Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can recent progress stop termination of my parental rights? In re T.O... (E.O. State)

2013 UT App 36No. 20120964-CADecided Feb 14, 2013Juvenile & Child WelfareAffirmed

Holding

The juvenile court’s credibility finding, its findings of termination grounds under Utah Code section 78A-6-507(1)(d) and (1)(e), and its best-interests determination were supported by the evidence, because the mother’s recent improvement had to be weighed against her long history of failing to remedy the conditions, as described in In re B.R., 2007 UT 82, ¶ 13, 171 P.3d 435.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld the termination of the mother’s parental rights.

  • The appeals court deferred to the juvenile court’s view that the mother’s testimony was not believable.
  • Recent improvement did not undo the termination: the children had been in state custody for over two years, and the mother herself estimated she could need up to two more years before regaining custody.
  • The best-interests question looks at the children’s need for stability. Here, the grandparents who wish to adopt them were meeting their needs.

What happened?

The juvenile court ended the parental rights of E.O. (the mother) to her four children, T.O., C.O., A.O., and H.O. At the time of the termination trial, the children had been in state custody for over two years. The Division of Child and Family Services had provided the mother with numerous services. The children were living with their grandparents, who wish to adopt them.

The mother appealed. The State of Utah defended the juvenile court’s decision on appeal, and a guardian ad litem, a lawyer appointed to represent the children’s interests, also took part.

What did the mother argue?

She made three arguments. First, the juvenile court should not have found her testimony not credible (not believable). Second, the evidence did not support the legal grounds for ending her rights, because the court gave too little weight to her recent efforts. Third, ending her rights was not in the children’s best interests.

Why did the court accept the finding that she was not believable?

Appeals courts give the juvenile court room on this kind of finding because the judge hears the witnesses in person. The juvenile court found that the mother “blamed everyone but herself for the problems in her home.” It did not believe her claim that she did not know about the sexual abuse of S.O. until April 2011. It also found S.O.’s testimony more believable than hers. The Court of Appeals held that these reasons were enough to support the finding.

Didn’t her recent progress count?

It did, but only so far. The court explained that recent improvement has to be weighed against a parent’s past conduct and how long the problems have lasted. The mother had recently finished an educational program and found a job. But she did not earn enough to support herself and the children. She lived in an apartment with two other people, which she agreed was not suitable for the children. She conceded she was not ready to regain custody and estimated it could take up to two more years.

The juvenile court found she was “very articulate in reciting good parenting practices” but had been unable to put them into practice “for a decade.” The Court of Appeals held the evidence supported more than one legal ground for termination. These included her failure to fix the problems that led to the children’s removal.

What about the children’s best interests?

The mother pointed to her love for the children, their enjoyment of visits, her gifts, and her improving earning power. The court said this argument did not focus on the children’s need for stability. The grandparents were meeting the children’s needs, including special educational and therapeutic needs, and the mother did not challenge any finding about their home. She had asked that the children stay in a permanent guardianship with the grandparents until some unspecified future date. The court held that the evidence amply supported adoption as being in the children’s best interest.

What happens now?

The termination order stands. The Court of Appeals affirmed, and the case was not sent back.

What should people take from this?

On appeal, the question is not whether the evidence could have supported a different result. The question is whether the evidence supports the juvenile court’s decision. When it does, the appeals court will not reweigh the evidence.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, McHugh, and Voros, JJ.). The mother challenged the juvenile court’s credibility finding, its grounds for termination, and its best-interests determination. Because “a foundation for the court’s decision exists in the evidence,” the court affirmed (¶ 9, quoting In re B.R., 2007 UT 82, ¶ 12, 171 P.3d 435).

Issue 1: Credibility finding (clearly erroneous, ¶ 3): affirmed (no error)

The juvenile court’s finding that the mother was not credible was adequately supported. The court deferred to the juvenile court’s first-hand view of credibility and its special training and experience (¶ 3, quoting In re E.R., 2001 UT App 66, ¶ 11, 21 P.3d 680). The juvenile court found that the mother “blamed everyone but herself,” and it rejected as not credible her claim that she was unaware of S.O.’s sexual abuse until April 2011. It noted other specific parts of her testimony it did not believe and found S.O. more credible (¶ 3). See also In re Z.D., 2006 UT 54, ¶ 52, 147 P.3d 401 (Wilkins, J., concurring), on how little a court’s findings need to say about credibility.

Issue 2: Termination of parental rights (clearly erroneous, ¶¶ 2, 4–8): affirmed (no error)

The court held that the evidence supported both the statutory grounds and the best-interests determination, so the termination order was affirmed (¶ 9).

Part 1: Grounds for termination

The evidence was sufficient to support more than one ground under Utah Code section 78A-6-507 (¶ 6). Under In re B.R., 2007 UT 82, ¶ 13, 171 P.3d 435, evidence of present ability is weighed against the length of past unwillingness or inability to improve and its effect on the parent-child relationship (¶ 4).

The juvenile court gave appropriate weight to the mother’s present ability (¶ 5):

  • The children had been in custody over two years, and she had received numerous services.
  • She lacked adequate income and suitable housing.
  • She conceded she could not regain custody and estimated it could take up to two more years.

That record supported grounds under section 78A-6-507(1)(d), failure to remedy the circumstances causing out-of-home placement. It also supported grounds under section 78A-6-507(1)(e), failure of parental adjustment, read with section 78A-6-509(1)(b) (¶ 7).

Part 2: Best interests

The best-interests challenge was “without merit.” The mother relied on her love for the children, their enjoyment of visits, her gifts, and her rising earning potential. That argument “does not focus on the interests of the children in achieving stability” (¶ 8). The grandparents, who wish to adopt, were meeting the children’s special educational and therapeutic needs. The mother did not challenge any finding about the grandparents’ home. Her proposal of a permanent guardianship until an unspecified future date did not undermine the determination (¶ 8).

Takeaways

  • A credibility finding backed by specific reasons, such as blame-shifting and implausible claims of ignorance, receives strong deference (¶ 3).
  • Recent improvement weighs little against a parent’s own concession that reunification is up to two years away after more than two years in custody (¶¶ 5, 7).
  • A best-interests argument built on the parent’s love and visits, rather than the children’s stability, fails when the children’s needs are being met in an adoptive placement whose findings go unchallenged (¶ 8).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
In re T.O... (E.O. State)
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 36
Case no.
20120964-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
February 14, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
The termination of a mother's parental rights to four children, whose grandparents wish to adopt them

The panel

Trial court
Third Juvenile Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Andrew A. Valdez

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Brent Salazar‐Hall
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyJohn E. SwallowJohn M. Peterson
Guardian ad litemOtherMartha Pierce

Practice Tip

The court rejected a best-interests challenge that relied on the parent's love and progress, holding that it did not address the children's need for stability, particularly where findings on the adoptive placement went unchallenged (¶ 8).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.