Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can my lawyers’ mistakes undo the end of my parental rights? In re A.H.

2026 UT App 88No. 20210353-CADecided Jun 4, 2026Juvenile & Child WelfareReversed

Holding

A parent’s statutory right to effective counsel in a termination case extended to a retained attorney who never appeared before trial, and retained and appointed counsel’s failure to file pretrial disclosures or seek a continuance was deficient and prejudicial because the excluded sibling and expert testimony created a reasonable probability of a different result.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the father, who appealed, and ordered a new trial on ending his rights to his two youngest children.

  • A parent’s right to effective counsel in a termination case reached a privately hired lawyer who had never entered an appearance before trial, because the court found the parents had actually hired him to represent them.
  • Court-appointed lawyers who stayed on the case but filed no witness lists and sought no extension or continuance performed deficiently, even though their clients had stopped talking to them.
  • Because the missing testimony was very persuasive to the court on remand, there was a reasonable probability the 2020 trial would have come out differently, so the father gets a new trial.

What happened?

Father and Mother have seven children. The Division of Child and Family Services (DCFS, the state child welfare agency) became involved in 2017 and twice removed the children from the home. The two youngest, whom the court calls by the made-up names Alice and Liam, have lived with the same foster family since August 2019.

Before the October 2020 termination trial, each parent had a court-appointed lawyer. The parents also paid a private lawyer a $1,000 retainer. The court later found he was acting as their attorney, promised to handle deadlines, and told them not to talk to their appointed lawyers. Nobody filed pretrial disclosures, the lists of witnesses and exhibits a party must give before trial.

On the first day of trial, the private lawyer asked for a delay and was refused as “untimely.” The parties agreed the five older brothers would go to their grandparents. As to Alice and Liam, the trial went forward, and the court let the parents call only themselves, the grandparents, and witnesses on the State’s list. The court ended both parents’ rights to Alice and Liam so the foster family could adopt them.

How did the case get here?

The Court of Appeals reversed in 2022 on the children’s best interest. The Utah Supreme Court reversed that decision in 2024 and sent the case back to decide the parents’ other issues. The Court of Appeals then sent the case to the juvenile court for a four-day hearing on the lawyers’ performance, where the five brothers, a former foster father, and an expert on sibling bonds testified. Mother died in December 2024, so only Father’s rights remain at issue.

What did the court decide?

Father won. A parent claiming “ineffective assistance of counsel” must show two things: the lawyer’s work fell below a reasonable standard, and there is a “reasonable probability” (enough to shake confidence in the result) that the outcome would have been different.

The court held the right to effective counsel covered the private lawyer even though he never appeared in the case before trial. His work was plainly deficient: he “did nothing,” as Father put it. The appointed lawyers were also deficient. They stayed on the case but filed no disclosures, sought no extension, and asked for no continuance (a delay of trial), even after learning that day that the State now wanted to split up the children. The State agreed the lawyers’ performance was deficient; the guardian ad litem, the lawyer for the children’s interests, did not.

Why did the mistakes matter?

The 2020 judge found Alice and Liam had “little beyond a biological connection” with their brothers. On remand, the court found the siblings’ testimony credible and found a “deep mutual affection and enduring emotional bond.” The expert, whom the court found highly persuasive, explained how children can be moved gradually from a foster home to relatives and described the harms of adoption-related loss. That testimony filled gaps the Supreme Court had pointed out in the original record.

What happens now?

The termination order as to Father is vacated, and the juvenile court will hold further proceedings, including a new trial. The court did not decide Father’s separate claim that DCFS failed to make reasonable efforts to keep the family together.

What should people take from this?

In a termination case, a lawyer’s failure to file witness lists can keep important evidence out entirely. When that evidence later proves persuasive, a parent may be entitled to a new trial.

Bottom line

Vacated and remanded “for such additional proceedings as may be appropriate, including a new trial” (¶ 94) (Harris, J., joined by Mortensen and Oliver, JJ.). After In re A.H., 2024 UT 26, 554 P.3d 969, reversed this court’s best-interest ruling in In re A.H., 2022 UT App 114, 518 P.3d 993, and returned the case for the remaining issues, the court ordered a remand to supplement the record (¶¶ 3, 16 & n.3). On the supplemented record, Father established both prongs of ineffective assistance (¶ 93). Mother died during the remand, so only Father’s rights are at issue (¶ 4 n.2).

