Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Is a low underinsured motorist offer bad faith? Newman v. LM General Insurance Co.

2026 UT App 94No. 20241295-CADecided Jun 19, 2026InsuranceAffirmed

Holding

Summary judgment for LM was proper on the alternative ground that Newman’s UIM claim was fairly debatable as a matter of law, because on the unrebutted record LM diligently investigated, fairly evaluated the uncertain value of her general damages, and acted promptly and reasonably to resolve the claim.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with LM General Insurance Company and upheld the dismissal of Erica Newman’s bad faith lawsuit.

  • An insurer that has a legitimate dispute about how much a claim is worth may argue about it without acting in bad faith, if it also investigates and handles the claim reasonably.
  • The court looked at LM’s offer as $36,500 in total, counting the $35,000 Newman had already received, not as $1,500.
  • The court did not decide whether Newman’s attorney fees or emotional distress could count as damages.

What happened?

In June 2019, another driver hit the car Erica Newman was driving. She injured her right knee, among other injuries. The other driver’s insurer paid its $25,000 limit, and her own insurer, LM General Insurance Company (LM), paid $10,000 in personal injury protection benefits, which cover some injury costs no matter who caused the crash.

Newman’s LM policy also had underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage of up to $100,000. That coverage pays what the injured person could have collected from the at-fault driver when that driver’s insurance is too small. In May 2020, Newman demanded the full $100,000 and gave LM fourteen days to answer.

How did LM respond?

An LM adjuster replied within the deadline, said he had reviewed her records, and asked for more information. The same day she answered, he offered $1,500 on top of what she had already received and said he was willing to discuss it further. He followed up three weeks later to ask for a counteroffer. Newman instead asked for arbitration, a private hearing before a neutral decision-maker. LM promptly paid the $1,500 when she asked for it.

The arbitrator found her total damages were $61,255.44 and that LM owed her another $24,755.44, which LM paid two weeks later. Newman then sued LM for acting in bad faith.

What did the district court do?

It granted summary judgment for LM, meaning it decided the case without a trial. It ruled that Newman had not shown she was actually harmed by LM’s conduct.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed, but on a different ground. An appeals court may uphold a ruling for any legal reason the record supports. Under Utah law, when a claim is “fairly debatable,” the insurer may dispute it without breaking its duty of good faith.

The court found that LM met each of its duties. It investigated: the adjuster’s sworn statement that he reviewed all of Newman’s documents went unrebutted. It evaluated the claim fairly: the court treated the offer as $36,500 in total, and said damages for pain and suffering vary widely, so LM’s view of their value was at least fairly debatable. Newman herself testified that the arbitrator’s award was “fair.” And it acted promptly and reasonably: the adjuster responded on time, made an offer, invited a counteroffer, and paid what was owed.

The court also disagreed with the district court’s view that the offer was a “nuisance offer” or a denial of the claim.

Did the court decide whether Newman had damages?

No. Because the fairly debatable ruling decided the case, the court did not decide whether her attorney fees or emotional distress could count as damages.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The judgment for LM stands.

What should people take from this?

A low offer alone did not prove bad faith here. The court looked at the whole process: whether the insurer reviewed the records, whether its valuation was within a reasonable range, and whether it kept trying to resolve the claim.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Mortensen, J., joined by Christiansen Forster and Harris, JJ.). The district court granted summary judgment because Newman had not shown damages, though it rejected LM’s fairly debatable argument (¶ 10 & n.4). The Court of Appeals affirmed on the alternative ground that the claim was fairly debatable as a matter of law (¶¶ 11, 31), relying on Bailey v. Bayles, 2002 UT 58, ¶ 20, 52 P.3d 1158.

Issue 1: Summary judgment on the bad faith claim — fairly debatable defense (correctness, ¶ 11): affirmed on other grounds

The court affirmed the summary judgment for LM on the alternative ground that Newman’s bad faith claim was fairly debatable as a matter of law, without reaching her damages arguments (¶¶ 11, 17, 31).

