argument was first raised in a motion for new trial whose denial was not appealed, so the court did not address it (¶ 5).

Issue 2: Denial of partial summary judgment on wrongful lien claims (none stated, ¶ 6): affirmed (no error)

The denial was proper because no claim remained pending. Skypark’s motion sought dismissal of all claims and was granted without reservation in January 2011 (¶ 6). Any argument that the January 2011 order was vague is waived for failure to object to the form of order, citing 438 Main St. v. Easy Heat, Inc., 2004 UT 72, ¶ 51, 99 P.3d 801 (n.4).

Issue 3: Attorney fees (none stated, ¶ 7): affirmed (no error)

Jensen did not show the contractual fee provision was limited to lien foreclosure actions. The assertion was conclusory, with no analysis of the whole provision, whose language “appears to permit suits in law or equity to enforce payment of liens” (¶ 7). The burden of persuasion is on the appellant, see State v. Robison, 2006 UT 65, ¶ 21, 147 P.3d 448, and Jensen did not carry it (¶ 7).

Disposition

Affirmed. Other arguments were rejected as without merit, citing State v. Carter, 776 P.2d 886, 888 (Utah 1989) (n.5).

Takeaways

  • Facts in a summary judgment motion not controverted with record citations are deemed admitted under rule 7(c)(3)(A) (¶¶ 2–3).
  • A claim first raised in opposition to summary judgment will not defeat the motion; if leave to amend is denied and not appealed, the claim is outside the appeal (¶ 4 & n.2).
  • Arguments raised only in a new trial motion are not reviewed when the denial of that motion is not appealed (¶ 5).
  • An appellant must analyze the whole contractual fee provision, not just assert a narrow reading (¶ 7).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Jensen v. Skypark Landowners Association
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 48
Case no.
20110756-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
February 22, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Jensen
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Landowners' claims against a landowners association, including wrongful lien claims and disputes over assessments, and an attorney fee award against the landowners

The panel

Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Second District Court, Farmington Department · Judge Thomas L. Kay

Parties & counsel

Jensen — AppellantOtherJerrald D. Conder
Skypark Landowners Association — AppelleeBusinessDonald J. WinderJohn W. Holt

Practice Tip

When opposing summary judgment, controvert each listed fact with record citations and keep to the pleaded claims; if leave to amend to add a new claim is denied, appeal that denial or the claim falls outside the appeal (¶¶ 2–4 & n.2).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.