Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Can I recover my lawyer’s contingency fee as damages after trial? Western Mortgage v. Walker

2026 UT 30No. 20250396Decided Aug 20, 2026Contracts & Business DisputesReversed

Holding

Attorney fees sought as consequential damages under the fiduciary-duty exception to the American Rule must be disclosed under rule 26 and their causation, foreseeability and amount proved at trial; a contingency fee first disclosed in a post-trial rule 73 motion is not recoverable, and the nondisclosure there was neither for good cause nor harmless.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with Western Mortgage and threw out the contingency-fee part of the Walkers’ damages award.

  • When attorney fees are claimed as damages for a breach of fiduciary duty, they follow the same rules as other consequential damages, including disclosure before trial.
  • A contingency fee counted in those damages must be disclosed and shown to have been foreseeable, normally at trial, unless the parties agree otherwise.
  • The Walkers keep their hourly fees and expenses, but the district court must recalculate them without the contingency add-on.

What happened?

Keith and Lorin Walker planned to develop land near Sand Hollow Reservoir in Washington County. After the 2008 mortgage crisis, they made an agreement with Western Mortgage & Realty Company and its owner, Frank Tiegs. Western was to clear title and put the land into an entity both sides would control. Western never formed it.

Western sued to quiet title, meaning to have the court declare it the sole owner. The Walkers counterclaimed. After a bench trial (a trial before a judge, with no jury), the district court ruled for the Walkers on breach of contract and breach of fiduciary duty, a duty of loyalty and care one party owed the other. It also awarded them attorney fees as consequential damages, which are losses that flow indirectly from the wrong.

What was the surprise?

Before trial, the Walkers had said only that they would seek “amounts paid” to their lawyers and experts. In their post-trial fee motion under rule 73, they revealed that their lawyers worked partly on a contingency fee, a share of what the Walkers recovered. The district court accepted it. It added a 15% markup to the fees, raised the money judgment from about $1.4 to $1.7 million, and raised the Walkers’ share of a constructive trust (property held for their benefit) from 41% to 48.235%.

Did Western give up its right to appeal?

No. The parties had signed a stipulation not to appeal earlier rulings. The court held it did not cover later rulings “related to” attorney fees, so Western could challenge them.

What did the court decide?

It reversed. Fees sought as damages are still damages. A party claiming them must disclose how it calculates them under rule 26, the rule on sharing information before trial, and prove at trial that the damages were caused by the wrong, were foreseeable, and how much they are. For a contingency fee, the specific fee arrangement itself must have been foreseeable when the fiduciary duty arose.

The Walkers proved causation at trial but did not disclose the contingency fee or prove its foreseeability or amount there. Rule 73 did not excuse that. The court also held rule 26’s exception for a “practice area” does not cover attorney fees.

Was the failure to disclose excused?

No. Rule 26 bars undisclosed material unless the failure was for good cause or harmless. The court found neither. Western could not challenge foreseeability in discovery or at trial, and by the time the fee came out, trial was over and judgment was entered.

What happens now?

The district court must change the Walkers’ damages award. Their hourly fees and expenses stand because Western did not challenge them, but they must be recalculated without the contingency add-on. The Walkers’ request for their fees on appeal was denied.

What should people take from this?

A party planning to claim lawyer fees as damages, especially a contingency fee, should not wait until after trial to reveal it. The court invited its rules committee to suggest how to fit this into the rules.

Bottom line

Reversed, with instructions to modify the damages award (Nielsen, J., joined by Petersen, J., Pohlman, A.C.J., Jorgensen, J., and Dent, J.; Durrant, C.J., recused and Hagen, J., stepped down). Attorney fees sought under the fiduciary-duty exception to the American Rule are consequential damages and must meet the usual requirements: pleading, rule 26 disclosure, causation, foreseeability and amount (¶ 38). The Walkers’ undisclosed contingency fee was not awardable (¶¶ 44–45, 53). As a threshold matter, the parties’ stipulation waiving appeal of pre-stipulation rulings did not bar Western’s arguments, because it carved out future rulings “related to” attorney fees (¶¶ 22–24). Review was for correctness because the ruling turned on the interplay of rules 26 and 73 (¶ 18).

