Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a jury find a company negligent but zero percent at fault? Coombs v. Natural Choice

2026 UT App 145Nos. 20240072-CA, 20240682-CADecided Sep 24, 2026Personal Injury & TortsRemanded

Holding

A special verdict finding a defendant negligent and a substantial factor in causing damages but allocating it zero percent of the fault is irreconcilably inconsistent, an alter ego finding cannot harmonize it, and a new trial is required; separately, allegations that defendants “their agents or employs” started the fire gave fair notice of a vicarious liability claim.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals agreed with NWR that the jury’s verdict was inconsistent and ordered a new trial, but it rejected Natural Choice’s pleading argument.

  • A jury cannot find a party negligent and a substantial cause of the damage and then give that party zero percent of the fault.
  • The verdict was vacated and the case goes back for a new trial.
  • The landowners’ complaint gave Natural Choice enough notice that they sought to hold it responsible for the people acting for it, so that theory can go forward on remand.

What happened?

NWR owns land in a canyon in Box Elder County. Natural Choice leased that land from NWR. In August 2016, Natural Choice sent Samuel to clear thistle on the property with a backhoe. A fire started where the weeds had just been knocked down. By the time firefighters put it out, it had burned over 20,000 acres, including parts of neighboring properties.

The neighboring owners (the court calls them “Landowners”) sued NWR and Natural Choice for negligence, meaning a failure to use reasonable care. They also claimed Natural Choice was NWR’s “alter ego,” meaning the two companies were so tied together that each should answer for the other.

What did the jury decide?

The jury answered a special verdict form, a list of specific questions. It found that both companies were negligent and that each one’s negligence was a substantial factor in causing the damage. It also found that Natural Choice was NWR’s alter ego. But when asked to divide the fault, it put 100% on NWR and 0% on Natural Choice. In a later phase, it ordered each company to pay $1,185,000 in punitive damages, which are meant to punish.

NWR told the trial court the answers contradicted each other and asked for a new trial. The trial court said no, reasoning that the alter ego finding explained why the jury put all the fault on NWR.

Did the verdict stand?

No. Under Utah law, “fault” includes negligence that causes or contributes to someone’s harm. So once the jury found Natural Choice negligent and a cause of the damage, it could not also find Natural Choice had zero fault.

The alter ego finding did not fix the problem. That theory only lets a plaintiff reach a second company for liability the first one already has. If Natural Choice had no fault, there was nothing to pass on to NWR. And because the Landowners also sued NWR directly, the court had no way to tell how much of NWR’s 100% came from its own conduct and how much came from Natural Choice. The court vacated (threw out) the verdict and ordered a new trial.

What about Natural Choice’s argument?

Natural Choice argued the Landowners never pleaded vicarious liability, meaning a claim that Natural Choice was responsible for what its employee Samuel did. The court disagreed. Utah only requires a complaint to give fair notice of the claim. The complaint said the companies, “their agents or employs,” started the fire with a backhoe, and a company can only run a backhoe through a person. Natural Choice had also listed Samuel in its own disclosures as working for it that day, and later named him to testify for the company. So it was not surprised or harmed.

The court decided this point to guide the new trial, and its ruling stays in force on remand.

What happens now?

The case goes back to the First District Court for a new trial. The court did not decide the other issues the two companies raised, because the new trial made that unnecessary.

What should people take from this?

When a jury’s answers seem to conflict while the jury is still there, the trial court can ask the jury what it meant. Once the jury is gone, the court must try to read the answers together, and if it cannot, a new trial follows.

Bottom line

Verdict vacated and remanded for a new trial (Christiansen Forster, J., joined by Tenney and Oliver, JJ.). In consolidated appeals by NWR and Natural Choice, the court held that the jury’s findings that Natural Choice was negligent and its negligence a substantial factor in causing damages could not be reconciled with its allocation of 0% fault to Natural Choice (¶¶ 29, 33). It also held, as guidance on remand, that Landowners adequately pleaded vicarious liability against Natural Choice (¶¶ 34–39).

