Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can I be charged for stolen property I’ve kept for over four years? State v. Vance

2026 UT App 111No. 20240668-CADecided Jul 23, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Whether theft by receiving stolen property under Utah Code § 76-6-408(2) is a continuing offense depends on the actus reus; “retaining” stolen property is continuing, and because Vance admitted retaining the skid steer until September 8, 2021, the June 1, 2022 prosecution was not barred by the four-year limitations period.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld the denial of Vance’s motion to dismiss his stolen-property charge as too late.

  • Whether theft by receiving stolen property is a continuing offense depends on which act the case involves.
  • Receiving stolen property happens at one moment, but retaining (keeping) it continues for as long as the person keeps it.
  • Because Vance admitted facts showing he kept the skid steer until September 2021, the June 2022 charge was not too late.

What happened?

In September 2021, police got a tip that Vance had a stolen skid steer, a tracked vehicle used in construction and landscaping. Officers found it parked in a field, with the identification numbers removed or scratched off. They identified it from the serial number on the engine block and confirmed it had been reported stolen. It had been missing since about April 2018.

Vance arrived while officers were there. He argued that the skid steer belonged to him and that he had owned it for four years, but he could not show proof of ownership.

Why did Vance say the charge was too late?

The State charged Vance on June 1, 2022, with theft by receiving stolen property, a third-degree felony. Utah law generally requires a felony prosecution to start within four years after the crime is committed. This deadline is called a statute of limitations.

Vance argued that because the skid steer went missing in April 2018, the charge came more than four years too late. The district court denied his motion to dismiss, ruling that this crime is a “continuing offense.” That means the crime keeps being committed for as long as the person keeps doing it, and the four-year clock does not start until the person stops.

Vance then pleaded guilty but kept the right to appeal that ruling. This is called a conditional guilty plea.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed. The court looked at the words of the statute. A person can commit this crime in several ways, including by receiving stolen property or by retaining it.

Receiving means coming into possession of the property, which happens at one point in time, so it is not a continuing offense. Retaining means keeping the property, which can go on for days, weeks or years, so it is a continuing offense.

Vance argued that an earlier Utah Supreme Court case, State v. Hummel, 2017 UT 19, 393 P.3d 314, treated all forms of theft as a single crime, so this crime could never be continuing. The court disagreed, explaining that Hummel was about whether a jury must agree unanimously, not about filing deadlines, and that it did not mention receiving stolen property.

Did Vance’s own admissions matter?

Yes. Vance argued that he only “received” the skid steer, no later than April 2018. But in his plea he also admitted he told police in September 2021 that he had owned it for four years. The court held that this meant he retained the stolen skid steer until September 8, 2021. The four-year clock started then, so the June 2022 charge was on time.

What did the court leave open?

The State argued that concealing and withholding stolen property are also continuing offenses. The court declined to address those questions because they were not at issue in this case.

What happens now?

The ruling denying Vance’s motion to dismiss stands, and so does his guilty plea.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Oliver, J., joined by Tenney and Luthy, JJ.). Theft by receiving stolen property under Utah Code § 76-6-408(2) is a continuing offense when committed by “retaining” stolen property, though not when committed by “receiving” it (¶¶ 9–12). Vance’s plea admissions established retention through September 8, 2021, so the June 1, 2022 charge was timely (¶¶ 17–18).

Issue 1: Whether theft by receiving stolen property is a continuing offense (correctness, ¶ 5): affirmed (no error)

The district court correctly denied the motion to dismiss, because Vance admitted to retaining stolen property, a continuing offense that did not end until September 8, 2021 (¶ 18).

Framework. A felony prosecution must start within four years after the offense is committed, Utah Code § 76-1-302(1)(a), but for a continuing offense the limitations period does not begin until the perpetrator stops satisfying the elements (¶ 6, quoting State v. Taylor, 2015 UT 42, ¶ 12, 349 P.3d 696). Taylor held theft is not continuing because “obtaining or exercising” are discrete acts, but noted in dicta that receiving stolen property includes an actus reus of retaining (¶¶ 7–8).

Statutory text. Because § 76-6-408(2) lists multiple actus rei, whether the offense is continuing “is a fact-specific question that depends on the actus reus at issue” (¶ 9). “Receives,” defined in § 76-6-408(1)(a)(iv) as acquiring possession or control, occurs at a single point in time (¶ 10). “Retains,” undefined, means “to keep in possession or use,” which is ongoing by nature (¶ 11).

Hummel. The court declined to extend State v. Hummel, 2017 UT 19, 393 P.3d 314, which treated theft as a single crime for jury unanimity. Hummel did not mention Taylor or receiving stolen property, addressed a different context, and a statute of limitations is “a filing deadline in a district court” (¶¶ 13–14, quoting State v. Rettig, 2017 UT 83, ¶ 58 n.13, 416 P.3d 520). The court also noted that Hummel rested partly on statutory language since amended in 2023 (¶ 14 n.6).

Application. Vance argued only “receiving” was at issue, completed by April 30, 2018 (¶ 16). But he also admitted telling police in September 2021 that the skid steer “belonged to him and that he had owned it for four years,” which necessarily establishes retention (¶ 17).

The court declined to decide the State’s argument that “conceal[ing]” and “withhold[ing]” are also continuing, because neither was before it (¶ 12 n.5, citing State v. Webster, 2001 UT App 238, ¶ 23 n.3, 32 P.3d 976).

Takeaways

  • For limitations challenges under § 76-6-408, identify which actus reus the charge and plea rest on; “receives” is instantaneous and “retains” is continuing (¶¶ 9–12).
  • Factual admissions in a plea agreement can establish the continuing actus reus even when the defendant frames the case as receipt only (¶ 17).
  • Hummel’s single-crime holding was not extended to the statute-of-limitations question (¶¶ 13–14).
  • Whether concealing or withholding is continuing remains open (¶ 12 n.5).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Vance
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 111
Case no.
20240668-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
July 23, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Vance
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A third-degree felony charge of theft by receiving stolen property, a stolen skid steer, that the defendant argued was barred by the four-year statute of limitations

The panel

Amy J. OliverAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Provo Department · Judge Robert A. Lund

Parties & counsel

Vance — AppellantIndividual(s)Dallas B. YoungJennifer L. Foresta
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownChristopher D. Ballard

Practice Tip

In a limitations challenge to a theft-by-receiving charge, look at every factual admission in the plea or record, because admissions showing continued possession can establish "retaining," which the court held is a continuing offense (¶¶ 11–12, 17).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.