Issue 1: Fees as damages must be disclosed and proved at trial (correctness, ¶ 18): reversed

Fees sought as consequential damages must be disclosed under rule 26 and proved at trial, not first claimed in a rule 73 motion. Consequential damages require disclosure of the fact, amount and basis of damages (¶ 28, following Keystone Ins. Agency v. Inside Ins., 2019 UT 20, ¶ 17, 445 P.3d 434) and proof of causation, foreseeability and amount as part of the case-in-chief (¶¶ 30–31, citing Mahmood v. Ross, 1999 UT 104, ¶ 20, 990 P.2d 933). For a contingency fee, the specific arrangement must also have been foreseeable when the duty arose (¶ 37, following USA Power, LLC v. PacifiCorp, 2016 UT 20, ¶ 94, 372 P.3d 629). Rule 26(a)’s “practice area” exception means areas like divorce or probate, not attorney fees (¶¶ 47–48), and rule 73 covers fees awarded under a statute or contract, not fees sought as damages (¶ 50 n.22). The preservation objection failed because Western only added authority on appeal (¶ 30 n.10).

Issue 2: Contingency fee not recoverable (correctness, ¶ 18): reversed

The Walkers could not recover the contingency fee because they did not disclose it or prove its foreseeability or amount at trial, though they proved causation (¶ 40). Their disclosures sought only “amounts paid” to counsel and experts (¶ 41), and their trial expert testified to a 59-41 split (¶ 42). Parties may agree to try foreseeability post-trial, but Western never did (¶ 44 n.19). Fee totals may still be finalized post-trial, but a computation including a contingency fee cannot first be disclosed then (¶ 40 n.18).

Issue 3: No good cause or harmlessness (correctness, ¶ 18): reversed

The failure to disclose was neither for good cause nor harmless under rule 26(d)(4). Rule 73 did not excuse disclosure of the “computation of any damages claimed” (¶ 50), and an unopposed ruling to proceed under rule 73 rested on withheld information (¶ 51). Western’s failure to seek more discovery did not shift the burden (¶ 52, following Keystone Ins. Agency v. Inside Ins., 2019 UT 20, ¶ 20, 445 P.3d 434), and by then trial was over and judgment entered (¶ 53).

Not reached

Issue 4: whether the attorney’s declaration was improper, undisclosed expert testimony, unnecessary given the reversal (¶ 38 n.17).

Issue 5: Attorney fees on appeal (none stated, ¶ 54 n.23): the Walkers’ request for attorney fees on appeal denied

Because the contingency award was reversed, the court awarded the Walkers no fees on appeal (¶ 54 n.23).

Disposition

The hourly fees and expenses stand because Western did not challenge them, but must be recalculated without the contingency “kicker” (¶ 54 n.23). The court left open how far the fiduciary-duty fee exception extends (¶ 36 n.13).

Takeaways

  • Disclose a contingency fee in the rule 26 damages computation if it will be part of fee damages (¶¶ 40 n.18, 43).
  • Foreseeability of fee damages is normally tried in the case-in-chief unless the parties agree otherwise (¶¶ 31 n.11, 44 n.19).
  • Rule 73 governs statutory and contractual fees, not fees sought as damages (¶ 50 n.22).
  • An appellate-waiver stipulation that carves out fee rulings preserves challenges to later fee rulings (¶ 24).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Western Mortgage v. Walker
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2026 UT 30
Case no.
20250396
Filed
2025
Decided
August 20, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Western Mortgage
Disposition
Reversed
At stake
A contingency-fee add-on awarded as consequential damages, which raised the Walkers' money judgment from about $1.4 to $1.7 million and their constructive-trust interest from 41% to 48.235%, and added a 15% markup to the fee award.

The panel

NielsenAuthor
DentConcurred
Jay T. JorgensenConcurred
Paige PetersenConcurred
Jill M. PohlmanConcurred
CHIEF JUSTICE DURRANTDid not participate
JUSTICE HAGENDid not participate
Trial court
Fifth District Court, Washington County · Judge Andrew H. Stone

Parties & counsel

Western Mortgage — AppellantOtherTroy L. BooherLaShel ShawZaven A. SargsianJack L. Darrington
Walker — AppelleeIndividual(s)Erik A. OlsonJason R. HullM. Eric Olmstead

Practice Tip

If a client's fee damages will include a contingency fee, put it in the rule 26 damages computation and be ready to prove the specific arrangement was foreseeable at trial, unless the other side knowingly agrees to try it later (¶¶ 31 n.11, 38, 43–44).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.