Part 1: Fairly debatable defense (the insurer’s alternative ground, ¶¶ 11–31)

LM was entitled to summary judgment because it diligently investigated, fairly evaluated, and acted promptly and reasonably on Newman’s UIM claim (¶ 17). The defense rests on the duties in Beck v. Farmers Ins. Exch., 701 P.2d 795, 801 (Utah 1985), as explained in Billings v. Union Bankers Ins. Co., 918 P.2d 461, 465 (Utah 1996) (¶¶ 12–13). A legitimate factual question about a claim’s value makes whether the insurer fairly evaluated it determinable as a matter of law (¶ 14, citing Prince v. Bear River Mutual Ins. Co., 2002 UT 68, ¶ 35, 56 P.3d 524). But summary judgment remains inappropriate if facts are disputed about investigation or prompt, reasonable handling (¶ 14 n.6).

Investigation (¶¶ 18–20). The adjuster responded within the fourteen-day deadline, requested missing information, and swore he reviewed every document. Newman did not dispute that he did, did not challenge the overruling of her objection to his declaration, and identified nothing concrete he should have done (¶ 19).

Evaluation (¶¶ 21–27). The offer was effectively $36,500, not $1,500, because Newman could not recover twice (¶ 21 n.9). With past medical expenses paid, the dispute concerned only general damages (¶ 21). Utah law tolerates wide variation in general damages (¶¶ 22–23, citing Pinney v. Carrera, 2020 UT 43, ¶ 31, 469 P.3d 970). Tort damages principles apply because the policy covers what the insured is “legally entitled to recover” from the tortfeasor (¶ 24, citing Utah Code § 31A-22-305.3(2)(a)). Newman called the $61,255.44 award “fair,” and LM’s implied $19,733.26 for general damages was closer to the arbitrator’s $41,000 than her $83,233.26 (¶ 26 & n.12).

Prompt and reasonable handling (¶¶ 28–30). LM offered, invited negotiation, followed up, tendered $1,500 on request, and paid the award shortly after arbitration. Beck is distinguishable because there the insurer rejected the offer “without explanation” and then went silent (¶ 29). The court disagreed that LM’s offer was a “nuisance offer” or “de facto denial” (¶ 29 n.13).

Part 2: Attorney fees as consequential damages (the appellant’s argument, ¶ 11): not reached

Newman argued that the attorney fees she incurred on the UIM claim and in the bad faith suit were recoverable as consequential damages, defeating the district court’s no-damages ground. The court did not address it: “We need not address either of Newman’s arguments” because summary judgment could be affirmed on the fairly debatable ground (¶ 11).

Not reached

Whether Newman’s attorney fees from the UIM claim and this suit were recoverable consequential damages, and whether a jury should decide emotional distress damages. The fairly debatable ruling made both unnecessary (¶ 11).

Takeaways

  • A genuine dispute over the value of general damages can make a first-party claim fairly debatable as a matter of law (¶¶ 14, 25–27).
  • Measure an insurer’s offer against the insured’s total recovery, including prior payments (¶ 21 n.9).
  • In valuing a UIM claim under a “legally entitled to recover” policy, tort general-damages cases are “directly on point” (¶ 24).
  • An unrebutted adjuster declaration on investigation can carry summary judgment where the insured points to nothing the adjuster should have done (¶ 19).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Newman v. LM General Insurance Co.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 94
Case no.
20241295-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
June 19, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Newman
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
An insured's bad faith claim against her underinsured motorist insurer over its handling of her claim, including a $1,500 settlement offer on a $100,000 policy, seeking attorney fees and emotional distress damages.

The panel

David N. MortensenAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
Ryan M. HarrisConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, West Jordan Department · Judge Matthew D. Bates

Parties & counsel

Newman — AppellantIndividual(s)Caleb BertchDaniel F. Bertch
LM General Insurance Co. — AppelleeBusinessByron G. MartinSteven M. Edmonds

Practice Tip

When opposing summary judgment on a fairly debatable defense, specifically dispute the insurer's evidence of investigation and identify what the adjuster should have done; here the adjuster's sworn statement stood unrebutted (¶ 19).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.