Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Is an “all or nothing” murder defense ineffective? State v. Feldmiller

2013 UT App 275No. 20120862-CADecided Nov 21, 2013Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Defense counsel’s consulted, strategic choice to reject lesser-offense instructions and forgo a special mitigation instruction under Utah Code section 76-5-205.5 in favor of an “all or nothing” defense was not ineffective assistance, and because the alleged instructional error resulted from that strategy, the court would not review it for plain error.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Feldmiller’s murder conviction.

  • A defense lawyer’s deliberate choice to give the jury only two options, murder or acquittal, was a reasonable trial strategy in this case.
  • When the defense chooses that strategy on purpose, the appeals court will not review a claim that the judge should have given a lesser instruction anyway.
  • Feldmiller’s murder conviction stands.

What happened?

William Robert Feldmiller was charged with murder. Before trial, he asked the court to give the jury instructions on two lesser crimes, manslaughter and negligent homicide, and on self-defense. The court allowed the self-defense instruction.

During the trial, the judge agreed to give a reckless manslaughter instruction but decided there was not enough evidence for a negligent homicide instruction. Feldmiller’s lawyer asked for time to talk with him. Afterward, the lawyer said Feldmiller did not want the manslaughter instruction either, because the two instructions were a “package together.”

In closing argument, the lawyer told the jury that Feldmiller may have done something wrong but could not be guilty of murder because he lacked the required intent, and that lesser crimes were not “on the table.” The jury convicted him of murder.

What did Feldmiller argue on appeal?

He made two arguments. First, his lawyer was ineffective, meaning the lawyer’s work fell below a reasonable standard and hurt the case, because the lawyer did not ask for a “special mitigation” instruction under Utah Code section 76-5-205.5, which the court describes as based on extreme emotional distress. Second, the judge should have given that instruction on the judge’s own, even though no one asked for it.

Was his lawyer ineffective?

No. To win this kind of claim, Feldmiller had to show there was no conceivable strategic reason for what his lawyer did. The court found a clear reason: the lawyer believed the State had overcharged Feldmiller and could not prove the intent needed for murder, so he chose, after consulting Feldmiller, to keep the jury from convicting on a lesser charge.

The court pointed out that Utah courts have recognized this “all or nothing” approach before. It also relied on State v. Campos, 2013 UT App 213, ¶ 36, 309 P.3d 1160, where a lawyer reasonably skipped a special mitigation instruction to pursue self-defense. Given the wide room lawyers have to make strategy choices at trial, the court could not say the lawyer acted unreasonably.

Should the judge have given the instruction anyway?

The court did not decide this. Feldmiller admitted he had not raised it at trial, so he asked the court to apply “plain error” review, a narrow exception for obvious, harmful mistakes the trial judge should have caught.

That exception does not apply when the claimed error came from the defense’s own strategic choice. Because the all or nothing defense was a legitimate strategy, the court said it was not the judge’s job to second-guess it or force a different one. So it declined to review this claim.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The conviction was affirmed.

What should people take from this?

When a defendant and the defense lawyer deliberately choose to give the jury only two options, convict of the top charge or acquit, a court may treat that as a reasonable strategy. That choice can also block a later complaint that the judge should have offered the jury a lesser option.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme, Davis and McHugh, JJ.). Feldmiller’s counsel, after consulting him, rejected a manslaughter instruction and did not seek a special mitigation instruction in order to pursue an “all or nothing” defense to murder. That was a legitimate strategy, which defeats both the ineffective-assistance claim (¶¶ 2–4) and plain error review of the court’s failure to instruct sua sponte (¶¶ 5–6).

Issue 1: Ineffective assistance for not requesting special mitigation (ineffective assistance, ¶¶ 2–4): affirmed (no error)

Counsel did not perform deficiently by failing to request a special mitigation instruction under Utah Code section 76-5-205.5. Under Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668, 689 (1984), and State v. Clark, 2004 UT 25, ¶ 6, 89 P.3d 162, Feldmiller had to show “no conceivable tactical basis” for counsel’s action (¶ 2). The record showed counsel opposed the manslaughter instruction once negligent homicide was refused, calling them a “package together,” and argued in closing that Feldmiller lacked the intent for murder and that lesser offenses were not “on the table” (¶ 3; cf. State v. Dyer, 671 P.2d 142, 145 (Utah 1983)). The court followed State v. Campos, 2013 UT App 213, ¶ 36, 309 P.3d 1160, which upheld counsel’s choice of one theory over another, especially arguably inconsistent ones, and held counsel reasonably pursued a strategy that would not let the jury convict on a lesser charge (¶ 4).

Issue 2: Plain error in not giving the instruction sua sponte (plain error, ¶¶ 5–6): not reached

The court declined plain error review because the alleged error resulted from Feldmiller’s strategic decision. Feldmiller conceded the claim was unpreserved (¶ 5). Plain error review “is inappropriate” when the error resulted from the appellant’s strategic decision, State v. McNeil, 2013 UT App 134, ¶ 13, 302 P.3d 844, and a conscious strategic choice that is not ineffective assistance forecloses review of the trial court’s ruling, State v. Bullock, 791 P.2d 155, 159 (Utah 1989) (¶ 5). It was not the district court’s province to question the defense’s strategy or force a different one (¶ 6).

Takeaways

  • A record showing counsel consulted the client and then deliberately kept lesser offenses from the jury supports a finding of a conceivable tactical basis (¶¶ 3–4).
  • Choosing an all or nothing defense over special mitigation can be reasonable, following State v. Campos, 2013 UT App 213, ¶ 36, 309 P.3d 1160 (¶ 4).
  • Once the strategy is found legitimate, plain error review of the court’s failure to give the omitted instruction sua sponte is unavailable (¶ 6).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
State v. Feldmiller
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 275
Case no.
20120862-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
November 21, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Feldmiller
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A murder conviction after a jury trial in which defense counsel pursued an "all or nothing" defense.

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Eighth District Court, Vernal Department · Judge Edwin T. Peterson

Parties & counsel

Feldmiller — AppellantIndividual(s)Daniel S. SamRyan B. Evershed
State — AppelleeState of UtahJohn E. SwallowRyan D. Tenney

Practice Tip

A record showing counsel conferred with the client and then argued that lesser offenses were not "on the table" was enough to show a strategic basis that defeated both ineffective-assistance and plain error claims (¶¶ 3–6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.