Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Does an appeal filed before a counterclaim is decided count? Ziegenbusch v. Westminster College

2013 UT App 2No. 20120946-CADecided Jan 4, 2013otherDismissed

Holding

A notice of appeal filed while the defendant’s counterclaim was pending was premature and not saved by rule 4(c), and a “renewal” notice filed more than thirty days after the final order was untimely, so the court lacked jurisdiction and dismissed the appeal (2013 UT App 2, ¶¶ 4–8).

Key takeaways

Westminster College won, as the Court of Appeals dismissed Ziegenbusch’s appeal because one notice of appeal came too early and the other too late.

  • A notice of appeal filed while a counterclaim is still pending does not start an appeal, because there is no final order yet.
  • A too-early notice cannot be “renewed” later, so a new notice must be filed within 30 days after the final order.
  • The Court of Appeals said that even if the other side failed to serve notice that the judgment was entered, that does not change the time to appeal.

What happened?

Jeremy Ziegenbusch sued Westminster College, and the college filed a counterclaim, meaning its own claim against him in the same case. In 2011 the trial court granted summary judgment for Westminster, which means it ruled without a trial, and dismissed Ziegenbusch’s claims. He filed a notice of appeal in October 2011, while the counterclaim was still waiting to be decided.

In mid-2012 the trial court took up the counterclaim and granted summary judgment to Westminster on it too. The final order was entered on August 10, 2012. Ziegenbusch filed a second notice, called a “renewal of notice of appeal,” on September 28, 2012.

What did each side argue?

Westminster asked the court to dismiss the appeal through a motion for summary disposition, a request to decide the appeal quickly without full proceedings. It argued that the notice of appeal was untimely, so the court had no jurisdiction (power to hear the case).

Ziegenbusch argued that a rule that saves some early notices of appeal applied to his October 2011 notice. He also said Westminster never served him with notice that the judgment had been entered.

What did the court decide?

The court agreed with Westminster and dismissed the appeal. It held that neither notice worked, for different reasons.

The October 2011 notice was too early. An appeal generally must come from a final order, one that ends the whole dispute between the parties. A ruling on the plaintiff’s claims is not final while a counterclaim is still pending.

The September 2012 notice was too late. A notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days after the final order is entered, and this one came well after that.

Did the rule for early notices help?

No. Rule 4(c) of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure treats a notice as filed on time when it comes after a decision is announced but before the formal order is entered. The court said that rule covers appeals from final decisions. Ziegenbusch’s 2011 notice came after an in-between (interlocutory) order, months before the counterclaim was even before the court. So the early notice was “simply ineffective” and could not be renewed.

What about the missing notice of judgment?

The court said that even if Westminster failed to serve notice of the judgment, under the civil rules that failure does not change the time for filing a notice of appeal.

What happens now?

The appeal is over. Because the court lacked jurisdiction, it had to dismiss and did not consider whether the trial court’s rulings were right.

What should people take from this?

When a case has claims and counterclaims, the time to appeal usually starts only after everything is decided. An early notice does not carry forward, and a new one must be filed within 30 days of the final order.

Bottom line

Dismissed (per curiam; Orme, Davis and Christiansen, JJ.). Neither notice of appeal invoked the court’s jurisdiction: the October 2011 notice was premature and the September 28, 2012 notice was untimely (¶¶ 3, 8).

Issue 1: Jurisdiction over the appeal (none stated, ¶¶ 3–8): Westminster’s motion for summary disposition granted

The court lacks jurisdiction because the first notice was premature and the second was late. An order is final when it “ends the controversy between the parties,” and summary judgment on a plaintiff’s claims is not final while a counterclaim is pending (¶ 4, citing Bradbury v. Valencia, 2000 UT 50, ¶¶ 8–9, 5 P.3d 649). The final order on the counterclaim was entered August 10, 2012, so the September 28, 2012 notice fell outside rule 4(a)’s thirty days (¶ 5, citing Serrato v. Utah Transit Auth., 2000 UT App 299, ¶ 7, 13 P.3d 616).

Rule 4(c) did not save the 2011 notice. That provision covers a notice filed after a decision is announced but before entry, and rule 4 governs appeals as of right from final orders. The 2011 notice followed an interlocutory order, months before the counterclaim was even before the trial court, so it “was simply ineffective and cannot be ‘renewed’” (¶ 6).

Ziegenbusch’s point that Westminster did not serve notice of entry of judgment under rule 58A(d) fails because, even if correct, that failure does not affect the time for filing a notice of appeal (¶ 7).

Disposition

Where the court lacks jurisdiction, it must dismiss (¶ 8, citing Bradbury v. Valencia, 2000 UT 50, ¶ 8, 5 P.3d 649). The merits were not considered.

Takeaways

  • Summary judgment on the plaintiff’s claims is not final while a counterclaim remains pending (¶ 4).
  • Rule 4(c) does not reach a notice filed after an interlocutory order. Such a notice is ineffective and cannot be renewed after the final order (¶ 6).
  • A failure to serve notice of entry of judgment under rule 58A(d) does not affect the time to file a notice of appeal (¶ 7).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Ziegenbusch v. Westminster College
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 2
Case no.
20120946-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
January 4, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Ziegenbusch
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
Summary judgments dismissing Ziegenbusch's claims and granting Westminster College's counterclaim

The panel

Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, West Jordan Department · Judge Andrew H. Stone

Parties & counsel

Ziegenbusch — AppellantIndividual(s)Loren M. Lambert
Westminster College — AppelleeBusinessRobert H. WildeBruce M. FransonMichael S. Wilde

Practice Tip

When a counterclaim remains pending after your client's claims are dismissed, calendar a new notice of appeal within thirty days of the final order on the counterclaim; an earlier notice after an interlocutory order cannot be renewed (¶¶ 4–6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.