Can a doctor tell a jury my car crash was “low impact”? Holmes v. Smith
Holding
The trial court erred by excluding workplace accommodation evidence under a misapplied collateral source rule, admitting medical records without rule 803(6) foundation, excluding a life care planner’s alternative projections under rules 702 and 403, and admitting an orthopedic surgeon’s collision-speed opinion without a rule 702 showing, and these errors together required a new trial.
Key takeaways
The Court of Appeals sided with Holmes, the injured driver who appealed, on her evidence challenges and ordered a new trial.
- An employer providing free workplace equipment does not reduce what an injured person can recover from the driver who caused the injury.
- Medical records offered under the business records exception need a qualified witness or a certification, and agreeing the records are genuine is not enough.
- A doctor may not give an opinion on how fast or hard a crash was without a showing of the expertise and reliable method needed for that opinion.
Utah cases relied on
- Peterson v. Hyundai Motor Co.2021 UT App 128
- Harris v. ShopKo Stores, Inc.2011 UT App 329
- Cove at Little Valley Homeowners Ass'n v. Traverse Ridge Special Service Dist.2022 UT 23
- Gardner v. Norman2025 UT 47
- Mahana v. Onyx Acceptance Corp.2004 UT 59
- Bailey v. Bayles2002 UT 58
- State v. Ellis2018 UT 2
- Belnap v. Graham2016 UT App 14
- State v. Rothlisberger2006 UT 49
Case details
- Case name
- Holmes v. Smith
- Court
- Utah Court of Appeals
- Citation
- 2026 UT App 89
- Case no.
- 20240613-CA
- Filed
- 2024
- Decided
- June 4, 2026
- Opinion type
- Authored
- Who appealed
- Holmes
- Disposition
- Reversed
The panel
Parties & counsel
Practice Tip
When offering medical records as business records, bring a certification or a witness who knows how the records were made; the treating expert's reliance on them and a stipulation to authenticity will not do (¶¶ 34–36).
Need appellate counsel?
Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.
About these Decision Summaries
Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.