Issue 1: Ineffective assistance of counsel (ineffective assistance, ¶ 42): reversed

All three of Parents’ lawyers performed deficiently, and the deficiencies prejudiced Father.

Retained counsel. Rejecting the GAL’s threshold argument, the court held the right to effective counsel under Utah Code § 78B-22-201(1)(b) extended to Retained Counsel though he was never counsel of record (¶¶ 47–50). It found persuasive Stoia v. United States, 22 F.3d 766, 769 (7th Cir. 1994), that ineffectiveness can arise “even though the attorney never appears in court,” and see Roderick v. Ricks, 2002 UT 84, ¶ 32, 54 P.3d 1119 (¶ 48). The remand court found, without challenge for clear error, that Parents paid a $1,000 retainer and he acted as their attorney, not a consultant (¶ 49).

Deficient performance. The State “readily” conceded deficiency; only the GAL contested it (¶¶ 52–53). Retained Counsel broke his promise to seek an extension and filed nothing before trial, with no conceivable strategy (¶ 54). Appointed Counsel stayed as counsel of record yet filed no disclosures and sought no extension or continuance (¶¶ 56, 59), cf. Dahl v. Dahl, 2015 UT 79, ¶ 83, 459 P.3d 276. In re R.G., 2023 UT App 114, 537 P.3d 627, was distinguishable because the communication breakdown came from Retained Counsel’s instruction, not a disengaged client (¶¶ 57–58). The futility rule of In re F.C.G., 2023 UT App 55, ¶ 11, 531 P.3d 763, did not apply: an earlier motion was not shown futile, and the State’s day-of-trial shift to separating the children was a new basis for a continuance (¶¶ 61–63).

Prejudice. Under In re C.M.R., 2020 UT App 114, ¶ 21, 473 P.3d 184, the court asked whether the October 2020 trial would have come out differently had the judge heard the remand evidence (¶ 65 & n.5). The new testimony undercut each category of the original reasoning: the sibling and parental bonds (¶¶ 68–76), the risks of changing a secure placement (¶¶ 77–82), and the long-term effects of termination and adoption (¶¶ 83–86). Expert’s testimony filled two evidentiary gaps the supreme court identified (¶¶ 75–76, 86, 92). The court rejected arguments that siblings cannot speak to Alice’s and Liam’s bonds, that best interest is child-specific, and that Expert never met the children and assumed a cooperative transition (¶¶ 88–92).

Not reached

Father’s claim that DCFS failed to make reasonable efforts, given the ruling on ineffective assistance (¶ 42 n.4). The court remarked that such arguments belong in the reasonable-efforts inquiry, not the best-interest inquiry.

Takeaways

  • A retained lawyer who never appears can still be the subject of an ineffective-assistance claim in a termination case when the client reasonably believed the lawyer represented them (¶¶ 48–50).
  • Appointed counsel who stay on the case cannot simply let disclosure deadlines pass because the client is not communicating (¶¶ 56, 59).
  • A day-of-trial change in the State’s position can supply a non-futile basis for a continuance (¶ 63).
  • Prejudice is judged against the original trial date, though any new trial is conducted present-tense (¶ 65 n.5).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
In re A.H.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 88
Case no.
20210353-CA
Filed
2021
Decided
June 4, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Disposition
Reversed
At stake
Termination of Father's parental rights to his two youngest children, Alice and Liam, so their foster family could adopt them

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
David N. MortensenConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Fourth Juvenile Court, Provo Department · Judge Suchada P. Bazzelle

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Alexandra MareschalKirstin H. NormanJason B. RichardsDebra M. Nelson
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyDerek E. BrownDeborah A. WoodJohn M. Peterson
Guardian ad litemOtherMartha PierceAlisha GilesHeath Haacke

Practice Tip

When a client in a termination case stops communicating, appointed counsel who remain of record should still protect disclosure deadlines or seek an extension or continuance; the court held that doing none of these was objectively unreasonable (¶¶ 56, 59, 62).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.