Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a judge push holdout jurors to side with the majority? State v. Wahlstrom

2026 UT App 143No. 20220988-CADecided Sep 17, 2026Criminal AppealsReversed & Remanded

Holding

An Allen charge that told only minority jurors to question their doubts, with no admonition against surrendering conscientious convictions, was coercive per se and under the circumstances, and counsel’s failure to object was deficient and prejudicial, requiring reversal of the DUI conviction.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with Wahlstrom on both of his issues, reversing his DUI conviction and sending the case back.

  • An instruction telling only the jurors in the minority to rethink their views, without reminding them not to give up honest beliefs, was coercive here.
  • Wahlstrom’s lawyer should have objected, and there was a reasonable chance the jury would otherwise have stayed deadlocked on DUI.
  • The DUI conviction is reversed; the other convictions stand, and the trial court must address the disputed item in the presentence report.

What happened?

Officers found Wahlstrom drunk, sitting in the driver seat of his work truck in the mountains with the key in the ignition and the lights on. The engine was not running. A friend he had been with, called “Sadie” in the opinion (a made-up name), had told police he pushed her out of the truck. His blood alcohol level was .17.

He was charged with DUI and three other crimes. At trial his lawyer admitted he was drunk but argued he was not in “actual physical control” of the truck, meaning able to start and move it, because he was waiting for another friend to drive him down.

How did the jury reach its verdict?

The trial was squeezed into one day, and the jury began deliberating at 6:37 p.m. It sent several questions and agreed on the other charges, but by 10:10 p.m. it was stuck on DUI. The judge then gave an “Allen charge,” an extra instruction meant to help a stuck jury agree.

This one told jurors in the minority to ask whether their doubts were reasonable when so many others disagreed. It did not tell them to keep their honest beliefs. Eleven minutes later, the jury convicted on every charge. Wahlstrom’s lawyer did not object.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It held that the instruction was coercive in two ways. First, its words pushed the minority to rethink their views without the usual reminder that no juror should give up an honest belief just to reach a verdict. Second, the setting added pressure: the late hour, the judge’s earlier direction to “reach a verdict,” no sign the jurors knew they could stop for the night or fail to agree, and a verdict only eleven minutes later.

It also held that Wahlstrom’s lawyer gave “ineffective assistance,” meaning his work fell below what the Constitution requires and it hurt the defense. Because the evidence of control was strong, the lawyer could tell the holdouts were likely jurors leaning toward acquittal, so the instruction could only pressure them to convict. Without it, the court found a reasonable chance of a “hung jury,” one that cannot agree.

What about the presentence report?

At sentencing, Wahlstrom’s lawyer said a past incident listed in his presentence report, a background report the judge uses at sentencing, may not have happened. The judge did not resolve it. The State agreed this was an error under Utah law.

What happens now?

The DUI conviction is reversed and goes back for a new trial or other proceedings. The other convictions were reached before the deadlock and are not affected. The trial court must also address the disputed item in the report.

What should people take from this?

When a judge urges a stuck jury to agree, the instruction should remind jurors not to give up honest beliefs. A lawyer who sees a one-sided instruction aimed at jurors who seem to favor the client can be expected to object.

Bottom line

Reversed and remanded (Luthy, J., joined by Christiansen Forster and Harris, JJ.). The DUI conviction is reversed because counsel was ineffective for not objecting to a coercive Allen charge (¶¶ 41, 46, 55, 57–58). The other convictions, unchallenged and reached before the deadlock, stand (¶ 58). A limited remand addresses the PSI (¶ 59).

Issue 1: Ineffective assistance for failing to object to the Allen charge (ineffective assistance, ¶ 29): reversed

Counsel performed deficiently and prejudicially by not objecting to an Allen charge that was coercive both per se and under the circumstances. Under the two-part test in State v. Dalton, 2014 UT App 68, ¶ 47, 331 P.3d 1110, the charge was coercive per se: it reused only the minority-directed language from Dalton and dropped Dalton’s “duty to decide . . . without yielding” and “not a mere acquiescence” counterbalancing language, leaving “nothing in the Allen charge to relieve its coercive force” (¶¶ 35–38, 41). A pre-deliberation instruction (“Your verdict must be your own”) was an inadequate counterbalance (¶ 38 n.9). The court relied on State v. Harry, 2008 UT App 224, 189 P.3d 98, State v. Ginter, 2013 UT App 92, 300 P.3d 1278, and federal circuit authority (¶¶ 39–40).

It was also coercive under the circumstances: a two-day trial compressed into one, deliberations starting at 6:37 p.m., an instruction to “reach a verdict. Do whatever you need to,” no indication jurors knew they could resume the next day or that a mistrial was possible, and a verdict eleven minutes after the 10:10 p.m. charge (¶¶ 43–46), contrasting State v. Lactod, 761 P.2d 23, 31 (Utah Ct. App. 1988), and following Harry, ¶ 33.

Deficiency: the evidence of actual physical control was strong, and because the jury had agreed on the interlock charge but deadlocked on DUI, counsel could infer the jury found Wahlstrom drove the truck and the holdouts favored acquittal; the charge could only pressure them to convict (¶¶ 49–55). Prejudice: the minority had held out for most of an hour after the 9:20 p.m. answers, so there was a reasonable probability of a hung jury absent the charge (¶ 57), applying State v. Scott, 2020 UT 13, ¶ 43, 462 P.3d 350.

Issue 2: Failure to resolve PSI inaccuracy (correctness, ¶ 30): reversed

The trial court erred by not resolving Wahlstrom’s challenge to a prior-history entry in the PSI. The State conceded the court failed to take the steps required by Utah Code section 77-18-103(5)(a), so the court ordered a limited remand, following State v. Cruz, 2020 UT App 157, ¶ 33, 478 P.3d 631 (¶ 59). The DUI reversal did not moot this issue because the other convictions stand (¶ 2).

Disposition

Remanded for further proceedings on the DUI charge and for the trial court to address the alleged PSI inaccuracy (¶ 60).

Takeaways

  • An Allen charge aimed at minority jurors needs language telling them not to surrender conscientious convictions; a general pre-deliberation instruction did not cure its absence here (¶¶ 38 n.9, 41).
  • Late-night deliberations, “reach a verdict” directives, and a verdict minutes after the charge weigh toward coercion under the circumstances (¶¶ 43–46).
  • Counsel can draw inferences about the holdouts from partial verdicts and jury questions, and failing to object to a charge that can only pressure them toward conviction may be deficient (¶¶ 51–55).
  • Prejudice can be shown by a reasonable probability of a hung jury (¶ 57).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Wahlstrom
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 143
Case no.
20220988-CA
Filed
2022
Decided
September 17, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Wahlstrom
Disposition
Reversed and Remanded
At stake
A jury's DUI conviction returned eleven minutes after the court gave a deadlocked jury an Allen charge, and an alleged error in the presentence investigation report

The panel

John D. LuthyAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
Ryan M. HarrisConcurred
Trial court
Second District Court, Farmington Department · Judge David R. Hamilton

Parties & counsel

Wahlstrom — AppellantIndividual(s)Scott L Wiggins
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownKaren A. Klucznik

Practice Tip

When a court proposes an Allen charge directed at minority jurors, check that it tells jurors not to yield their conscientious convictions, and object if it does not (¶¶ 38, 41, 55).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.