Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Does my lender have to show the original note to foreclose? Howard v. CitiMortgage, et al.

2012 UT App 19No. 20110772-CADecided Jan 20, 2012Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed

Holding

Where the borrower raised no question about the duplicate note’s authenticity or fairness, PNC Mortgage did not need the original note to show it was the holder, and securitization and Fair Debt Collection Practices Act claims supported only by conclusory allegations were properly dismissed.

Practice areaCivil Appeals

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with PNC Mortgage and upheld the dismissal of all of Howard’s claims.

  • When nobody gives a reason to doubt that a copy of a note is accurate, a copy can be enough to show who holds the note.
  • Selling interests in a note as a security does not, on its own, change the rights under the trust deed; a borrower has to plead specific facts showing the documents did not allow it.
  • A complaint built on broad conclusions, without supporting facts, can be dismissed.

What happened?

J. Mark Howard sued PNC Mortgage, CitiMortgage, Inc., and others over the note and trust deed on his property. A trust deed is the document that secures a home loan with the property. Howard represented himself.

The district court dismissed his claims in a July 20, 2011 order, and Howard appealed. PNC Mortgage asked the Court of Appeals for “summary disposition,” a quick ruling without full proceedings, arguing his appeal was too weak to need more.

The court had also raised, on its own motion, whether the order was final enough to appeal. It withdrew that question after PNC Mortgage explained that it had prepared the order the district court signed.

Did PNC Mortgage have to show the original note?

No. Howard argued that PNC Mortgage had to produce the original note, not a photocopy, to prove it held the note. The court noted that courts generally accept photocopies when there is no evidence the copy differs from the original. Under Utah’s evidence rule on duplicates, a copy is admissible like an original unless its authenticity is questioned or using it would be unfair.

Here, Howard’s own complaint admitted that CitiMortgage assigned its rights in the note and trust deed to PNC Mortgage. PNC Mortgage attached a copy of the note, with an endorsement showing the transfer, to its verified answer. Howard gave no reason to doubt the copy, so the original was not needed.

Did selling the note as a security stop the foreclosure?

No. Howard argued that PNC Mortgage could not foreclose because his note had been pooled with others and sold as a security. The court relied on its earlier decision in Commonwealth Property Advocates, LLC v. Mortgage Electronic Registration System, Inc., 2011 UT App 232, 263 P.3d 397, which held that this kind of sale does not on its own change the rights under a trust deed.

To make that claim, a borrower must plead facts specific to his case showing the documents did not allow securitization. Howard did not, so those claims were properly dismissed.

What about the debt collection claim?

Howard also claimed a violation of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, a federal law on debt collection. The district court found the claim was “based entirely on legal conclusions.” The Court of Appeals reviewed the complaint itself and agreed: Howard made broad statements without the facts needed to back them up.

What happens now?

Nothing more. The dismissal stands, and the case is over at this level.

What should people take from this?

A lawsuit against a lender needs facts, not just conclusions. Questioning whether a copy of a note is good enough works only if there is a real reason to doubt it.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; McHugh, P.J., Thorne and Christiansen, JJ.), on PNC Mortgage’s motion for summary disposition (¶¶ 1, 7). Pleadings rulings are reviewed for correctness, and sufficiency turns on “the facts pleaded rather than the conclusions stated,” quoting Franco v. Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, 2001 UT 25, ¶ 26, 21 P.3d 198 (¶ 2). The court withdrew its own sua sponte motion on finality after PNC Mortgage confirmed it prepared the signed order, making Giusti v. Sterling Wentworth Corp., 2009 UT 2, 201 P.3d 966, inapplicable (¶ 1 n.1).

Issue 1: Dismissal of claims on the original-note and securitization theories (correctness, ¶¶ 3–5): affirmed (no error)

The court held that the district court correctly dismissed Howard’s claims, because neither the original-note theory nor the securitization theory stated a valid claim.

Part 1: Original note (¶¶ 3–4)

PNC Mortgage did not need to produce the original note to show it was the holder. The court followed the general rule that, absent evidence a copy is inexact, a photocopy suffices, quoting Dobson v. Substitute Trustee Services, Inc., 711 S.E.2d 728, 730 (N.C. Ct. App. 2011), and see also Utah R. Evid. 1003 (¶ 3). Howard’s complaint admitted CitiMortgage assigned its interest to PNC Mortgage, the note attached to the verified answer showed the endorsement chain, and Howard raised no authenticity or unfairness question (¶ 4).

Part 2: Securitization (¶ 5)

The securitization claims were properly dismissed. Under Commonwealth Property Advocates, LLC v. Mortgage Electronic Registration System, Inc., 2011 UT App 232, 263 P.3d 397, a transfer of the obligation also transfers the mortgage, and selling passive investment interests does not alone alter the trust deed’s rights or enforceability (¶ 5, citing id. ¶¶ 10, 13). A litigant must plead case-specific facts showing the documents barred securitization; Howard did not (¶ 5).

Issue 2: FDCPA claim (correctness, ¶ 6): affirmed (no error)

The FDCPA claim was properly dismissed. On its own review of the pleadings, the court agreed the claim consisted of conclusory allegations “unsupported by a recitation of relevant surrounding facts,” quoting Franco v. Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, 2001 UT 25, ¶ 36, 21 P.3d 198 (¶ 6).

Takeaways

  • Absent any challenge to authenticity or fairness, a duplicate note can establish holder status (¶¶ 3–4).
  • A borrower’s own admission of the assignment undercuts a “produce the original” theory (¶ 4).
  • Securitization claims need case-specific facts showing the loan documents did not allow it (¶ 5).
  • Conclusory FDCPA allegations do not survive a pleadings challenge (¶ 6).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Howard v. CitiMortgage, et al.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 19
Case no.
20110772-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
January 20, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Howard
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A homeowner's claims challenging PNC Mortgage's right to enforce his note and foreclose on his property, including a Fair Debt Collection Practices Act claim

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
William A. Thorne Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Provo Department · Judge Lynn W. Davis

Parties & counsel

Howard — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
CitiMortgage, et al. — AppelleeBusinessAnthony C. KayeAngela W. AdamsSteven D. Burt

Practice Tip

A challenge to a lender's use of a photocopied note needs a concrete reason to doubt the copy's authenticity or the fairness of relying on it under Utah R. Evid. 1003 (¶¶ 3–4); a securitization challenge must plead facts specific to the loan documents (¶ 5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.