Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a lawyer’s lien on estate property be a “wrongful lien”? Estate of Carey v. Spencer

2026 UT App 142No. 20250147-CADecided Sep 11, 2026Real Property & Land UseReversed

Holding

Because an attorney’s lien is authorized by statute, it is wrongful under the Wrongful Lien Act only if the claimant lacked a good-faith basis for claiming it, and a firm that alleged it represented the personal representative, who held title to estate property in that role, pleaded such a basis, so judgment on the pleadings was error.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals mostly sided with the lawyer and his firm, undoing the judgment that their lien on the Estate’s property was a wrongful lien.

  • Under Utah’s Wrongful Lien Act, a lien authorized by statute, such as an attorney’s lien, is not wrongful just because it may later prove unenforceable; the question is whether the lien claimant had a good-faith basis for claiming it.
  • An earlier probate ruling denying a motion, shown only in hearing minutes with no written order, did not block the later lawsuit, because it was not shown to be a final judgment on the merits.
  • Arguments not raised in the trial court, including a challenge to who was named as plaintiff, were not considered on appeal.

What happened?

Doreen Jo Carey died in August 2021 without a will. James M. Gibbons, who had lived with her, hired attorney Terry R. Spencer of TR Spencer & Associates, Inc. (together, “TR Spencer”) to have him appointed personal representative of her estate. A personal representative is the person a court puts in charge of a dead person’s property.

After a settlement with Doreen’s mother and brother, the probate court appointed Gibbons. In June 2022, TR Spencer recorded an attorney’s lien, a legal claim against property to secure payment of a lawyer’s fees, on real property held by the Estate. It started at $20,168 and was later raised to $98,742.

Gibbons was removed for cause in September 2022, and Doreen’s brother Dale became the new personal representative. Dale asked the probate court to declare the lien wrongful. At a December 2022 hearing, the probate judge denied that request.

How did the case get to the Court of Appeals?

In 2023 the Estate sued TR Spencer in district court. The district court granted judgment on the pleadings, meaning it ruled based only on the written claims and answers. It held the lien was wrongful because the Estate was never TR Spencer’s client, and it awarded $10,000 in statutory damages and $16,650.30 in attorney fees. TR Spencer appealed.

What did TR Spencer argue?

TR Spencer argued the Estate could not sue because an estate is not a legal entity. It also argued that the probate judge’s earlier ruling settled the question, and that the lien was authorized by statute.

Could the Estate bring the suit?

The court held the Estate had standing, meaning it was personally harmed by a lien on its property. TR Spencer’s real complaint was about capacity, meaning whether the Estate had legal authority to sue in its own name rather than through Dale. TR Spencer never raised that in the district court, so the court did not decide it.

Did the probate judge’s earlier ruling end the matter?

No. Issue preclusion stops parties from relitigating an issue already decided, but only after a final judgment on the merits. The court had only minutes saying the request was “denied,” with no transcript and no written order, so it could not tell whether that was a final decision on the merits. Two other arguments, about the probate court’s exclusive authority and comity (respect between courts), were not raised below and were not considered.

Was the lien wrongful?

The court held the district court got this wrong. Attorney’s liens are authorized by statute, and such a lien is not wrongful unless the lawyer had no good-faith basis for claiming it. TR Spencer said its client was Gibbons acting as personal representative, and a personal representative has the same power over estate property as an owner. Taking TR Spencer’s statements as true at this stage, it had pleaded a good-faith basis. The court reversed that ruling and vacated the part of the judgment on the wrongful lien claim.

What happens now?

The court did not decide how much the Estate owes TR Spencer, if anything. TR Spencer’s request for fees is pending in the probate case.

What should people take from this?

A wrongful lien claim is not the place to decide whether a statutory lien is enforceable. And an argument about who should have been named as a party needs to be made in the trial court.

Bottom line

Order reversed and the wrongful lien portion of the Judgment vacated (Luthy, J., joined by Orme and Christiansen Forster, JJ.) (¶¶ 55, 57). Statutory liens are not wrongful under the Wrongful Lien Act unless the claimant lacked “a good-faith basis for claiming a statutory lien,” and TR Spencer pleaded one (¶¶ 3, 49, 55).

