Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal again after my first appeal was dismissed? In re J.R. and M.R. (J.R. v. State)

2011 UT App 429No. 20110927-CADecided Dec 15, 2011Juvenile & Child WelfareDismissed

Holding

Where a parent’s first appeal from a termination order was dismissed under Utah R. App. P. 55(a) and remitted, res judicata bars a later appeal, and re-entry of the identical order marked “amended” is a nunc pro tunc entry that does not enlarge the time for appeal, so the court lacks jurisdiction.

Practice areaFamily Law Appeals

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals dismissed the mother’s second appeal, so the order ending her parental rights stands.

  • When a termination appeal is dismissed for failure to file a petition on appeal, and the case is sent back to the juvenile court, the parent cannot later bring the same challenge in a new appeal.
  • Re-entering the same order with only “amended” added to the caption did not give the mother a new deadline to appeal.
  • Because her notice of appeal was late, the court had no power to hear the appeal.

What happened?

In April 2011 the juvenile court entered an order terminating the parental rights of J.R. (the mother) in her two minor children. Terminating parental rights means permanently ending the legal relationship between parent and child.

The mother filed a notice of appeal. But in a child welfare appeal, the parent must also file a “petition on appeal.” She did not, so the Court of Appeals dismissed that appeal in May 2011 under rule 55 of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure. In June 2011 the case was sent back to the juvenile court, which made it final.

On October 3, 2011, the juvenile court entered another termination order. It was identical to the April order except that “amended” was handwritten in the caption. The mother filed a new notice of appeal and, this time, a petition on appeal.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals dismissed the new appeal for two reasons.

First, the earlier appeal barred this one. Once the first appeal was dismissed and the mother did not seek any of the relief then available to get that dismissal reviewed, the dismissal counted as a decision on the merits. A legal rule called res judicata stops a party from relitigating issues that were raised, or could have been raised, in an earlier case. The court said her challenge “could have, and should have” been raised in the first appeal by filing a timely petition.

Second, the October order did not reset the clock for appealing. When a court re-enters a judgment without changing its substance, the new entry relates back to the date of the original judgment and does not extend the time to appeal. Here the only change was the word “amended.” So the October notice of appeal was measured from the April order, and it was too late. When an appeal is not filed on time, the court has no power to hear it.

Did the court say anything about the mother’s arguments?

In a footnote, the court noted the mother’s argument that ending her rights was not in the children’s best interests because it would not substantially change the status quo. The court responded that adoption is the preferred permanent placement and that foster care does not offer the same permanency, citing In re R.A.J., 1999 UT App 329, ¶ 23, 991 P.2d 1118, and In re J.D., 2011 UT App 184, ¶ 23, 257 P.3d 1062.

What happens now?

The appeal is dismissed. The order terminating the mother’s parental rights remains in place.

What should people take from this?

Appeals in termination cases have strict steps, including the petition on appeal. In this case, missing that step ended the first appeal, and re-entering the same order with a new label did not open the door to a second one.

Bottom line

Dismissed (per curiam; Orme, Voros, and Roth, JJ.). The mother’s first appeal from the April 2011 termination order was dismissed under Utah R. App. P. 55(a) for failure to file a petition on appeal, and remittitur issued in June 2011 (¶ 2). A second appeal from an identical October 2011 order is barred by res judicata and is untimely (¶¶ 4–5).

Issue 1: Second appeal of the termination order (none stated, ¶¶ 2–6): not reached

The court held it was “barred from considering this appeal” (¶ 3) on two grounds.

Res judicata (¶ 4). Because the first appeal was dismissed and the mother did not seek the relief then available to obtain review of the dismissal, the case was remitted and the “appeal became an adjudication on the merits,” following State v. Clark, 913 P.2d 360, 363 (Utah Ct. App. 1996). Res judicata bars issues raised or that could have been raised in prior litigation, State v. Garner, 2005 UT 6, ¶ 8, 106 P.3d 729, and the issue here could have been raised in the first appeal by a timely petition.

Untimeliness (¶ 5). A belated entry that does not change the substance of the judgment is a nunc pro tunc entry that relates back and “does not enlarge the time for appeal” (quoting State v. Garner, 2005 UT 6, ¶ 11, 106 P.3d 729). The October order differed only by a handwritten “amended” in the caption, so the October notice of appeal was untimely from the April judgment, and the court lacked jurisdiction, citing Serrato v. Utah Transit Auth., 2000 UT App 299, ¶ 7, 13 P.3d 616.

Footnote 1 (¶ 6 n.1) adds a response to the mother’s best-interests argument that termination would not substantially change the status quo: adoption is the preferred permanent placement, citing In re R.A.J., 1999 UT App 329, ¶ 23, 991 P.2d 1118, and In re J.D., 2011 UT App 184, ¶ 23, 257 P.3d 1062.

Disposition

Appeal dismissed (¶ 6).

Takeaways

  • After a rule 55(a) dismissal and remittitur, without seeking review of the dismissal, the court treated the first appeal as an adjudication on the merits barring a later challenge to the same termination (¶ 4).
  • Re-entering an identical order with only “amended” in the caption is a nunc pro tunc entry that relates back and does not restart the appeal period (¶ 5).
  • An untimely notice of appeal leaves the court without jurisdiction (¶ 5).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
In re J.R. and M.R. (J.R. v. State)
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 429
Case no.
20110927-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
December 15, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
A mother's second appeal from the juvenile court's order terminating her parental rights in her two minor children.

The panel

J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Fourth Juvenile Court, Provo Department · Judge Kay A. Lindsay

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)David R. Boyer
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyMark L. ShurtleffJohn M. Peterson
Guardian ad litemOtherMartha Pierce

Practice Tip

In a child welfare appeal, file the petition on appeal on time; the court held that re-entering an identical order with only "amended" in the caption did not restart the appeal period (¶¶ 4–5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.