Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Does a temporary protective order end if the final one was never served? State v. Bridgewaters

2020 UT 32No. 20180190Decided May 28, 2020Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Under the Cohabitant Abuse Act, a protective order issued after a hearing must be served under rule 4 of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure, and when it has not been, Utah Code § 78B-7-107(1)(d) keeps the previously served ex parte order in effect until service is completed, notwithstanding the 180-day extension limit in § 78B-7-107(1)(c).

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court mostly sided with the State, holding that Bridgewaters must stand trial for violating the earlier ex parte order, though not the later protective order.

  • A protective order issued after a hearing under Utah’s Cohabitant Abuse Act must be served the way rule 4 of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure requires. Mailing it to a last known address under rule 5 is not enough.
  • When the court issues a protective order at the hearing, the earlier temporary order stays in effect until the protective order is served, even after 180 days.
  • Here, the charges can go forward only as violations of the temporary order, not the protective order.

What happened?

On February 5, 2016, Jeremy Bridgewaters’ former girlfriend, T.T., asked the court for a protective order against him. That same day the court issued an ex parte order, meaning a temporary order issued before he had a chance to respond. He was handed a copy in person. It told him to stay away from T.T.’s home and work and to come to a hearing on February 23, 2016.

He did not attend the hearing. The court issued a protective order with the same limits. The law says the sheriff should serve that order, but for reasons the record does not show, the sheriff never did. In May 2016, T.T.’s lawyer mailed it to Bridgewaters’ last known address, which was T.T.’s home, a place both orders barred him from going.

In June 2017, T.T. saw him leaving her apartment complex. The next day he texted her. The State charged him in two cases with violating the orders.

How did the case reach the Utah Supreme Court?

After a preliminary hearing, a magistrate “bound him over,” meaning the judge found enough evidence for the charges to go to trial. Bridgewaters asked the court to undo that decision and lost. He got permission to appeal before trial, and the Court of Appeals sent the case to the Supreme Court.

What did Bridgewaters argue?

He argued that the protective order was never properly served because it was only mailed. He also argued that the temporary order had expired, because the law says a temporary order cannot be extended past 180 days.

Was the protective order properly served?

No. The crime requires proof that the person was “properly served.” The court read the Cohabitant Abuse Act, which says the protective order goes to the sheriff for “service of process.” That phrase points to rule 4 of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure, the rule for serving papers that start a lawsuit. Mailing under rule 5, the rule for papers served later in a case, does not count. So the court agreed with Bridgewaters on this point.

Had the temporary order expired?

No. The 180-day limit applies when a court extends a temporary order before a protective order is issued. A different part of the law says that if the court issues a protective order at the hearing, the temporary order “remains in effect until service of process of the protective order is completed.” Because the protective order was never properly served, the temporary order was still in force in June 2017.

What happens now?

The court affirmed the decision sending the case to trial. But the charges may be based only on violating the temporary order, not the protective order.

What should people take from this?

How a protective order is delivered matters. Mailing it is not proper service of a protective order issued after a hearing. Even so, a temporary order the person did receive can keep protecting the petitioner until the final order is properly served.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Petersen, J., joined by Durrant, C.J., Lee, A.C.J., Himonas and Pearce, JJ.). On an interlocutory appeal certified from the Court of Appeals, the court held the protective order was not properly served under the Violation Statute, Utah Code § 76-5-108(1) (2017), but the ex parte order remained in effect under § 78B-7-107(1)(d), so the bindover stands only “to the extent” the charges rest on the ex parte order (¶¶ 32, 40–41).

Issue 1: Proper service of the protective order (correctness, ¶ 16): affirmed (harmless error)

The court agreed with Bridgewaters that a protective order must be served under rule 4 and that mailing it under rule 5 was not proper service, but this did not require reversing the denial of the motion to quash (¶¶ 20, 32). Proper service is an element of the offense, so the State had to produce evidence of it at the preliminary hearing (¶ 21, citing State v. Virgin, 2006 UT 29, ¶ 17, 137 P.3d 787). Because § 76-5-108 does not define proper service, the court looked to the Cohabitant Abuse Act, whose provisions govern where they are more specific than the civil rules (§ 78B-7-106(12)) (¶ 24). Section 78B-7-106(4)(a) directs delivery to the sheriff “for service of process,” a phrase that invokes rule 4 (¶¶ 27–29, citing Carlson v. Bos, 740 P.2d 1269, 1271 (Utah 1987)). The court rejected the State’s argument that rule 4 service is duplicative once the ex parte order has been personally served: the statute has no such exception, and a protective order can impose additional restrictions (¶ 29 n.11). It also rejected the State’s argument that it should not reach service, because § 107(1)(d) applies only if service has not been “completed” (¶ 33 n.14).

Issue 2: Life of the ex parte order (correctness, ¶ 16): affirmed (no error)

The ex parte order remained in effect at the time of the alleged violations (¶¶ 40–41). The 180-day cap in § 78B-7-107(1)(c) works with § 107(1)(b) to limit a court’s extension of an ex parte order before a protective order issues. Both use forms of “extend” and describe court action, while § 107(1)(d) uses the passive “remains in effect” (¶ 38). Once the court holds the hearing and issues a protective order, § 107(1)(d) keeps the ex parte order in effect until service of the protective order is completed, and the 180-day limit “no longer applies” (¶ 39).

Disposition

Affirmed to the extent the charges rest on the ex parte order. The charges may not be based on the protective order (¶¶ 40–41).

Takeaways

  • Proper service under § 76-5-108(1) is an element the State must support with evidence at a preliminary hearing (¶ 21).
  • Mailing a post-hearing protective order to a last known address under rule 5 is not proper service; the Act requires rule 4 service (¶¶ 29, 32).
  • An ex parte order outlives the 180-day cap when a protective order issued at the hearing has not been served (¶ 39).
  • The court did not decide whether rule 4 service must be made by the sheriff or another law enforcement agency, which Bridgewaters did not argue (¶ 32 n.13), or the constitutionality of the Act’s procedural provisions, which the State did not challenge (¶ 24 n.9).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Bridgewaters
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2020 UT 32
Case no.
20180190
Filed
2018
Decided
May 28, 2020
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Bridgewaters
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether the defendant must stand trial on two charges of violating a protective order or ex parte protective order, after the denial of his motion to quash the bindover

The panel

Paige PetersenAuthor
Matthew B. DurrantConcurred
Deno G. HimonasConcurred
Thomas R. LeeConcurred
John A. PearceConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, West Jordan Department · Judge William K. Kendall

Parties & counsel

Bridgewaters — AppellantIndividual(s)Samantha R. Dugan
State — AppelleeState of UtahSim GillSamuel P. Sutton

Practice Tip

In protective-order violation cases, check how the post-hearing order was served: mailing under rule 5 does not satisfy the Act, but the State may still proceed on a served ex parte order that § 78B-7-107(1)(d) keeps alive (¶¶ 32, 39–40).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.