Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a teen appeal a juvenile custody order after release? In re M.M.

2026 UT App 105No. 20250665-CADecided Jul 16, 2026Juvenile & Child WelfareDismissed

Holding

A juvenile’s appeal of a JJYS custody placement, brought as an ineffective assistance claim because the statutory objection was unpreserved, is moot once he is no longer in custody, and the mootness exception does not apply because that fact-specific claim is not likely to recur.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the State and dismissed M.M.’s appeal as moot.

  • Because M.M. was no longer in custody on these charges, his challenge to the custody order was moot.
  • The court looked at the actual claim on appeal, ineffective assistance of counsel, and held that this claim was not likely to come up again.
  • The court did not decide whether contempt adjudications count as prior misdemeanors under the juvenile commitment statute.

What happened?

In September 2024 the State filed a petition alleging that M.M., then fourteen, had committed retail theft and failed to stop at a police officer’s command. He admitted the allegations and was adjudicated delinquent, which is the juvenile court’s version of a finding of guilt. Over the following months he was put on house arrest, spent time in detention, admitted five contempt of court allegations, and faced new charges from a fast-food restaurant incident and a second retail theft.

A Utah statute lets a juvenile court commit a minor to the division only in certain situations. One is when the minor is adjudicated for a misdemeanor and has “five prior misdemeanors or felony adjudications arising from separate criminal episodes.” The court asked the lawyers whether contempt adjudications count. The State wrote that they likely do not. M.M.’s lawyer filed nothing and took no position on the point. The court ruled that the contempts did count and placed M.M. in JJYS custody.

What did each side argue on appeal?

Everyone agreed that M.M.’s lawyer had not preserved an objection to the court’s reading of the statute. Preserving an objection means raising it in the trial court first. So M.M. argued that his lawyer gave him ineffective assistance, meaning legal help so poor it violated his constitutional right to counsel.

The State argued that the appeal was moot. A case is moot when later events mean a ruling could no longer make any practical difference. The parties agreed M.M. was no longer in custody on these charges. M.M. admitted the appeal was moot but asked the court to use an exception that lets courts decide moot issues that affect the public interest, are likely to recur, and are likely to evade review.

What did the court decide?

The court dismissed the appeal. It said the exception is applied issue by issue, and the issue M.M. actually raised was not the meaning of the statute. It was whether his own lawyer performed so poorly in this case that the Constitution was violated.

The court assumed, without deciding, that the lawyer’s performance was unreasonable. Even so, it said unreasonable lawyer behavior is “almost by definition, unlikely to recur.” It also said ineffective assistance claims depend heavily on the facts of each case. M.M. pointed to three Illinois decisions, but the court found them different because they involved a specific Illinois mental health commitment law. M.M. therefore did not prove that the exception applied.

What happens now?

Nothing more happens in this appeal. Because the issue was moot, the court said it lacked jurisdiction (the power to decide the case) and dismissed it. The juvenile court’s ruling stays in place.

What should people take from this?

The court left open whether contempt adjudications count as prior misdemeanors under the statute. It said that at some point a lawyer will raise and preserve that question, and then it will be squarely presented for an appeals court to answer.

Bottom line

Appeal dismissed (Harris, J., joined by Mortensen and Oliver, JJ.). The juvenile court ruled that M.M.’s contempt adjudications counted as “prior misdemeanors” under Utah Code § 80-6-703(2)(b)(ii) and committed him to JJYS custody (¶ 13). The parties agreed the statutory objection was unpreserved, so M.M. raised it through ineffective assistance (¶ 15). Because M.M. is no longer in custody on those charges, the claim is moot. The court dismissed for lack of jurisdiction because the mootness exception does not reach an ineffective assistance claim that is unlikely to recur (¶¶ 29–31).

Issue 1: Mootness of the ineffective assistance claim (none stated, ¶¶ 16–31): not reached

The appeal is moot, and M.M. did not carry his burden of showing that the exception to the mootness doctrine applies (¶ 30). An appellate mootness question is “not governed by any standard of review” (¶ 16). Mootness “implicates our judicial power,” so courts cannot hear a moot issue unless an exception applies (¶ 18, citing State v. Dowhaniuk, 2025 UT App 100, ¶ 33, 574 P.3d 1000). The exception requires an issue that affects the public interest, is likely to recur, and is likely to evade review, and the party invoking it bears the burden (¶ 19, citing State v. Seat, 2022 UT App 143, ¶ 33, 523 P.3d 724, and Ramirez v. Landau, 2026 UT App 17, ¶ 15, 586 P.3d 536).

The exception is applied issue by issue (¶ 20). The issue presented was ineffective assistance, a “stand-alone constitutional claim,” not raw statutory interpretation (¶ 22, quoting State v. Johnson, 2017 UT 76, ¶ 22, 416 P.3d 443). Assuming without deciding that counsel performed deficiently, unreasonable attorney behavior is “almost by definition, unlikely to recur.” That falls short of a “reasonable expectation or a demonstrated probability that the same controversy will recur” (¶ 27, quoting Utah Transit Auth. v. Local 382 of Amalgamated Transit Union, 2012 UT 75, ¶ 36, 289 P.3d 582). Ineffective assistance claims are fact-specific on both deficiency and prejudice (¶ 28).

The court distinguished M.M.’s Illinois authorities, including In re Leo M., 2022 IL App (5th) 190211, ¶ 29, 217 N.E.3d 239. They involve a specific Illinois involuntary-commitment statute, contain little analysis on recurrence, and two apply a different mootness exception (¶ 27 n.7). The court also questioned whether the public-interest element was met, but offered no analysis because the State did not argue it (¶ 25 n.6).

Not reached

Whether contempt adjudications count as prior misdemeanors under § 80-6-703(2)(b)(ii). The court said this will be “squarely presented” once a reasonable attorney preserves it (¶ 29). The court also suggested the preservation question was “closer than the parties make it appear,” but followed the parties’ agreement that it was unpreserved (¶ 15 n.5).

Takeaways

  • Courts apply the mootness exception to the issue actually raised on appeal, so framing an unpreserved claim as ineffective assistance changes the issue being tested (¶¶ 20–24).
  • Assuming deficient performance, an ineffective assistance claim is unlikely to satisfy the likely-to-recur element (¶¶ 27–28).
  • The party invoking the mootness exception carries the burden on each element (¶¶ 19, 30).
  • The statutory question about contempt adjudications remains open (¶ 29).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
In re M.M.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 105
Case no.
20250665-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
July 16, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
The juvenile court's order placing M.M. in the custody of Juvenile Justice and Youth Services (JJYS) after delinquency and contempt adjudications

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
David N. MortensenConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Second Juvenile Court, Ogden Department · Judge Rick T. Westmoreland

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Emily AdamsAnna GrigsbyMonica Maio
Appellee — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownJason E. Greene

Practice Tip

To get an appellate ruling on whether contempt adjudications count as prior misdemeanors under Utah Code § 80-6-703(2)(b)(ii), raise and preserve the objection in juvenile court; the court said the statutory question will be squarely presented once a reasonable attorney preserves it (¶ 29).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.