Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Can I add new claims to my post-conviction petition after the deadline? Nunez v. State

2026 UT 25No. 20240402Decided Jul 30, 2026Post-Conviction ReliefAffirmed

Holding

Rule 15(c) of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure applies to post-conviction petitions even when the district court grants leave to amend under rule 65C(h)(3), Patterson v. State, 2021 UT 52, did not make that test discretionary, and the PCRA’s one-year time bar was not unconstitutional for the reasons Nunez asserted.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with the State and upheld the dismissal of Nunez’s amended post-conviction petition as filed too late.

  • A post-conviction petitioner who amends after the one-year deadline can add only claims that grow out of the same facts as the original petition.
  • Permission to fix “pleading errors” under rule 65C(h)(3) covers correcting existing claims, not adding new ones.
  • The court again refused to bring back an “interests of justice” exception to the deadline.

What happened?

A jury convicted Oscar Alonso Nunez of various child sexual abuse crimes. The Court of Appeals upheld his convictions, and the Utah Supreme Court declined to review them.

A year later, Nunez filed a petition for post-conviction relief, a separate case asking a court to undo a conviction after the direct appeal is over. The district court dismissed it because the claims had already been decided in his direct appeal.

Nunez got a new lawyer, who got the dismissal set aside. The court then let Nunez file an amended petition. The new petition raised claims that Nunez admitted were “quite different” from his original ones.

Why was the amended petition a problem?

Utah’s Post-Conviction Remedies Act (PCRA) gives a petitioner one year to bring claims. Nunez filed his amended petition after that year had passed.

Under rule 15(c) of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure, a late amendment counts as filed on the original date only if it “relates back,” meaning the new claim arises from the same conduct or events described in the original petition. Nunez’s new claims did not. The State asked the court to dismiss them as untimely, and the district court did.

What did Nunez argue?

He made three arguments. First, that rule 65C(h)(3), which lets a petitioner fix a “pleading error,” let him amend however he wished. Second, that a 2021 case, Patterson v. State, 2021 UT 52, 504 P.3d 92, gave judges the choice whether to apply the relation-back test. Third, that the one-year deadline violated the Utah Constitution’s Open Courts Clause, which protects people’s access to the courts to seek a remedy.

What did the court decide?

It rejected all three arguments.

On the first, the court said rule 65C(h)(3) “is not a blank check.” It lets a petitioner correct pleading or technical errors in existing claims. Adding new claims is not fixing a pleading error. The court had rejected the same argument in Noor v. State, 2019 UT 3, 435 P.3d 221.

On the second, the court said Patterson did not overrule Noor. Patterson said the court uses its power over these petitions “in total harmony with the PCRA,” including its one-year deadline.

On the third, Nunez’s argument depended on reviving an “interests of justice” exception to the deadline from an older case. The court declined to do that, as it had in Patterson. It said what matters is whether a constitutional right was violated, not how unfair the circumstances feel, and Nunez did not explain how anything stopped him from raising his claims within the year.

Did the court consider his other constitutional claims?

No. Nunez said in his reply brief that his due process argument was really a Suspension Clause argument, so the court treated due process as waived. Because his Suspension Clause argument was thin and mixed in with his Open Courts argument, the court looked only at the Open Courts claim.

What happens now?

The dismissal stands. Nunez’s amended petition will not be heard on its merits.

What should people take from this?

In a post-conviction case, the one-year deadline is enforced. New claims added later must come from the same facts as the claims filed on time.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Nielsen, J., joined by Petersen, J., Pohlman, A.C.J., Jorgensen, J., and Court of Appeals Judge Harris). Chief Justice Durrant recused, Justice Hagen stepped down, and Justice Dent joined the court after argument and did not participate. The court reaffirmed that rule 15(c) applies to PCRA petitions “even where a district court grants a petitioner leave to amend a petition under rule 65C(h)(3),” and held the one-year time bar and rule 15(c)’s application were not unconstitutional for the reasons Nunez asserted (¶ 33). It was undisputed that the amended claims did not relate back (¶ 19).

