Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I ask the trial court to undo a judgment I never appealed? Dennett v. Ferber

2013 UT App 209No. 20120413-CADecided Aug 22, 2013Real Property & Land UseAffirmed

Holding

A rule 60(b) ruling is a separately appealable order requiring its own notice of appeal, and a trial court does not abuse its discretion in denying a rule 60(b)(6) motion that merely reargues legal errors the movant failed to raise in a timely direct appeal.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with Stewart Ferber, affirming the district court and awarding him attorney fees for the appeal.

  • A ruling on a rule 60(b) motion is its own appealable order, so a party must file a notice of appeal after that ruling to challenge it.
  • A rule 60(b)(6) motion cannot be used to argue legal errors that should have been raised in a timely appeal.
  • A party who received attorney fees below and wins the appeal is generally entitled to fees on appeal as well.

What happened?

Donald Dennett and Wakara Elk Ventures, LLC were the plaintiffs, and Stewart Ferber was the defendant who also filed counterclaims. A judgment was entered in 2011 that included attorney fees for Ferber, partly because he won an unlawful detainer claim (a type of eviction claim).

On April 17, 2012, the district court denied a motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction and granted a motion for sanctions, which included filing restrictions on Dennett and Wakara. Both appealed that order.

Meanwhile, they asked the district court under rule 60(b) of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure to set aside various orders. The court denied that request on December 27, 2012. Wakara then filed an amended notice of appeal. Dennett did not.

Could the court hear everything they raised?

No. A ruling on a rule 60(b) motion is a separate order that needs its own notice of appeal (the paper that starts an appeal). Wakara’s amended notice was filed on time and showed it meant to appeal, so the court took up Wakara’s challenge. Dennett filed nothing after the December order, so the court said it had no power to hear his challenges to it.

What about the sanctions and filing limits?

Both argued the filing limits violated the Open Courts Clause, a part of the Utah Constitution that protects access to the courts. The court explained that filing limits can be valid if the trial court gives certain protections. But Dennett and Wakara offered no analysis of whether those protections were given, so the court declined to decide the point.

They also objected to the district court’s statement that the time to appeal had expired. The court declined this too, because they gave no legal analysis and did not explain how they were harmed.

Wakara also raised claims for other people: Wesley and Karolee Dennett, who never appealed, and Donald Dennett, whom the district court sanctioned. The court said Wakara can argue only its own interests, so those claims were not properly before it. Donald Dennett tried to raise the sanctions point himself, but it came from the rule 60(b) ruling he never appealed.

Did Wakara’s rule 60(b) motion succeed?

No. Rule 60(b)(6) is for unusual and exceptional situations and is not a substitute for an appeal. Wakara only argued that the court’s original decisions were wrong and never explained why it did not appeal them directly. The court held the district court did not abuse its discretion, meaning it did not act outside the range of reasonable choices, in denying the motion.

What happens now?

The orders stand. Because Ferber received attorney fees in the district court and won the appeal, he is entitled to reasonable fees for the appeal. The district court will set the amount.

What should people take from this?

Each party who wants to challenge a new order must file its own notice of appeal from that order. And a request to set aside a judgment cannot replace a timely appeal.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme, McHugh, and Roth, JJ.) (¶ 12). Dennett and Wakara Elk Ventures, LLC, the plaintiffs and counterclaim defendants, appealed an April 17, 2012 order denying a post-judgment motion to dismiss and granting sanctions. Wakara then amended its notice to add the December 27, 2012 denial of rule 60(b) relief (¶¶ 1–2). The rule 60(b)(6) denial stands because Wakara used the motion in place of an appeal it never took (¶ 10). Ferber, the defendant and counterclaim plaintiff, is entitled to fees on appeal (¶ 11).

Issue 1: Jurisdiction over Dennett’s rule 60(b) challenges (none stated, ¶¶ 2–4): not reached

The court lacked jurisdiction over Dennett’s challenges to the rule 60(b) ruling because he filed no notice of appeal after it. A rule 60(b) ruling is a separate appealable order that cannot be folded into an existing appeal, citing Amica Mut. Ins. Co. v. Schettler, 768 P.2d 950, 970 (Utah Ct. App. 1989), and Utah R. App. P. 4(a) (¶ 3). Wakara should have filed a new notice and sought consolidation. Its timely amended notice was enough to show intent to appeal, so the court took jurisdiction over Wakara’s challenge (¶ 3). Dennett’s appeal was limited to his two issues from the April 17 order (¶ 4).

