Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Is a lease guarantor off the hook once the tenant gives the space back? 628 Park Avenue, LLC v. Miller

2026 UT App 113No. 20240378-CADecided Jul 30, 2026Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed/Reversed in part

Holding

Summary judgment was improper because the landlord’s intent to accept a surrender was genuinely disputed and the guaranty was ambiguous as to treble damages; the landlord’s bare total damages figure violated rule 26(a)(1)(C), but components readily calculable from disclosed documents were adequately disclosed.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals mostly sided with the landlord, 628 Park Avenue, reversing the dismissal of its suit against guarantor Robert A. Miller and sending the case back.

  • Whether a landlord accepted a tenant’s surrender of a lease depends on intent, and here the evidence pointed both ways, so it could not be decided without weighing the evidence.
  • The guaranty could reasonably be read either to include or to exclude treble damages, so its meaning is a question of fact.
  • Giving only a total damages figure was not enough, but parts of the damages that could readily be calculated from the documents the landlord disclosed may still be proved.

What happened?

628 Park Avenue LLC (the landlord) leased a building in Park City to Church LLC, which ran a restaurant and bar there. Robert A. Miller signed a guaranty, a promise to pay if Church did not. Church fell behind on rent, and the landlord sued Church for unlawful detainer, meaning staying in a property without the right to. The two signed a forbearance agreement, a deal to pause the suit in exchange for installment payments.

Church missed more payments, and the court ordered it out. On August 12, 2017, Church signed a “Return of Possession” and a short license to keep using the space for $35,000. Church later left.

In 2019 the landlord sued Miller under the guaranty for $2,043,978.26.

What did the district court do?

On summary judgment, meaning a ruling without a trial, it held that the landlord had accepted Church’s “surrender” of the lease on August 12, 2017. That cut off rent after that date. It held that Miller’s guaranty did not cover treble (triple) damages under the unlawful detainer statute. It also held that the landlord had not properly disclosed how it computed its damages, so it could prove only unpaid rent for April through August 2017. Because Church had paid more than that, the court dismissed the case and awarded Miller attorney fees.

Did the surrender ruling stand?

No. Whether a landlord accepted a surrender depends on what it intended. Some documents called the lease “terminated.” Others said the landlord was not giving up its rights and Church was not relieved of its obligations. The landlord’s manager also said it never meant to accept a surrender. Because a reasonable factfinder could go either way, summary judgment was wrong.

What about treble damages?

The guaranty covered losses “incurred” by the landlord. Read on its own, that word might not cover triple damages. But the lease, which the guaranty was attached to, used “incurred” to include amounts allowed by Utah law. Both readings were reasonable, so the guaranty is ambiguous, and its meaning must be decided as a question of fact.

Was the damages disclosure good enough?

Mostly not. Utah’s rules require a party to share how it computed its damages. The landlord gave a figure to the penny but never showed the math. The court agreed that this overall disclosure fell short.

But four pieces could be figured out from the documents the landlord did share: unpaid rent for April through August 2017, unpaid minimum future rent, treble damages for May 15 through June 2, 2017, and the $35,482.91 still owed under the forbearance agreement. The landlord may offer evidence of those amounts if its theories are otherwise allowed.

What happens now?

The dismissal is reversed and the case goes back to the district court. The landlord may try to show it applied Church’s payments to other debts Church owed, as the lease allowed, if those debts are proved by admissible evidence. Miller’s fee award is undone, and the district court will decide who prevailed and what fees to award at the end.

What should people take from this?

A tenant returning the keys does not by itself end the lease. When a party seeks a specific damages number, it should show how it got there.

Bottom line

Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded (Luthy, J., joined by Harris and Tenney, JJ.). 628 Park Avenue LLC sued Robert A. Miller, guarantor of Church LLC’s restaurant lease, for $2,043,978.26 (¶ 20). The district court granted summary judgment on surrender and acceptance and on treble damages, limited the landlord’s damages evidence under rule 26, and dismissed the case (¶¶ 25–29). The court reversed on the first two issues, affirmed the general disclosure ruling but held four components adequately disclosed, and reversed the dismissal (¶¶ 68–71).

