Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Can old mistakes be raised in a second parental-rights appeal? In re J.A.C.

2026 UT 27No. 20231128Decided Jul 30, 2026Juvenile & Child WelfareAffirmed

Holding

Under A.S. v. R.S., 2017 UT 77, a jurisdictional defect in a prior appeal cannot be challenged after the time to seek certiorari on that decision lapses, and errors predating that appeal and not raised in it are likewise beyond review; the post-remand termination order was not against the clear weight of the evidence.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court upheld the juvenile court’s order ending the mother’s parental rights, though it refused to throw out her appeal entirely.

  • Once the time to seek review of an appeals court’s earlier decision has passed, parties can no longer argue that the court lacked power to make that decision.
  • The same rule kept the mother from raising complaints about events before her first appeal that she did not raise in that appeal.
  • The court upheld the juvenile court’s decision that ending the mother’s rights was strictly necessary for the children’s best interest.

What happened?

The State removed two boys, J.A.C. and A.E.C., from their parents in 2015 and again in 2019 after finding neglect. The boys were placed with a foster family in Tennessee that wanted to adopt them. The State then asked the juvenile court to end the parental rights of C.T.M. (the mother, called “Mother” in the opinion). This is called termination of parental rights. The court did so in an order dated August 3, 2021.

Mother’s lawyer filed her appeal in the wrong court, so it was late and was dismissed. The juvenile court then set aside and re-entered its order so she could appeal again. Before the appeal was decided, the parties mediated and jointly asked the Court of Appeals to reverse, because the juvenile court had not explained why it rejected options short of termination. The Court of Appeals agreed and sent the case back.

After a second trial, the juvenile court again ended Mother’s rights in a December 17, 2023 order. Mother appealed, and the Court of Appeals sent the case to the Utah Supreme Court.

What did each side argue?

The guardian ad litem, a lawyer who represents the children’s interests, argued the whole appeal had to be dismissed because the first appeal was filed late. The State agreed there was a problem with jurisdiction, meaning the court’s power to hear the case. Mother argued that the issue was settled when the Court of Appeals reversed without objection. She also wanted to raise problems going back to 2019, including that she had no lawyer for a long stretch.

Could the court hear the appeal at all?

Yes. Relying on A.S. v. R.S., 2017 UT 77, 416 P.3d 465, the court held that once the time to seek review of the Court of Appeals’ reversal passed, no party could challenge that court’s power to issue it.

But the same reasoning cut against Mother. She could not raise complaints about events before her first appeal, because she did not raise them in that appeal. The court said it was “troubled” that she was unrepresented for nearly a year and a half, but it could not reach that issue. It also refused to consider her argument about J.A.C. possibly refusing to consent to adoption, because she had not raised it in the juvenile court.

Did the termination stand?

Yes. The court reviews these decisions only to see whether they go against the “clear weight of the evidence,” giving the juvenile court real deference. The juvenile court had found the boys lacked the capacity to give meaningful opinions on adoption, and Mother did not challenge that finding. It also found she was uninterested in the boys’ significant needs, and her therapist said four sessions were not enough to judge her parenting.

The court also considered permanent custody and guardianship, where the foster parents would raise the boys while Mother kept some rights. It found that would not protect the boys equally, given Mother’s trouble respecting the foster family’s boundaries. Mother did not show that finding was wrong.

Did all the justices agree?

Yes. Justice Nielsen joined the opinion but wrote separately. He explained why a late appeal is not a defect in subject-matter jurisdiction (the kinds of cases a court may hear), and said that kind of defect might be treated differently.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The order ending Mother’s parental rights stands.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Pohlman, A.C.J., joined by Durrant, C.J., Petersen, J., Nielsen, J., and Judge Neider; Nielsen, J., concurring). The court rejected the guardian ad litem’s argument that the entire appeal must be dismissed, held that it lacked jurisdiction over alleged errors predating the first appeal, and upheld the December 17 termination order (¶¶ 2–3, 108).

Threshold: jurisdiction over the appeal (¶¶ 46–74)

Mother’s first notice of appeal was untimely under Utah R. App. P. 52(a), and the juvenile court then used rule 60(b)(1) to re-enter the order (¶¶ 50–52). The Court of Appeals later granted a stipulated motion to reverse without addressing jurisdiction, which implicitly exercised jurisdiction; the reversal was a merits ruling (¶ 60 & n.7). Following A.S. v. R.S., 2017 UT 77, 416 P.3d 465, “the ability to raise questions of jurisdiction expires after the last available opportunity to appeal final judgments” on those issues (¶ 70). Once the certiorari period lapsed, no party could challenge the alleged defect (¶ 71). The court did not decide whether the Court of Appeals actually had jurisdiction (n.8). The timely appeal from the December 17 order is properly before the court (¶ 74 & n.9).