Issue 1: Inconsistent special verdict (correctness, ¶ 22): reversed

The verdict was irreconcilably inconsistent, so a new trial is required (¶ 33). While the jury is still empaneled, the trial court has discretion to ask the jury what it meant, citing KTM Health Care Inc. v. SG Nursing Home LLC, 2018 UT App 152, ¶ 36, 436 P.3d 151 (¶ 24). If it does not, the court must try to harmonize the answers, resolving any inconsistency “in favor of giving effect to a jury verdict,” Neff v. Neff, 2011 UT 6, ¶ 49, 247 P.3d 380, or order a new trial (¶ 25). Under Utah Code § 78B-5-817(2), “fault” includes negligence proximately causing or contributing to injury, and the instructions tracked that definition, so negligence plus causation with zero fault is inconsistent (¶¶ 27–29).

The alter ego finding does not reconcile the answers. An alter ego is liable “only to the same extent” as the underlying entity, Prows v. State, 822 P.2d 764, 767 (Utah 1991), so if Natural Choice bore no fault there was nothing to pass to NWR (¶ 32). Because Landowners also sued NWR directly, the court could not tell what share of NWR’s 100% rested on direct liability versus alter ego (¶ 33).

Issue 2: Pleading of vicarious liability (correctness, ¶ 23): remand guidance

The trial court correctly ruled that Landowners adequately pleaded Natural Choice’s vicarious liability for Samuel’s conduct and allowed related instructions (¶ 39). Under notice pleading and Utah R. Civ. P. 8(a) and 8(f), a pleading need only give “fair notice of the nature and basis of the claim,” Southern Utah Wilderness All. v. San Juan County Comm’n, 2021 UT 6, ¶ 40, 484 P.3d 1160 (¶ 36). The complaint alleged the defendants, “their agents or employs,” ignited the fire with a backhoe, and the failure to name Samuel did not make the claim unclear (¶ 37). Natural Choice’s own disclosures and rule 30(b)(6) designation of Samuel showed actual notice and no prejudice, citing Consolidated Realty Group v. Sizzling Platter, Inc., 930 P.2d 268, 275–76 (Utah Ct. App. 1996) (¶ 38). The court addressed the issue for guidance under State v. Low, 2008 UT 58, ¶ 61, 192 P.3d 867, and the ruling remains in force on remand (¶¶ 34, 40).

Disposition

Verdict vacated; remanded for a new trial (¶ 40). The court did not reach the parties’ other issues because the new trial made them unnecessary (¶ 2 n.1, ¶ 34).

Takeaways

  • A jury may not find a party negligent and causal yet assign it 0% fault; Utah’s statutory definition of fault ties the two together (¶¶ 27–29).
  • An alter ego finding passes liability through but does not erase the underlying entity’s fault (¶ 32).
  • When direct and alter ego theories run against the same defendant, a single fault percentage may be impossible to parse (¶ 33).
  • Pleading conduct by defendants’ “agents or employs” can give fair notice of vicarious liability without naming the employee, particularly where the defendant’s litigation conduct shows actual notice (¶¶ 37–38).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Coombs v. Natural Choice
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 145
Case no.
20240072-CA, 20240682-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
September 24, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Natural Choice
Disposition
Remanded
At stake
A jury verdict for landowners whose properties were damaged by a wildfire, assigning all fault to NWR and awarding $1,185,000 in punitive damages against each of NWR and Natural Choice

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterAuthor
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
First District Court, Brigham City Department · Judge Brandon J. Maynard

Parties & counsel

Natural Choice — AppellantBusinessEmily AdamsFreyja JohnsonRachel Phillips AinscoughHannah Leavitt-HowellMikayla IrvinLaura J. FullerTroy L. BooherTaylor P. WebbOlivia C. ShaughnessyDavid E. KingstonTodd WeilerKristen Kiburtz
Coombs — AppelleeOtherJonathan R. Grover

Practice Tip

If a special verdict appears inconsistent while the jury is still empaneled, ask the court to return the jury for clarification, since once the jury is discharged the court can only harmonize the answers or order a new trial (¶¶ 24–25).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.