Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Does withheld evidence always mean a new trial? State v. Marx

2026 UT App 109No. 20230044-CADecided Jul 23, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Undisclosed body camera footage and a medical examination report were not material under Brady given the recorded pretext call and the defendant’s own testimony, and for the same reason the defendant could not show prejudice on his ineffective-assistance claims or justify a rule 23B remand.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State, upholding Marx’s convictions and denying his request to send the case back for more evidence.

  • Evidence the State did not turn over leads to a new trial only if there is a reasonable probability it would have changed the verdict.
  • Here, a recorded phone call and Marx’s own trial testimony weighed heavily against him, so the missing evidence and the proposed expert testimony would not have changed the result.
  • A claim that a lawyer should have called an expert fails if the defendant does not identify an expert and what that expert would have said.

What happened?

Marx’s daughter, called Taylor in the opinion (a made-up name), told her mother in 2019, when she was thirteen, that Marx had abused her when she was young. Police had Taylor make a recorded “pretext call” to Marx, meaning a call set up to see what he would say. On the call, Marx told her three times he would “prefer [she] not” tell her counselor anything and twice that he could “get into a lot of trouble.”

A jury convicted him of sodomy upon a child and tampering with a witness. He was sentenced to twenty-five years to life and zero to five years, to run at the same time.

What did Marx argue?

After trial, with a new lawyer, Marx asked for a new trial. He said the State never gave him police body camera footage of the mother’s report or a report from Taylor’s medical exam. He also said his trial lawyer failed to use those items, failed to present medical proof of his claimed chocolate allergy, and failed to call an expert on child memory. The district court denied the motion.

Did the missing evidence require a new trial?

No. The State must share evidence that helps the defense, but a new trial follows only if the evidence is “material,” meaning there is a reasonable probability it would have changed the verdict.

The court said the body camera footage cut both ways. It showed the mother had asked Taylor many times about abuse, but her reason for asking was that Marx’s second ex-wife kept raising concerns about him. The exam report, which found no injuries, was not helpful to Marx, since the abuse had ended years earlier.

The court also stressed that this was not just one person’s word against another’s. The jury heard the recorded call, the detective’s account of Marx’s reaction, and Marx’s claim that he was never alone with his daughter from 2006 to 2011, even though he had cared for her while her mother worked.

Was his lawyer ineffective?

The court assumed, without deciding, that the lawyer fell short, but held Marx was not harmed. For the footage and report, the answer followed from the first ruling. For the allergy, Marx’s own photos and skin test showed only mild irritation, which undercut his and his father’s testimony about severe reactions. And he never identified a medical expert who would have testified for him.

Why didn’t the court send the case back?

Marx asked for a “rule 23B remand,” a procedure that sends a case back to the trial court to gather facts for an ineffective-lawyer claim. He offered a statement from a new expert on childhood memory and false accusations during divorces. The court held that testimony would not likely have changed the verdict, partly because Taylor remembered many details of the house where the abuse began.

What happens now?

The convictions and sentences stand, and the case does not go back to the district court.

What should people take from this?

When a jury hears strong evidence like a recorded call, missing evidence or extra expert testimony must be weighed against all of it. Here it was not enough to show a reasonable chance of a different result.

Bottom line

Affirmed; rule 23B motion denied (Oliver, J., joined by Orme and Luthy, JJ.). The pretext call, the detective’s account of Marx’s response, and Marx’s own trial testimony defeated materiality and prejudice on every claim (¶¶ 28–30, 34, 37–38, 44–47).

Issue 1: Brady claim and new-trial motion (abuse of discretion, ¶ 22): affirmed (no error)

The district court did not abuse its discretion in denying a new trial, because the body camera footage and the SHF report were not material. Applying Carter v. State, 2025 UT 13, ¶ 97, 570 P.3d 315, and weighing cumulative effect under Tillman v. State, 2005 UT 56, ¶ 32, 128 P.3d 1123, the court found the footage double-edged: Mother’s repeated questioning was prompted by Ex-wife’s concerns about Marx’s “weird” behavior (¶ 26). The SHF report was not favorable at all; no injuries were expected years after the abuse ended, and scheduling the exam showed cooperation as readily as a “nefarious purpose” (¶ 27). The case was not “simply a he said/she said case”: Marx three times said he would “prefer [she] not” talk, never denied anything on the pretext call, responded to the detective by asking about timing, and testified he was never alone with Taylor from 2006 to 2011 (¶¶ 28–29). The court reviewed the call audio itself and noted the tone shift (¶ 28 n.4).

Issue 2: Ineffective assistance, footage and report (mixed, ¶ 23): affirmed (harmless error)

Assuming deficient performance, Marx was not prejudiced. Strickland prejudice and Brady materiality ask the same reasonable-probability question, comparing Archuleta v. Galetka, 2011 UT 73, ¶ 40, 267 P.3d 232, with Carter, so the Part I ruling resolved this claim (¶¶ 33–34).

Issue 3: Ineffective assistance, chocolate allergy (mixed, ¶ 23): affirmed (harmless error)

Assuming deficient performance, the failure to present allergy evidence did not prejudice Marx. His self-conducted chocolate test (after washing and scratching “with some vigor”) and a skin-prick test showing only “sensitivity” would have undercut his and his father’s testimony about anaphylaxis-level reactions (¶¶ 36–37). He identified no medical expert or expected testimony, so the claim was speculative, citing State v. Gerber, 2015 UT App 76, ¶ 14, 347 P.3d 852, and see State v. Suhail, 2023 UT App 15, ¶ 124, 525 P.3d 550 (¶ 38). He did not seek a 23B remand on this point (¶ 38 n.5).

Issue 4: Rule 23B remand (none stated, ¶ 24): Marx’s rule 23B motion denied

Even accepting deficient performance in not calling New Expert, Marx showed no prejudice under the totality-of-the-evidence counterfactual in State v. Samora, 2023 UT 5, ¶ 22, 529 P.3d 330 (¶ 42). The other evidence created credibility problems the testimony would not overcome (¶ 44). The memory opinion said only that early memories “may not be accurately retrieved,” and could not explain Taylor’s detailed recall of the St. George house, which Marx never contradicted (¶ 45, n.6). Testimony that false allegations “can occur” more often in contentious divorces was unquantified and likely within jurors’ common understanding (¶ 46).

Takeaways

  • Where Brady materiality has been rejected, a parallel ineffective-assistance claim on the same evidence fails for the same reason (¶ 34).
  • Evidence that cuts both ways may not be material when weighed against the whole record (¶¶ 26, 28).
  • An ineffective-assistance claim for not calling an expert needs an identified expert and expected testimony in the record (¶ 38).
  • Proposed 23B expert testimony framed in possibilities (“may,” “can occur”) carried little weight against specific trial evidence (¶¶ 45–46).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Marx
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 109
Case no.
20230044-CA
Filed
2023
Decided
July 23, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Marx
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Jury convictions for sodomy upon a child and tampering with a witness, carrying concurrent sentences of twenty-five years to life and zero to five years

The panel

Amy J. OliverAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred
Trial court
Fifth District Court, St. George Department · Judge Jeffrey C. Wilcox

Parties & counsel

Marx — AppellantIndividual(s)Staci VisserAnn Marie Taliaferro
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownKaren A. Klucznik

Practice Tip

To show prejudice from counsel's failure to call an expert, put the expert's identity and expected testimony in the record or seek a rule 23B remand; otherwise the claim is speculative (¶ 38 & n.5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.