Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Is touching inside the labia “penetration” under Utah’s object rape law? State v. Black

2026 UT App 114No. 20230342-CADecided Jul 30, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Under State v. Heath, 2019 UT App 186, 453 P.3d 955, which the court declined to overrule, touching the clitoris inside the labia is penetration of the genital opening under Utah Code § 76-5-402.2(2), and that reading does not make the statute vague or violate equal protection or uniform operation of laws.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Raymond Black’s convictions for object rape and forcible sexual abuse, rejecting every argument he raised.

  • The Court of Appeals kept its rule from Heath: touching the clitoris inside the labia counts as penetration under Utah’s object rape statute.
  • A defense expert may not tell the jury what a legal term in a statute means, and the court found her anatomy testimony unhelpful given the victim’s own account.
  • To complain about lost police video, a defendant must show more than a guess that it would have helped the defense.

What happened?

At a family reunion in 2017, Black’s fifteen-year-old niece, whom the court calls “Jori” (the court used made-up names for her and her cousin), said Black held her on a picnic bench, touched her breasts under her shirt, and then reached under her underwear and rubbed her clitoris. She described the clitoris as being inside the “flaps” of her labia.

Black was charged with object rape, a crime that requires “penetration, however slight” of the genital opening, and with forcible sexual abuse, a crime of unlawful sexual touching. A jury convicted him of both. He was sentenced to concurrent prison terms of five years to life and one to fifteen years.

What did Black argue?

His main argument was that touching the clitoris is not penetration of a “genital opening.” To win that point, he needed the court to overrule its own 2019 decision in State v. Heath, 2019 UT App 186, 453 P.3d 955, which held the opposite. He also argued that Heath made the statute too vague and treated male and female victims unequally.

He raised other complaints too: the judge would not let his medical expert testify, refused to let the jury consider a lesser crime, did not make sure the jury agreed on which act supported the abuse count, and denied his motion over police body camera video that had been erased.

What did the court decide?

It rejected every argument. The court said Heath’s reasoning is “solid and persuasive.” It traced the rule back to State v. Simmons, 759 P.2d 1152 (Utah 1988), and noted that many courts in other states agree. Mere touching is not enough; the touching must go between the outer folds of the labia, and Jori testified that it did.

The statute is not vague, because it clearly separates outside touching from penetrating touching. It does not treat the sexes unequally, because it applies to everyone, and any difference comes from anatomy.

The expert could not tell the jury what a legal term means. Her points about how body position can expose the clitoris did not matter, because Jori said the touching was inside her labia. For the same reason, there was no evidence supporting only the lesser crime.

On jury agreement, the court found no problem. The only genital touching was charged as object rape, so the abuse count could only rest on the breast touching. Because Black’s lawyer had not objected at trial, the court reviewed this under “plain error,” an obvious mistake the judge should have caught, and “ineffective assistance,” a lawyer’s performance below a reasonable standard. Neither applied.

On the lost video, Black offered only guesses about what it might have shown that would help him, which is not enough.

What happens now?

Nothing more in this appeal. The convictions and sentences stand.

What should people take from this?

In Utah, the Court of Appeals continues to treat touching the clitoris inside the labia as penetration for object rape. Claims about lost evidence need a concrete showing of how the evidence would have helped the defense, not speculation.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Mortensen, J., joined by Luthy and Oliver, JJ.). The panel declined to overrule State v. Heath, 2019 UT App 186, 453 P.3d 955, and held that the victim’s testimony that Black rubbed her clitoris, which she placed inside her labia, was sufficient evidence of penetration of the “genital opening” under Utah Code § 76-5-402.2(2) (¶¶ 34, 38).

Issue 1: Sufficiency and the request to overrule Heath (sufficiency of the evidence, ¶ 23): affirmed (no error)

Under Heath, the evidence sufficed, and Heath is not clearly erroneous. Horizontal stare decisis allows overruling only a clearly erroneous decision or one made inapplicable by changed conditions (¶ 24). Heath applied State v. Simmons, 759 P.2d 1152 (Utah 1988), and State v. Patterson, 2017 UT App 194, ¶ 3, 407 P.3d 1002 (“entry between the outer folds of the labia”), and matches a national consensus, including People v. Quintana, 108 Cal. Rptr. 2d 235, 238 (Ct. App. 2001) (¶¶ 36–38). The absurdity argument fails because mere touching is not enough without breaching the outer labia, and “anal opening” is a narrower term than “genital opening” (¶¶ 40–42, n.7).

