Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Does my employer get a cut of my debt collection settlement? Granite School v. Labor Commission

2026 UT 29No. 20240646Decided Aug 13, 2026Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

Substantial evidence supported each challenged element of the permanent total disability award, the ALJ acted within its discretion in instructing the medical panel and declining to reopen the record, and the employer was not entitled to a Utah Code § 34A-2-106 offset absent evidence that the FDCPA settlement overlapped the compensable work injuries.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with the injured teacher, Robyn Young, and left her permanent total disability award in place.

  • The award of permanent total disability benefits to the teacher stands.
  • The judge handling the claim had discretion to refuse to reopen the evidence after the hearing.
  • The school district was not entitled to a share of the teacher’s debt collection settlement, because on this record that money paid for the collectors’ conduct, not her work injuries.

What happened?

Robyn Young was a special education teacher for Granite School District. In 2013 a student head-butted her in the face, and in 2014 another student punched her and pulled out chunks of her hair. She developed migraines, depression and other problems.

Her doctor cleared her for light duty, but Granite would not accommodate her restrictions and fired her. In a first workers’ compensation claim, she was awarded temporary benefits and Granite was ordered to pay her related medical bills. Granite disputed some bills and did not pay them, and the bills went to collection agencies. Young sued the collectors in federal court under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act and settled for $610,000, of which she received $295,000.

What was the second claim about?

Young later asked for permanent total disability benefits, which are paid when a work injury leaves someone unable to work in the long term. An administrative law judge (ALJ), the Labor Commission’s hearing judge, sent the medical questions to a medical panel, a group of independent doctors. The panel found that all her permanent restrictions came from the work accidents, and that other stress, such as her divorce and money worries, was only temporary. The ALJ awarded benefits, and the Labor Commission agreed.

What did Granite argue?

Granite said the panel was not told clearly enough to separate work causes from other causes. It said the ALJ should have reopened the evidence to admit depositions from the federal case and evidence of a 2021 car accident. It challenged five of the six things a worker must prove for permanent total disability. And it claimed subrogation, a right to be repaid from money the worker recovers from someone else, out of the settlement.

What did the court decide?

The court rejected every argument. The panel was asked exactly the question Granite said was missing, and it answered it. Reopening the evidence was up to the ALJ, and Granite made its requests two months and two years after the hearing. The car accident happened after the hearing and the disability finding, so it could not make her condition more permanent or more total.

On the disability elements, the court asked whether there was “substantial evidence,” meaning enough evidence that a reasonable person could accept it. There was. No exact impairment rating was required. Whether she is employed is judged at the time of the hearing, and earning $100 to $150 a month selling online was not gainful employment. Her doctor’s report and her own testimony supported the other findings.

On subrogation, Granite never proved that the settlement overlapped with its benefits. The Commission found her benefits rested entirely on the work injuries, while the settlement paid for the collectors’ wrongful conduct.

What happens now?

Nothing goes back to the Commission. Its order, including the permanent total disability award, stands.

What should people take from this?

When a medical panel is asked to separate work causes from other causes and does so, a challenge to its instructions faces a steep climb. Employers seeking a share of a worker’s outside settlement need evidence that the settlement paid for the same injuries.

Bottom line

Commission order affirmed (Nielsen, J., joined by Petersen, J., Pohlman, A.C.J., Christiansen Forster, J., and Hansen, J., sitting by designation). Granite School District petitioned for review; the court of appeals certified the case (¶ 35). Every challenge fails (¶ 83).

Issue 1: Medical panel instructions (abuse of discretion, ¶ 36): affirmed (no error)

The ALJ’s instructions were adequate. The panel was asked to parse the effects of each accident and of non-industrial stressors, and it found the stressors temporary and noncontributory (¶¶ 41–42). Granite cited no authority requiring more granular instructions (¶ 43).

Issue 2: Reopening the record (abuse of discretion, ¶¶ 37, 46): affirmed (no error)

Refusing to reopen the record was within the ALJ’s discretion. Utah Admin. Code R602-2-1(I)(8) requires “leave of the administrative law judge,” and Utah Code § 34A-2-802(1) gives the Commission broad investigative latitude (¶¶ 45–46), consistent with Ernest Health, Inc. v. Lab. Comm’n, 2016 UT App 48, ¶¶ 3–9, 369 P.3d 462. Granite’s requests came two months and two years after the hearing, the panel found the debt collection did not meaningfully contribute, and the car accident postdated the disability finding (¶¶ 47–49).