Issue 1: Rule 65C(h)(3) and rule 15(c) (correctness, ¶ 14): affirmed (no error)

Rule 65C(h)(3) does not let a petitioner add new claims after the limitations period without satisfying rule 15(c). Following Noor v. State, 2019 UT 3, ¶ 26, 435 P.3d 221, rule 65C does not address new claims in late amended petitions, so rule 15(c) fills the gap (¶ 20). Rule 65C(h)(3) is “quite narrow”: it lets a petitioner correct pleading or technical errors on existing claims, and “[a]dding new claims does not correct a ‘pleading error’” (¶ 22). The court rejected Nunez’s attempt to distinguish Noor on timing of service; Noor made the same argument (¶ 22 n.2). It left the full contours of “pleading error” open but held they do not include new claims (¶ 22 n.3).

Issue 2: Effect of Patterson (correctness, ¶ 14): affirmed (no error)

Patterson v. State, 2021 UT 52, 504 P.3d 92, did not give district courts discretion to skip rule 15(c). Patterson did not abrogate the relation-back test or overrule Noor’s holding that courts lack discretion to allow non-relating new claims after the limitations period (¶ 26). Patterson reaffirmed that rule 65C incorporates the PCRA, including its one-year limitations period, and that the court exercises its writ power “in total harmony with the PCRA” (¶¶ 24, 26, quoting Patterson ¶ 174).

Issue 3: Open Courts Clause (correctness, ¶ 14): affirmed (no error)

The time bar did not violate the Open Courts Clause in Nunez’s case. His argument required reinstating the “interests of justice” exception from Julian v. State, 966 P.2d 249 (Utah 1998), which the court called “now defunct” and again declined to revive, as in Patterson ¶¶ 200–04 (¶¶ 28–30 & n.5). Whether Patterson’s hypothetical constitutional exception applies “turns not on how egregious the petitioner’s circumstances are, but on whether the constitution was violated” (¶ 32). Nunez did not show how he was prevented from asserting his claims within the year (¶ 32).

Issue 4: Due process (none reached, ¶ 27 n.4): not reached

Nunez waived his due process challenge in his reply brief by saying it should be read as a Suspension Clause argument (¶ 27 n.4).

Issue 5: Suspension Clause (none reached, ¶ 27 n.4): not reached

The court limited review to the Open Courts claim because the Suspension Clause discussion was sparse and conflated with the Open Courts analysis (¶ 27 n.4).

Takeaways

  • Leave to amend under rule 65C(h)(3) does not shelter new claims from rule 15(c)’s relation-back test (¶¶ 22, 33).
  • Patterson leaves Noor intact; district courts lack discretion to accept non-relating claims after the limitations period (¶ 26).
  • An as-applied constitutional challenge to the time bar must show an actual constitutional violation, not just hard circumstances (¶ 32).
  • Brief each state constitutional clause separately; a sparse or conflated argument may be set aside (¶ 27 n.4).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Nunez v. State
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2026 UT 25
Case no.
20240402
Filed
2024
Decided
July 30, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Nunez
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Nunez's amended petition for post-conviction relief from his child sexual abuse convictions, dismissed as untimely under the PCRA's one-year time bar

The panel

NielsenAuthor
Ryan M. HarrisConcurred
Jay T. JorgensenConcurred
Paige PetersenConcurred
Jill M. PohlmanConcurred
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Provo Department · Judge Thomas Low

Parties & counsel

Nunez — AppellantIndividual(s)David Ferguson
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. Brown, Utah Attorney General's OfficeDaniel L. Day, Utah Attorney General's Office

Practice Tip

When amending a PCRA petition after the one-year period, tie each new claim to the conduct, transaction, or occurrence alleged in the original petition, because rule 65C(h)(3) leave covers only pleading or technical errors on existing claims (¶¶ 22, 33).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.