Issue 2: Open Courts Clause challenge to filing restrictions (none stated, ¶ 5): not reached

The court declined the argument as inadequately briefed under Utah R. App. P. 24(a)(9). Filing restrictions may be valid if the court gives safeguards sufficient for due process, under Gardiner v. York, 2010 UT App 108, ¶ 25, 233 P.3d 500. The appellants offered no analysis of whether the district court complied with those requirements (¶ 5), citing Broderick v. Apartment Mgmt. Consultants, LLC, 2012 UT 17, ¶ 11, 279 P.3d 391.

Issue 3: Statement that the time to appeal had expired (none stated, ¶ 6): not reached

The court declined this claim as inadequately briefed. There was no legal analysis and no showing of harm, since the court had reviewed the record itself to set the scope of its jurisdiction (¶ 6).

Issue 4: Denial of Wesley and Karolee Dennett’s motion to dismiss (none stated, ¶ 7): not reached

The claim was not properly before the court. No notice of appeal was filed for Wesley and Karolee Dennett, so they are not parties to the appeal (Utah R. App. P. 3(b)) (¶ 7).

Issue 5: Sanctioning Dennett but not Wakara’s counsel (none stated, ¶ 7, n.1): not reached

Wakara cannot raise this claim on Dennett’s behalf, under Provo City Corp. v. Thompson, 2004 UT 14, ¶ 9, 86 P.3d 735 (¶ 7). Dennett’s own attempt to raise it failed for lack of jurisdiction. The issue was preserved only in the rule 60(b) motion, and he did not appeal that ruling (¶ 7 n.1).

Issue 6: Denial of Wakara’s rule 60(b)(6) motion (abuse of discretion, ¶ 8): affirmed (no error)

The district court did not abuse its discretion. Rule 60(b)(6) is to be invoked “only in unusual and exceptional circumstances” and is not a substitute for appeal, per Kell v. State, 2012 UT 25, ¶ 18, 285 P.3d 1133 (¶ 9). Legal errors belong in a timely appeal, per Franklin Covey Client Sales, Inc. v. Melvin, 2000 UT App 110, ¶ 21, 2 P.3d 451 (¶ 9). Wakara did not explain why the alleged errors were not raised on direct appeal from the 2011 judgment. It only argued that the original decisions were wrong (¶ 10).

Issue 7: Attorney fees on appeal (none stated, ¶ 11): Ferber’s request for attorney fees on appeal granted

Ferber is entitled to reasonable fees on appeal. The judgment below included fees based partly on his unlawful detainer win under Utah Code § 78B‐6‐811(3). A party awarded fees below who prevails on appeal generally recovers appellate fees, under Robertson’s Marine, Inc. v. 14 Solutions, Inc., 2010 UT App 9, ¶ 8, 223 P.3d 1141. The district court will set the amount (¶ 11).

Takeaways

  • File a new notice of appeal from a rule 60(b) ruling, then move to consolidate. Each party must do so; an amended notice from one party does not cover another (¶¶ 3–4).
  • A filing-restriction challenge needs analysis of the Gardiner v. York, 2010 UT App 108, ¶ 25, 233 P.3d 500 safeguards, or it may go unaddressed (¶ 5).
  • A rule 60(b)(6) motion that only reargues the merits after the appeal time has run will not succeed (¶ 10).
  • An entity appellant cannot press claims belonging to another party, such as a sanction imposed on a co-appellant (¶ 7).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Dennett v. Ferber
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 209
Case no.
20120413-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
August 22, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Dennett
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
An order imposing sanctions and filing restrictions on Dennett and Wakara, and the denial of their rule 60(b) motion for relief from a judgment that included attorney fees for Ferber on his unlawful detainer claim

The panel

Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Fifth District Court, St. George Department · Judge James L. Shumate

Parties & counsel

Dennett — AppellantOtherSelf-represented
Ferber — AppelleeIndividual(s)Russell J. GallianMatthew D. Ekins

Practice Tip

After a rule 60(b) ruling enters during a pending appeal, each party wanting review should file a new notice of appeal and seek consolidation; Dennett's failure to file anything left the court without jurisdiction over his challenges (2013 UT App 209, ¶¶ 3–4).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.