Issue 1: Standing, mootness and capacity to sue (correctness, ¶ 23): not reached

TR Spencer’s standing and mootness arguments raised only the Estate’s capacity to sue, which was unpreserved, so the court did not reach it (¶¶ 31, 36–37). Taking up the question reserved in Estate of Faucheaux v. City of Provo, 2019 UT 41, 449 P.3d 112, the court held an estate is personally aggrieved by a lien on its property and so has standing; any aside to the contrary was inadequately briefed (¶¶ 30, 34–35). Relying on Elite Legacy Corp. v. Schvaneveldt, 2016 UT App 228, ¶ 51, 391 P.3d 222, it explained standing is not capacity. A lack of capacity makes a case voidable, not void, the remedy is substitution under rule 17(a), and the defect is not jurisdictional, so it had to be raised below (¶ 37).

Issue 2: Issue preclusion (correctness, ¶ 24): affirmed (no error)

The probate judge’s denial of Dale’s motion was not shown to be a final judgment on the merits, so issue preclusion did not apply (¶¶ 40–41). The record had only minutes saying the petition “is denied,” with no transcript or written order (¶ 40). TR Spencer’s argument that probate orders resolving an issue are final conflicts with In re Estate of Heater, 2021 UT 66, 498 P.3d 883, which disavowed the pragmatic finality test (¶ 41).

Issue 3: Probate court’s exclusive authority (correctness, ¶ 24): not reached

The argument under Utah Code section 75-1-303(1) was unpreserved because TR Spencer argued only issue preclusion below (¶¶ 42–43).

Issue 4: Comity (correctness, ¶ 24): not reached

The comity argument was a distinct legal theory never presented to the district court, so it was unpreserved (¶ 43, citing Ahhmigo, LLC v. Synergy Co. of Utah, 2022 UT 4, ¶ 18, 506 P.3d 536).

Issue 5: Wrongful lien (correctness, ¶ 24): reversed

The district court erred in granting judgment on the pleadings because TR Spencer pleaded a good-faith basis for its statutory attorney’s lien (¶ 55). Under Hutter v. Dig-It, Inc., 2009 UT 69, 219 P.3d 918, and Bay Harbor Farm, LC v. Sumsion, 2014 UT App 133, 329 P.3d 46, a statutory lien is not wrongful even if unenforceable, unless the claimant has “no plausible claim” to the property (¶¶ 46–49). TR Spencer alleged its client was Gibbons as personal representative, who had “the same power over the title to property of the estate that an absolute owner would have” under section 75-3-710(1) (¶¶ 51–52). It denied knowingly including fees for the other cases and gave a statutory basis for pre-appointment fees (¶ 53). Taking those allegations as true, it pleaded a good-faith basis (¶ 54). The district court’s ruling did not hold the Estate owed no fees; that question is pending in the Probate Case (¶ 55 n.7).

Not reached

  • Issue 6: Whether the lien was authorized by Gibbons as title holder; unnecessary given the statutory-authorization ruling (¶ 45 n.6).
  • Issue 7: Whether Spencer individually belonged in the judgment; unnecessary because the relevant portion of the judgment was vacated (¶ 1 n.2).

Takeaways

  • In a Wrongful Lien Act case over a statutory lien, the question is a good-faith basis for the lien, not whether it is enforceable (¶¶ 47–49).
  • Hearing minutes without a transcript or written order may not show a final judgment on the merits for issue preclusion (¶ 40).
  • A defect in naming an estate as plaintiff goes to capacity, not standing, and is waived if not raised below (¶¶ 36–37).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Estate of Carey v. Spencer
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 142
Case no.
20250147-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
September 11, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Spencer
Disposition
Reversed
At stake
A judgment of $10,000 in statutory damages and $16,650.30 in attorney fees under the Wrongful Lien Act over an attorney's lien recorded on estate property.

The panel

John D. LuthyAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Robert P. Faust

Parties & counsel

Spencer — AppellantOtherCameron L. SabinJoshua B. Cutler
Estate of Carey — AppelleeOtherBrent W. Hastings

Practice Tip

When defending a wrongful lien claim over a statutory lien, plead the facts showing a good-faith basis for each element of the lien statute; on judgment on the pleadings those allegations are taken as true (¶¶ 49, 54–55).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.