Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I ask a court to overturn a parole board’s natural life decision? Maguire v. Bigelow

2013 UT App 221No. 20130597-CADecided Sep 6, 2013Post-Conviction ReliefAffirmed

Holding

Because Board of Pardons and Parole decisions are final and judicial review extends only to the fairness of the Board’s process, the district court properly dismissed claims attacking a natural life term within the inmate’s indeterminate range, and the Board had no duty to produce a presentence report it neither had nor considered.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Board of Pardons and Parole and the State and upheld the dismissal of Maguire’s petition.

  • Under Utah law, the Board’s parole decisions are final and courts do not review them. A court may look only at whether the Board’s process was fair.
  • A natural life term that falls within an inmate’s ten-year-to-life range is, absent unusual circumstances, not arbitrary.
  • The Board did not have to give Maguire a presentence report that was not in its file and that it did not consider.

What happened?

Brian Maguire is serving a ten-year-to-life sentence. The Board of Pardons and Parole, the agency that decides if and when inmates are released on parole, decided he would serve natural life, the maximum term of that sentence.

Maguire filed a petition for extraordinary relief in the district court. That is a request asking a court to step in where no ordinary appeal is available. He made ten claims. The district court dismissed the petition, and Maguire appealed. He represented himself.

The Court of Appeals decided the appeal on its own motion for summary disposition, meaning a quick ruling because the appeal raised no substantial question.

What did Maguire argue?

Nine of his claims challenged the Board’s natural life decision. He attacked the information the Board relied on, the legality of the sentence, and the decision itself. He also argued his sentences should add up to no more than thirty years.

His tenth claim was that his right to due process, meaning fair procedures, was violated because he did not receive his 1992 presentence investigation report before his Board hearing.

What did the court decide about the natural life decision?

The court upheld the dismissal. By statute, the Board’s parole decisions “are final and are not subject to judicial review.” Courts may review only the fairness of the Board’s process, not its result.

Because natural life fell within Maguire’s ten-year-to-life range, the decision could not be arbitrary absent unusual circumstances. Maguire said the Board did not give enough weight to his objections, but how much weight to give the evidence is for the Board. He had the information before the hearing and could address it, so he received the process he was due.

The thirty-year argument also failed. The statute capping consecutive sentences at thirty years does not apply when the maximum of an indeterminate sentence may be life in prison.

What about the missing report?

That claim failed too. Maguire said the report was the source of some information in an institutional progress report in the Board’s file, and he objected to that information at his hearing. But the presentence report itself was not in the Board’s file and the Board did not consider it, so the Board did not have to produce it.

What happens now?

Nothing more in this case. The dismissal stands, and the Board’s natural life decision remains in place.

What should people take from this?

In Utah, a court will not second-guess the Board’s parole result. A challenge has to focus on whether the Board’s process was fair. In this case, that meant whether Maguire had the information before the hearing and a chance to respond.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, Thorne and McHugh, JJ.), on the court’s own motion for summary disposition for lack of a substantial question (¶¶ 1, 4). The district court properly dismissed Maguire’s petition for extraordinary relief challenging the Board of Pardons and Parole’s decision that he serve natural life on a ten-year-to-life sentence (¶¶ 2–3).

Issue 1: Challenges to the natural life determination (none stated, ¶ 2): affirmed (no error)

The district court did not err in dismissing the nine claims attacking the Board’s natural life decision. The Board decides if, when and under what conditions an inmate is paroled, and its parole decisions “are final and are not subject to judicial review” under Utah Code § 77‐27‐5(3) (¶ 2). Review reaches only “the fairness of the process,” not the result, under Lancaster v. Board of Pardons, 869 P.2d 945, 947 (Utah 1994). A term within the inmate’s indeterminate range, “absent unusual circumstances, cannot be arbitrary and capricious,” under Preece v. House, 886 P.2d 508, 512 (Utah 1994) (¶ 2).

Footnote 1 answers the related arguments. The weight given to evidence is for the Board and not reviewable (citing Lancaster, 869 P.2d at 947). Maguire had the information before the hearing and could address it, so he received the process due; see Neel v. Holden, 886 P.2d 1097, 1101 (Utah 1994); Labrum v. Board of Pardons, 870 P.2d 902, 909 (Utah 1993). The thirty-year cap on consecutive sentences in Utah Code § 76‐3‐401 does not apply when the maximum of an indeterminate sentence may be life (¶ 2 n.1).

Issue 2: Procedural due process and the 1992 PSI (none stated, ¶ 3): affirmed (no error)

The Board did not have to produce the 1992 presentence investigation report, so the due process claim was properly dismissed. Maguire alleged the PSI was the source of some information in an Institutional Progress Report in the Board’s file, and he objected to that information at the hearing. The PSI itself was not in the Board’s file and was not considered by the Board (¶ 3); see Peterson v. Board of Pardons, 931 P.2d 147, 152 (Utah Ct. App. 1997).

Takeaways

  • Attacks on the Board’s result, including the weight it gave to evidence, are not reviewable. Frame a challenge around the fairness of the process (¶ 2 & n.1).
  • Advance access to the information and a chance to address it at the hearing satisfied due process here (¶ 2 n.1).
  • The Board’s duty to disclose did not reach a source document it neither had in its file nor considered (¶ 3).
  • Section 76‐3‐401’s thirty-year cap does not apply where an indeterminate sentence’s maximum may be life (¶ 2 n.1).

Case details

Case name
Maguire v. Bigelow
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 221
Case no.
20130597-CA
Filed
2013
Decided
September 6, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Maguire
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
The Board of Pardons and Parole's determination that Maguire would serve a natural life sentence, the maximum term of his ten-year-to-life sentence

The panel

Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Royal I. Hansen

Parties & counsel

Maguire — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Bigelow — AppelleeGovernment agencyJohn E. SwallowBridget K. Romano

Practice Tip

When challenging a Board of Pardons and Parole decision, focus on process (whether the inmate had the information beforehand and could address it), because the Board's result and the weight it gives evidence are not reviewable (¶ 2 & n.1).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.