Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I undo a court loss because my lawyer did a poor job? Mojo Syndicate v.Fredrickson

2013 UT App 6No. 20110995-CADecided Jan 10, 2013Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed

Holding

There is no constitutional right to effective representation in a civil case, and the district court properly granted summary judgment where the opposition memorandum failed rule 7(c)(3)(B) and the plaintiffs’ claims were inconsistent with the Asset Purchase Agreement and their own deposition testimony.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the defendants, John Fredrickson and 3928 LLC, upholding their win and their fee award and granting them fees for the appeal.

  • In a civil case, the court said there is no constitutional right to effective representation, and it would not reverse a judgment because of a former lawyer’s alleged poor work.
  • A response to a summary judgment motion that does not follow rule 7’s format, with each disputed fact restated and backed by record citations, can lead the court to treat the other side’s facts as undisputed.
  • An argument against attorney fees that was never made in the district court was not considered on appeal.

What happened?

Mojo Syndicate, Inc. and A Bar Named Sue LLC (the plaintiffs, called the “Mojo Plaintiffs” by the court) signed an Asset Purchase Agreement for the sale of the bar’s assets to 3928 LLC. They later signed a Closing Memorandum giving a $40,000 credit against the price, signed a document ending the bar’s lease, and gave up the liquor license.

They then sued John Fredrickson and 3928 LLC (the defendants). Their main claim was that Fredrickson led Mark and Judith Peterson, Mojo Syndicate’s principals, to believe Mark Peterson would stay on as a partner in the bar.

The district court granted summary judgment, which means it decided the case without a trial because the key facts were not genuinely disputed. It also awarded the defendants attorney fees under the Agreement.

Could the plaintiffs appeal at all?

Yes. The defendants argued the appeal was too late, but the court disagreed. The plaintiffs had filed a motion asking the district court to reconsider under rule 59, and that motion paused the deadline to appeal. The notice of appeal came within thirty days after that motion was denied.

Did blaming the former lawyer help?

No. The plaintiffs, with new lawyers on appeal, argued their earlier lawyer did a poor job. The court said there is no constitutional right to effective representation in a civil case, and no basis to reverse a judgment for that reason.

Was summary judgment proper?

Yes. Rule 7 requires the side opposing summary judgment to restate each fact it disputes and point to evidence in the record. The district court struck the plaintiffs’ first response for not doing this and let them try again. The second response also fell short. It mostly disagreed and asked rhetorical questions without citations. So the court could treat the defendants’ facts as undisputed.

The court also agreed there was no real factual dispute. The partnership claim was “clearly inconsistent” with the Agreement. The idea of a later spoken change to the deal conflicted with the plaintiffs’ own testimony that no further talks happened.

Did they get enough chance to gather evidence?

Yes. The plaintiffs canceled Fredrickson’s deposition and asked for more discovery (the pretrial exchange of evidence) only on the eve of the summary judgment hearing. The district court properly denied that request as untimely.

What about attorney fees?

The plaintiffs argued fees should not cover tort claims. They never raised that point in the district court, so the appeals court would not consider it. Below, they had challenged only whether the fees were reasonable, and on appeal they did not show the district court’s findings on that were wrong.

What happens now?

The judgment stands. Because the Agreement provides for attorney fees, the defendants also get their reasonable fees and costs for the appeal. The case goes back to the district court only to set that amount.

What should people take from this?

Following court rules on how to oppose summary judgment matters. And arguments not made to the trial court generally cannot be raised for the first time on appeal.

Bottom line

Affirmed, with a remand only to set appellate fees (per curiam; Orme, Davis and Thorne, JJ.). The court first rejected the Fredrickson Defendants’ jurisdiction challenge: the plaintiffs’ rule 59 motion could be used to challenge a summary judgment, so it tolled the time to appeal, and the notice of appeal was filed within thirty days of the August 30, 2011 order denying it (¶ 2; see Moon Lake Elec. Ass’n v. Ultrasystems W. Constructors, Inc., 767 P.2d 125, 128 (Utah Ct. App. 1988)).

Issue 1: Summary judgment (none stated, ¶¶ 3–6): affirmed (no error)

The summary judgment stands: the plaintiffs’ challenges to counsel’s performance, their rule 7 noncompliance, the absence of a genuine factual dispute, and their claimed lack of discovery all failed (¶¶ 3–6).

Part 1: Inadequate representation, rule 7(c)(3)(B), and genuine dispute of material fact (¶¶ 3–5)

Inadequate representation by retained counsel is no ground for reversal, because there is no constitutional right to effective representation in a civil case (¶ 3). The plaintiffs’ second opposition, like the first, which the court had struck, did not comply with rule 7(c)(3)(B). It “did little more than state a disagreement” and posed rhetorical questions without citations, so the court properly deemed the movants’ facts undisputed (¶ 4, following Jennings Inv., LC v. Dixie Riding Club, Inc., 2009 UT App 119, ¶ 21, 208 P.3d 1077). Because a rule 7 failure alone does not justify summary judgment (¶ 5, see Jennings, ¶ 29), the court also confirmed there was no genuine dispute of material fact. The partnership claim was “clearly inconsistent” with the Agreement. A later oral modification was contradicted by the plaintiffs’ deposition testimony that no further discussions took place. Judith Peterson’s assertion that she owned the assets personally was controverted by the Agreement she signed (¶ 5).

Part 2: Discovery and prematurity (¶ 6)

The plaintiffs were not denied discovery, and the summary judgment motion was not premature. They canceled John Fredrickson’s deposition, sought to reschedule it only after the motion was filed, and moved for more discovery on the eve of the hearing. The district court correctly denied that motion as untimely (¶ 6).

Issue 2: Fee award below (none stated, ¶ 7): affirmed (no error)

The fee and cost award is affirmed. The argument that tort claims fell outside the Agreement’s fee provision was not presented below and so was not considered. Below, the plaintiffs challenged only reasonableness. The court required a supplemental affidavit and adjusted the award slightly downward, and the plaintiffs did not undertake the analysis needed to show those findings were erroneous (¶ 7).

Issue 3: Appellate fees (none stated, ¶ 8): the Fredrickson Defendants’ request for attorney fees on appeal granted

The Fredrickson Defendants recover the fees and costs they reasonably incurred on appeal under the contractual fee provision, per Management Servs. Corp. v. Development Assoc., 617 P.2d 406, 409 (Utah 1980). The case is remanded to set the amount (¶ 8).

Takeaways

  • A claim that prior retained counsel performed poorly does not support reversing a civil judgment (¶ 3).
  • An opposition that fails rule 7(c)(3)(B) risks having the movant’s facts deemed undisputed; the court need not “comb the record” (¶ 4).
  • A rule 59 motion attacking a summary judgment tolls the time to appeal (¶ 2).
  • A discovery request first made on the eve of the summary judgment hearing may be denied as untimely (¶ 6).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Mojo Syndicate v.Fredrickson
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 6
Case no.
20110995-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
January 10, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Summary judgment against the plaintiffs' claims arising from an Asset Purchase Agreement for the assets of A Bar Named Sue, and an award of attorney fees and costs under that Agreement

The panel

Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Sandra N. Peuler

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantBusinessDenver C. Snuffer Jr.Daniel B. GarriottTahnee L. Hamilton
Appellee — AppelleeOtherJ. Ryan MitchellAndrew V. Collins

Practice Tip

When opposing summary judgment, restate each disputed fact verbatim and support each dispute with record citations; a memorandum that only disagrees and asks rhetorical questions lets the court treat the movant's facts as undisputed (¶ 4).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.