Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Was shooting from a car at an angry crowd self-defense? State v. Rendon

2026 UT App 123No. 20240269-CADecided Aug 6, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Sufficient evidence disproved Rendon’s justification defense and supported an initial-aggressor instruction under Utah Code § 76-2-402(3)(a)(iii), and any error in refusing a curative instruction on the prosecutor’s overbroad statement that one cannot defend an aggressor was harmless given overwhelming evidence the shooting was not justified.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals ruled for the State on all three of Rendon’s arguments and upheld his murder and firearm convictions.

  • The jury could reasonably decide the shooting was not justified, given the space between the car and the crowd and the car’s clear path to drive away.
  • Evidence that Rendon yelled at the driver to “go back” to the party was enough to let the jury hear the rule that an aggressor generally cannot claim self-defense.
  • The prosecutor’s statement that you can never defend an aggressor was too broad, but the court held any error in not correcting it was harmless here.

What happened?

Anthony Dominic Rendon and his friends arrived at a house party as it was ending. The court used made-up names for everyone but Rendon. His friend Andrew fought with another guest, Will, and Rendon’s group drove off.

The evidence showed that Rendon and Andrew then yelled at the driver, Curtis, to “go back” so Andrew could “get” Will. Back at the party, Will body-slammed Andrew. Andrew got into the driver’s seat, and an angry crowd attacked the car. After Andrew stopped to let Curtis in, there was considerable space between the car and the crowd and nothing blocking the way. Rendon then fired thirteen shots from the back seat. One hit Will in the chest and killed him.

What happened at trial?

Rendon admitted he was the shooter but argued he acted to defend himself and his friends. The judge told the jury that a person who was “the aggressor” generally cannot claim self-defense. In closing, the prosecutor said, “You don’t get to defend another person who was an aggressor.” Rendon asked for a curative instruction, meaning a statement from the judge correcting a lawyer’s error. The judge said she would look at it but never ruled, and none was given.

The jury convicted Rendon of murder and eleven counts of felony discharge of a firearm. The judge denied his requests to set aside the verdict and for a new trial.

Did the evidence support rejecting self-defense?

Yes. The State had to disprove justification beyond a reasonable doubt, the highest standard of proof. The court held a reasonable jury could find it did so. The car had room to drive away, no one testified that Rendon’s group saw a partygoer carrying a maintenance hole cover, and there was no evidence anyone in the crowd was armed. The court said the jury could find the shooting was retaliation, which is not lawful self-defense.

Was it right to tell the jury about the aggressor rule?

Yes. Rendon did not say the instruction misstated the law, only that he was not an aggressor. The court held that evidence he yelled at Curtis to go back, knowing Andrew wanted to “get” Will, let a jury find he acted in a way that would ordinarily lead to a fight.

What about the prosecutor’s comment?

The court agreed Rendon had a point: the law does let someone defend an aggressor in limited situations, such as when the aggressor withdraws and says so. It assumed, without deciding, that the judge should have given a correcting instruction. But it held the error was harmless, meaning it did not likely change the outcome, because the evidence that the shooting was not justified was overwhelming.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The convictions are affirmed.

What should people take from this?

Whether force was justified depends on the facts at the moment it is used. Here, the court pointed to the space from the crowd, the open road, and the lack of any seen weapon.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Mortensen, J., joined by Orme and Oliver, JJ.). Rendon fired thirteen shots from a car outside a party, killing Will. The State’s evidence was enough to disprove justification beyond a reasonable doubt, to support the initial-aggressor instruction, and to make any error in denying a curative instruction harmless (¶ 37).

Issue 1: Motion to arrest judgment (correctness, ¶ 16): affirmed (no error)

The trial court properly denied the motion to arrest judgment because a reasonable jury could find justification disproved beyond a reasonable doubt. Under Utah R. Crim. P. 23 and State v. Miller, 2023 UT 3, ¶ 50, 527 P.3d 1087, reversal requires evidence so inconclusive that reasonable minds must have doubted (¶ 20). Rendon fired with considerable space between car and crowd and nothing blocking the car; no one testified his group saw the partygoer with the maintenance hole cover; and no evidence showed anyone was armed or believed to be armed (¶ 22). Any forcible-felony threat had abated, see Utah Code § 76-2-402(2)(b) (¶ 23), and the jury could find retaliation, “illegal force used too late,” see State v. Berriel, 2013 UT 19, ¶ 14, 299 P.3d 1133 (¶ 24).

Issue 2: Initial-aggressor instruction and new trial (mixed, ¶ 17): affirmed (no error)

The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying a new trial, because evidence supported instructing on the aggressor provision, Utah Code § 76-2-402(3)(a)(iii). Rendon conceded the instruction tracked the statute and argued only that he was not the aggressor (¶ 28). Under State v. Schoenfeld, 545 P.2d 193, 196 (Utah 1976), an aggressor includes one who does acts “as would ordinarily lead to combat”; evidence that Rendon yelled at the driver to “go back” so Andrew could “get” Will supported that finding (¶ 29). The court rejected his claim that the detective “corrected” this testimony (¶ 29 n.4).

Issue 3: Curative instruction (abuse of discretion, ¶ 18): affirmed (harmless error)

Assuming the court abused its discretion by not giving a curative instruction, the error was harmless. The prosecutor’s statement was overbroad: the statute’s withdrawal clause allows defense of an aggressor in limited circumstances, see also Ray v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 2015 UT 83, ¶ 40, 359 P.3d 614 (¶ 32). But failure to give a requested instruction is reversible only if it misleads the jury to the party’s prejudice, State v. Kitzmiller, 2021 UT App 87, ¶ 29, 493 P.3d 1159, and errors are often harmless given overwhelming evidence, State v. Reece, 2015 UT 45, ¶ 33, 349 P.3d 712 (¶ 33). The evidence that the shooting was retaliatory and “too late” was overwhelming (¶¶ 34–36).

Takeaways

  • A sufficiency challenge to a justification defense fails where the record shows space to retreat by car, no seen weapon, and an abated threat (¶¶ 22–23).
  • Urging a return to a fight with knowledge of a companion’s intent can support an initial-aggressor instruction under Schoenfeld (¶ 29).
  • The aggressor bar in § 76-2-402(3)(a)(iii) has a withdrawal exception, so a flat statement that one cannot defend an aggressor is overbroad (¶ 32).
  • Even so, overwhelming evidence against justification can make a refused curative instruction harmless (¶¶ 33–36).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Rendon
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 123
Case no.
20240269-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
August 6, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Rendon
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Convictions for murder and eleven counts of felony discharge of a firearm after Rendon fired thirteen shots from a car outside a house party

The panel

David N. MortensenAuthor
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Kara L. Pettit

Parties & counsel

Rendon — AppellantIndividual(s)Freyja JohnsonRachel Phillips Ainscough
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownAubrey Bisbee

Practice Tip

When a prosecutor says flatly that a defendant cannot defend an aggressor, the statute's withdrawal clause makes that overbroad (¶ 32), but on appeal the request for a curative instruction must still be tied to prejudice, since overwhelming evidence against justification can render the error harmless (¶¶ 33–36).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.