Issue 1: Surrender and acceptance (correctness, ¶ 30): reversed

A genuine dispute of fact exists on whether the landlord accepted a surrender (¶ 36). The question is the landlord’s intent, express or implied, and it is “one for the fact finder” (¶¶ 32–33, citing Brookside Mobile Home Park, Ltd. v. Peebles, 2000 UT App 314, ¶¶ 21, 24, 14 P.3d 105). The license agreement called the lease “terminated,” but the Return of Possession and the license preserved the landlord’s rights and Church’s obligations, no written termination notice was served, and the manager declared no surrender was intended (¶¶ 34–35). The manager’s declaration had an adequate foundation, and other evidence supported the landlord anyway (¶ 38).

Issue 2: Treble damages under the guaranty (correctness, ¶ 30): reversed

The guaranty is ambiguous as to treble damages under Utah Code § 78B-6-811(3), so its meaning is a fact question (¶ 44). Reading “incurred” as “to suffer” is reasonable (¶ 42), but the attached lease used “incurred” to include amounts permitted by Utah law, and interrelated contemporaneous agreements are harmonized under Winegar v. Froerer Corp., 813 P.2d 104, 109 (Utah 1991) (¶ 43).

Issue 3: Overall damages disclosure (abuse of discretion, ¶ 30): affirmed (no error)

The disclosure of $2,043,978.26 generally violated rule 26(a)(1)(C) (¶ 49). A figure “delineated down to the penny” was the product of a computation that had to be produced (¶ 47). The cited documents did not show treble-damages scope, application of payments, or whether waste, nuisance, interest or fees were included (¶ 49).

Issue 4: Individual components (abuse of discretion, ¶ 30): reversed

Four components were adequately disclosed (¶ 60). Drawing on Williams v. Anderson, 2017 UT App 91, 400 P.3d 1071, and Bad Ass Coffee Co. of Hawaii Inc. v. Royal Aloha International LLC, 2020 UT App 122, 473 P.3d 624, a component is adequately disclosed if readily calculable from a disclosed formula or a contractually agreed value (¶¶ 55, 59). Those were April–August 2017 rent (¶ 61), minimum future rent (¶ 62), treble damages for May 15–June 2, 2017 (¶ 63), and the $35,482.91 forbearance balance (¶ 64). Treble damages from July 13, 2017 had no end date and were not calculable (¶ 63 n.3).

Issue 5: Disclosure duty for offset amounts (abuse of discretion, ¶ 30): affirmed (no error)

Because the landlord was claiming the other amounts as damages when disclosures were due, they were subject to the disclosure requirement and the failure was sanctionable (¶ 66).

Issue 6: Final summary judgment and dismissal (correctness, ¶ 30): reversed

Since the landlord may now prove other amounts Church owed, it may show it applied Church’s payments to other arrearages under the lease, so the dismissal is reversed (¶¶ 67, 70).

Issue 7: Miller’s appellate fees (none stated, ¶ 71 n.5): remand guidance

The prevailing-party ruling and fee award are vacated, and the district court will reassess fees after remand, following Vanderwood v. Woodward, 2019 UT App 140, ¶ 49, 449 P.3d 983 (¶ 71 n.5).

Takeaways

  • Surrender and acceptance is rarely suited to summary judgment when the documents point both ways (¶¶ 33, 36).
  • A guaranty attached to a lease may be read with the lease’s definitions (¶ 43).
  • Disclosing a precise total without the computation behind it violates rule 26(a)(1)(C), though readily calculable components may survive (¶¶ 47, 55, 60).

The court left for remand the landlord’s argument that the full lease balance had already accrued before any surrender (¶ 62 n.2).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
628 Park Avenue, LLC v. Miller
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 113
Case no.
20240378-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
July 30, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
628 Park Avenue, LLC
Disposition
Affirmed in part and Reversed in part
At stake
A landlord's suit seeking $2,043,978.26 from the personal guarantor of a commercial restaurant lease

The panel

John D. LuthyAuthor
Ryan M. HarrisConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Silver Summit Department · Judge Richard E. Mrazik

Parties & counsel

628 Park Avenue, LLC — AppellantBusinessTroy L. BooherLaShel ShawTaylor P. WebbTal S. Madanes
Miller — AppelleeIndividual(s)Craig A. HogganMatthew M. Kaufmann

Practice Tip

When initial disclosures give a damages total calculated to the penny, produce the computation behind it; the court held that withholding the calculation actually used violates rule 26(a)(1)(C) (¶ 47).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.