Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

If the judge raises a damages theory, can I argue it on appeal? Abu-Ulba v. Ananda Scientific

2026 UT 24No. 20240716Decided Jul 29, 2026Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed

Holding

Although a district court’s sua sponte ruling on an issue may preserve it for appeal, it must comport with the preservation principles of judicial economy and fairness, and the district court’s rejection of Abu-Ulba’s Note Theory as too speculative, on an undeveloped factual record and without notice to Ananda, did not preserve it.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with Ananda Scientific and held that Abu-Ulba could not rely on his promissory-note damages theory on appeal.

  • When a trial judge raises and decides an issue on its own, that can preserve the issue for appeal, but not automatically.
  • The court asks whether treating the issue as preserved serves judicial economy and fairness to the other side.
  • Abu-Ulba could not argue on appeal for damages based on the promissory note, because he never offered that theory at trial and the facts behind it were never developed.

What happened?

John Abu-Ulba founded a successful hemp company. Ananda Scientific, Inc., a start-up, hired him and paid him less than market rate. To help make up the difference, it gave him stock options. He bought 550,000 shares at $0.85 each by signing a promissory note for $467,500, which was to be forgiven rather than repaid.

Abu-Ulba later learned that Ananda had misrepresented its clinical trials and its technology. He sued Ananda and Mark J. Rosenfeld under Utah’s securities laws.

What did the trial court decide?

After a bench trial (a trial with a judge and no jury), the district court found that Ananda had violated the law intentionally. Ananda does not dispute that.

The harder question was damages. Asked how to calculate them, Abu-Ulba said they were “the value of his work for the company” and that he had no way of figuring out the number. So the judge identified three possible measures on its own. One, which the court called the “Note Theory,” used the note and the strike price (the price per share he paid to exercise the options). The judge rejected it as too speculative. Instead, it measured damages by the pay gap: $5,000 a month for twenty-three months, or $115,000, tripled to $345,000 because the violation was intentional.

What happened on the first appeal?

Abu-Ulba appealed and argued that damages should be the note’s face value of $467,500. The Court of Appeals held the argument was not preserved. “Preserved” means the issue was properly raised in the trial court, which is usually required before an appeals court will consider it. Abu-Ulba then asked the Utah Supreme Court to review that ruling, and it agreed to.

What did the Utah Supreme Court decide?

It affirmed. The court explained that preservation rests on two goals: judicial economy (letting the trial court fix problems first and saving appeals) and fairness (giving the other side a chance to respond). A trial judge’s own ruling on an issue can preserve it, but only when treating it as preserved serves those goals.

Here it did not. The judge rejected the Note Theory because the facts behind it were never developed. If the trial court lacked enough facts, the appeals court had even less to work with. The question was also factual, not a pure question of law like those in earlier cases where a judge’s own ruling preserved an issue.

Fairness also cut against Abu-Ulba. He had chances to propose the note as his measure of damages and did not. His statements gave Ananda no reason to treat the note as a live theory, object to it, or build a response.

What happens now?

The Court of Appeals’ decision stands, and Abu-Ulba cannot rely on the Note Theory on appeal.

What should people take from this?

A judge mentioning a theory is not a substitute for a party arguing it. A party who wants a particular measure of damages generally needs to propose it and back it with evidence at trial.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Durrant, C.J., joined by Petersen, J., Pohlman, A.C.J., Nielsen, J., and District Judge Bell, sitting in place of Hagen, J.). No categorical rule makes every issue a district court considers sua sponte preserved. An issue the court takes up on its own “may be preserved” when that review satisfies judicial economy and fairness (¶ 28). The Note Theory failed both (¶¶ 32–38).

Issue 1: Sua sponte preservation of the Note Theory (correctness, ¶ 20): affirmed (no error)

The district court’s sua sponte consideration and rejection of the Note Theory did not preserve it for appeal, because treating it as preserved would serve neither judicial economy nor fairness (¶ 38).

Framework. The court traced Kell v. State, 2012 UT 25, 285 P.3d 1133, where the district court gave an issue a thoroughgoing analysis and the State had a chance to oppose it (¶ 25); Fort Pierce Indus. Park Phases II, III, IV Owners Ass’n. v. Shakespeare, 2016 UT 28, ¶ 13, 379 P.3d 1218, where the court’s decision to take up a question overcame the preservation objection (¶ 26); and Cove at Little Valley Homeowners Ass’n v. Traverse Ridge Special Serv. Dist., 2022 UT 23, ¶ 29, 513 P.3d 658, where a broad ruling on the ultimate issue did not preserve the specific issue (¶ 27).

Judicial economy. The district court plainly addressed the Note Theory (¶ 31), but rejected it as too speculative because the parties never developed the facts (¶ 32). If the district court lacked enough facts, the appellate court “certainly” does not (¶ 33). Relying on Patterson v. Patterson, 2011 UT 68, ¶ 15, 266 P.3d 828, the court said preservation applies most strictly to issues requiring factual predicates; Kell and Fort Pierce involved legal questions, which more readily suit appellate review (¶¶ 30, 34).

Fairness. Abu-Ulba had several chances to ask for damages based on the Note and instead said his damages were “the value of his work for the company” and that he had no way of figuring that out (¶ 36). That gave Ananda no reason to treat the Note Theory as a live theory requiring objection, so treating it as preserved would let him rely on a theory Ananda had no meaningful reason or opportunity to contest at trial (¶ 37).

The court did not adopt the Court of Appeals’ “take up” and “thoroughgoing analysis” reasoning as the test (¶¶ 17–18). It resolved the question under the judicial economy and fairness principles (¶¶ 28–29).

Takeaways

  • A district court’s sua sponte ruling can preserve an issue, but only if that serves judicial economy and fairness; there is no categorical rule (¶ 28).
  • Sua sponte preservation is harder for fact-dependent issues than for pure legal questions like those in Kell and Fort Pierce (¶¶ 33–34).
  • A party’s own statements at trial disclaiming a calculable damages theory can defeat later reliance on a theory the court raised (¶¶ 36–37).

Who’s who

Abu-Ulba was the plaintiff below and the appellant; Ananda Scientific, Inc. and Mark J. Rosenfeld were the defendants and appellees.

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Abu-Ulba v. Ananda Scientific
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2026 UT 24
Case no.
20240716
Filed
2024
Decided
July 29, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Abu-Ulba
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether Abu-Ulba could argue on appeal that his securities damages should be measured by the $467,500 promissory note rather than the under-compensation measure that produced a tripled award of $345,000

The panel

Matthew B. DurrantAuthor
Matthew L. BellConcurred
NielsenConcurred
Paige PetersenConcurred
Jill M. PohlmanConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake County · Judge Kent R. Holmberg

Parties & counsel

Abu-Ulba — AppellantIndividual(s)Troy L. BooherTaylor P. WebbKenneth L. Reich
Ananda Scientific — AppelleeOtherTimothy R. PackAaron D. Lebenta

Practice Tip

Do not count on a trial judge's own discussion of a damages theory to preserve it; propose the theory and develop its factual basis at trial, especially where the issue turns on facts rather than law (¶¶ 32–37).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.