Issue 3: Permanent total disability award – significant impairment and no gainful employment (mixed, ¶ 55 n.5): affirmed (no error)

The court upheld the Commission’s permanent total disability award on both challenged elements: no impairment rating is required and substantial evidence supported the significant-impairment finding, and the not-gainfully-employed element is measured at the time of the hearing with substantial evidence supporting the finding.

Part 1: Significant impairment (¶¶ 55–58, n.5, n.6). No impairment rating is required, and substantial evidence supported the finding. The court agreed with Rouse v. Lab. Comm’n, 2024 UT App 77, ¶ 35, 551 P.3d 1014 (¶ 56). The second treating physician’s report, credited by the panel, showed limitations exceeding the “minimum threshold” of Provo City v. Utah Lab. Comm’n, 2015 UT 32, ¶ 16, 345 P.3d 1242 (¶¶ 57–58); the court did not define that threshold (n.6).

Part 2: Not gainfully employed (¶¶ 59–63, n.7). The element is measured at the time of the hearing, and substantial evidence supported the finding. The present tense “is” controls, adopting Prows v. Lab. Comm’n, 2014 UT App 196, ¶ 12, 333 P.3d 1261 (¶¶ 60–62). Earning $100 to $150 a month from online sales was not gainful employment (¶ 63). The court clarified that the facts on this element are reviewed for substantial evidence (n.7).

Issue 4: Basic work activities and essential functions of prior work (substantial evidence, ¶ 38): affirmed (no error)

The court held that substantial evidence supported the Commission’s findings on these two elements of the permanent total disability award, so the award stands (¶¶ 64–71).

Part 1: Limited ability to do basic work activities (¶¶ 64–66)

Substantial evidence supported the finding. Applying Oliver v. Utah Lab. Comm’n, 2017 UT 39, ¶¶ 23–24, 424 P.3d 22, the physician’s report sufficed even if Granite’s psychologist contradicted it in some respects (¶¶ 65–66).

Part 2: Inability to perform the essential functions of former work (¶¶ 67–71)

Substantial evidence showed Young could no longer keep a full-time schedule. The burden of production is “not high” (Oliver, 2017 UT 39, ¶ 56), and the Commission weighed her degree, volunteering, workouts and sales work (¶¶ 68–71).

Issue 5: Direct cause (substantial evidence, ¶ 73 n.8): affirmed (no error)

Substantial evidence supported causation. Granite challenged only the evidence, not the legal standard (¶ 73, n.8). The panel found no prior headaches and only temporary effects from later stressors (¶¶ 75–77).

Issue 6: Subrogation offset (mixed, ¶ 39): affirmed (no error)

Granite was not entitled to an offset under Utah Code § 34A-2-106. It never tried to prove overlap after Granite Sch. Dist. v. Young, 2023 UT 21, 537 P.3d 225 (¶ 80), and the Commission found the benefits rested entirely on the work injuries while the settlement compensated the collectors’ tortious conduct (¶¶ 81–82).

Takeaways

  • Significant impairment does not require an impairment rating (¶ 56).
  • Gainful employment is measured at the time of the hearing (¶ 62).
  • Reopening a closed record is discretionary under R602-2-1(I)(8); late requests and post-disability events weigh against it (¶¶ 45–48).
  • A section 34A-2-106 offset fails without evidence that the third-party recovery overlaps the compensable injury (¶¶ 80–82).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Granite School v. Labor Commission
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2026 UT 29
Case no.
20240646
Filed
2024
Decided
August 13, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Labor Commission
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A teacher's award of permanent total disability benefits and medical expenses for two workplace head injuries, and the school district's claimed subrogation offset against her federal debt-collection settlement.

The panel

NielsenAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
Matthew J. HansenConcurred
Paige PetersenConcurred
Jill M. PohlmanConcurred
JUSTICE PEARCEDid not participate
CHIEF JUSTICE DURRANTDid not participate
JUSTICE HAGENDid not participate
JUSTICE JORGENSENDid not participate
JUSTICE DENTDid not participate
Trial court
Labor Commission

Parties & counsel

Labor Commission — AppellantGovernment agencyBret A. GardnerKristy L. Bertelsen
Granite School — AppelleeOtherGary E. AtkinChristopher Hill

Practice Tip

An employer seeking a section 34A-2-106 offset against a worker's third-party recovery should build a record showing the recovery compensated the same injuries; without it, the claim fails (¶¶ 80–82).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.