Issue 1: Pre-remand due process and structural error claims (correctness, ¶ 75): not reached

The court lacks jurisdiction over Mother’s due process challenges, including the 2019 failure to appoint counsel. The finality reasoning that bars the GAL also bars Mother from raising errors that predate the reversal but were not raised in the first appeal (¶¶ 76–77). Her first petition on appeal raised only two issues, and nothing in the stipulation reserved others (¶¶ 78–79). The court was “troubled” by the lack of counsel but could not reach it (¶ 80).

Issue 2: DCFS reasonable efforts (correctness, ¶ 75): not reached

This challenge, which also predates the first appeal, is barred for the same reasons (¶¶ 75–79).

Issue 3: Cumulative error (correctness, ¶ 75): not reached

Because it rests on errors outside the court’s jurisdiction, the court could not reach it (¶ 75).

Issue 4: J.A.C.’s possible refusal to consent to adoption (none stated, ¶ 82 n.12): not reached

The argument was waived as unpreserved. Mother did not dispute the GAL’s preservation argument or identify where it was raised, citing In re D.S., 2025 UT 11, ¶ 64, 568 P.3d 1060 (n.12).

Issue 5: Children’s testimony (clearly erroneous, ¶ 43): affirmed (no error)

Mother did not show error in the court’s assessment of the boys’ wishes. She did not challenge the finding that they lacked “sufficient capacity to express meaningful opinions” about the outcome, which governs under Utah Code § 80-4-303(1)(a) (¶¶ 89, 91). The court’s distinctions were defensible (¶ 90), and the statute does not turn the decision over to the child (¶ 92).

Issue 6: Present parental fitness (clearly erroneous, ¶ 43): affirmed (no error)

The fitness concerns were not against the clear weight of the evidence. Mother did not engage with evidence supporting the findings, including her therapist’s admission that four sessions could not support an assessment (¶¶ 93–98). Present-ability evidence is not dispositive (n.14, citing In re B.R., 2007 UT 82, ¶ 13, 171 P.3d 435).

Issue 7: Strict necessity vs. permanent custody and guardianship (clearly erroneous, ¶ 43): affirmed (no error)

The juvenile court permissibly found guardianship would not equally protect and benefit the children (¶¶ 100, 107). It relied on boundary violations, Mother’s parenting deficits, and the children’s inability to distinguish guardian from parent (¶¶ 102–106), consistent with In re K.R., 2023 UT App 75, ¶ 15, 533 P.3d 1165 (per curiam) (¶ 101).

Separate opinion

Justice Nielsen concurred, joining fully. He views an untimely notice of appeal as a case-specific defect, not a defect in subject-matter jurisdiction, and would read A.S. as limited to such defects. He left open how finality applies to subject-matter jurisdiction (¶¶ 109–118 & n.17).

Takeaways

  • A jurisdictional objection not pressed before the certiorari period on a prior appellate decision lapses is foreclosed in a later appeal (¶ 71).
  • Errors that could have been raised in a first appeal cannot be raised after a stipulated reversal and remand absent a reservation (¶¶ 76–79).
  • A challenge to discounting a child’s wishes fails without a successful attack on the capacity finding (¶ 91).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
In re J.A.C.
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2026 UT 27
Case no.
20231128
Filed
2023
Decided
July 30, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Termination of a mother's parental rights to her two sons, who were living with a Tennessee foster family willing to adopt them

The panel

Jill M. PohlmanAuthor
NielsenConcurring opinion
DentDid not participate
Diana HagenDid not participate
Jay T. JorgensenDid not participate
John A. PearceDid not participate
Matthew B. DurrantConcurred
Camille L. NeiderConcurred
Paige PetersenConcurred
Trial court
Fourth District Juvenile Court, Utah County · Judge F. Richards Smith III

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Alexandra MareschalKirstin NormanJason B. RichardsDebra M. Nelson
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyDerek E. Brown, Utah Attorney General's OfficeDeborah A. Wood, Utah Attorney General's OfficeJohn M. Peterson, Utah Attorney General's Office
Guardian ad litemOtherMartha PierceAlisha GilesHeath Haacke

Practice Tip

If an appellate court reverses by stipulation despite an unresolved jurisdictional question, raise it before the certiorari period runs, and expressly reserve any other issues you may want to raise after remand (¶¶ 71, 78–79).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.