Issue 2: Vagueness (none stated, ¶ 44): affirmed (no error)

Heath does not make the statute vague. Exterior touching falls under forcible sexual abuse or sexual battery; penetrative touching, including the clitoris inside the labia, is object rape, and Heath marks that line (¶¶ 43–44, citing State v. Ray, 2022 UT App 95, ¶ 36, 516 P.3d 329).

Issue 3: Equal protection and uniform operation (none stated, ¶¶ 47–48): affirmed (no error)

Neither the statute nor Heath classifies by sex. Both focus on penetration; any different treatment stems from “a straightforward matter of biology,” In re adoption of J.S., 2014 UT 51, ¶ 73, 358 P.3d 1009 (¶ 47). The uniform operation claim fails for the same reason (¶ 48).

Issue 4: Exclusion of the defense expert (abuse of discretion, ¶ 25): affirmed (no error)

The court did not abuse its discretion under Utah R. Evid. 702(a). The expert’s view that “genital opening” is a “misnomer” would be a legal opinion, see Steffensen v. Smith’s Mgmt. Corp., 862 P.2d 1342, 1347–48 (Utah 1993) (¶¶ 50–51). Her positional-anatomy testimony was unhelpful given Jori’s testimony that the touching was inside her labia (¶ 52). The jury’s question about the labial folds did not change this (n.8).

Issue 5: Lesser-included-offense instruction (correctness, ¶ 25): affirmed (no error)

No rational basis supported acquittal of object rape and conviction of forcible sexual abuse (¶ 55, citing State v. LoPrinzi, 2014 UT App 256, ¶ 17, 338 P.3d 253). Jori identified no genital touching other than the clitoris, and her “scooted back” statement, read in context, meant she prevented vaginal penetration (¶ 56).

Issue 6: Unanimity on Count 2 (correctness, ¶ 26): affirmed (no error)

Unpreserved; reviewed for plain error and ineffective assistance. There was no unanimity problem: the clitoral touching was wholly covered by Count 1, so Count 2 could rest only on the breast touching, despite the indecent-liberties language (¶ 61). Not objecting to correct instructions is not deficient performance, State v. Vigil, 2019 UT App 131, ¶ 11, 448 P.3d 738 (¶ 62).

Issue 7: Lost body camera video (mixed, ¶ 27): affirmed (no error)

Black did not meet the threshold showing of a reasonable probability that the video was exculpatory (¶ 66). Lighting, layout and demeanor claims were speculative; a video of the victim right after the assault “could have just as easily been inculpatory” (¶ 67, citing State v. Mohamud, 2017 UT 23, ¶ 22, 395 P.3d 133).

Issue 8: Cumulative error (none stated, ¶ 69): affirmed (no error)

With no errors shown, there was nothing to accumulate (¶ 69, citing State v. Hunt, 2025 UT 54, ¶ 83, 582 P.3d 772).

Takeaways

  • A challenge to object rape convictions based on clitoral contact inside the labia must overcome Heath, which this panel reaffirmed (¶¶ 36–38).
  • Expert testimony defining a statutory term is a legal opinion and may be excluded as unhelpful (¶ 51).
  • A lost-evidence claim needs a proffer of what the evidence would have shown and how it would have helped, not general benefit (¶¶ 66–67).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Black
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 114
Case no.
20230342-CA
Filed
2023
Decided
July 30, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Black
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Convictions for object rape and forcible sexual abuse of the defendant's fifteen-year-old niece at a family reunion

The panel

David N. MortensenAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Fourth District Court, American Fork Department · Judge Denise Porter

Parties & counsel

Black — AppellantIndividual(s)Ann M. Taliaferro
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownTerry M. CristDavid A. Simpson

Practice Tip

A due process claim over lost police video fails at the threshold without a specific proffer of what the video would have shown and how it would have contradicted the State's evidence; general claims about lighting, layout or demeanor are speculation (¶¶ 66–67).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.