Utah Court of Appeals · Memorandum Decision

What if my appointed lawyer files a deficient appeal brief? State v. Smith

2010 UT App 231No. 20090775-CADecided Aug 19, 2010Criminal AppealsPetition Granted

Holding

An appointed counsel’s brief that wholly fails to comply with Utah R. App. P. 24(a) is struck, and given counsel’s prior failure to obey an order to file a compliant brief, counsel is discharged, an order that falls within rule 38B(e) and bars his appointment in either appellate court for three years.

Practice areaCriminal Appeals

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals granted the State’s motion, struck the defendant’s brief, and removed his court-appointed appeal lawyer so a new one could be appointed.

  • The court struck the appeal brief because it did not meet the briefing requirements of rule 24(a).
  • The court usually lets a lawyer fix a deficient brief, but here it removed the lawyer because of his failure to obey a similar order in an earlier case.
  • Under rule 38B, that removal means the lawyer may not be appointed in either Utah appellate court for three years.

What happened?

Gary Whitener Smith, the defendant, appealed from a case in the Fourth District court in Nephi. The court appointed a lawyer to handle his appeal. The State, the other side in the appeal, asked the Court of Appeals to strike (throw out) that lawyer’s brief, remove the lawyer, and have a qualified new lawyer appointed. No one filed anything opposing the State’s request.

What was wrong with the brief?

The appellate rules require a brief to contain certain parts. The court found the brief had no summary of what happened in the district court, only a very short statement of facts with no citations to the record, and a confusing statement about the standard of review (the level of deference the appeals court gives the lower court).

It also had no argument section at all. It had a “scant paragraph” asking the court to consider due process, a list of constitutional rights, and a one-sentence conclusion. The court said appellate courts are not “a depository” where a party may “dump the burden of argument and research,” quoting State v. Thomas, 961 P.2d 299, 304 (Utah 1998).

What did the court decide?

It granted the State’s motion and struck the brief. Normally, the court said, it lets a lawyer file a corrected brief. But in 2008 the court had struck a brief by the same lawyer in a juvenile delinquency appeal and ordered him to file a proper one. He never did, and his client’s appeal was dismissed.

Because of that history, the court did not give the lawyer another chance. It discharged him as Smith’s appointed lawyer.

What does that mean for the lawyer?

Rule 38B of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure sets out who can be appointed as appeal counsel. It bars appointing a lawyer who, in the prior three years, was discharged by an appellate court for substandard performance. The court said its order fits that rule, so this lawyer may not be appointed in either Utah appellate court for three years from the decision.

The court added in a footnote that not every order striking a brief counts as a sanction under rule 38B. In most cases, ordering a lawyer to fix a brief is not the same as sanctioning the lawyer.

What happens now?

The case goes back to the district court for a short time so it can appoint a new appeal lawyer who meets rule 38B’s qualifications. Smith’s appeal itself was not decided; it continues with new counsel.

What should people take from this?

The court treated a brief with no real argument as no help to the client. A lawyer’s record of ignoring a court’s order to fix a brief can lead the court to remove the lawyer rather than allow a second try.

Bottom line

Motion granted; temporarily remanded (per curiam; Davis, P.J., McHugh, A.P.J., and Orme, J.). The court struck appointed counsel’s opening brief as wholly noncompliant with rule 24(a), discharged counsel, and remanded for appointment of new counsel qualified under rule 38B (¶¶ 5, 7). The State’s motion was unopposed (¶ 1). The merits of the appeal were not addressed.

Issue 1: Motion to strike brief and discharge counsel (none stated, ¶¶ 2–7): the State’s motion to strike the brief and discharge appointed counsel granted

The brief “wholly fails to comply” with rule 24(a) and is struck, and counsel is discharged rather than given leave to refile (¶¶ 2, 5).

Brief defects (¶ 2): no summary of proceedings; a very brief fact statement without record citations (rule 24(a)(7)); a standard-of-review statement that did not satisfy rule 24(a)(5); and no argument section, only a cursory summary listing constitutional rights and a one-sentence conclusion (rules 24(a)(8), (9)). Rule 24(k) permits striking such briefs. The court relied on State v. Green, 2005 UT 9, ¶ 11, 108 P.3d 710, and State v. Sloan, 2003 UT App 170, ¶ 13, 72 P.3d 138, identifying the lack of “reasoned analysis based upon relevant legal authority” as the most glaring defect (¶ 3), and quoted State v. Thomas, 961 P.2d 299, 304 (Utah 1998) (¶ 2).

Remedy (¶¶ 4–5): the usual practice is to allow a compliant brief. But in a 2008 juvenile delinquency appeal the court struck the same lawyer’s brief and ordered a compliant one within twenty days; he filed nothing, the appeal was dismissed by default, and he did not use the ten days allowed for reinstatement. That failure warranted discharge here.

Rule 38B consequence (¶ 6): the discharge is an order “discharging counsel . . . because of counsel’s substandard performance” under rule 38B(e), so counsel may not be appointed before either appellate court for three years from the decision. Footnote 1 (¶ 6 n.1) clarifies that not every order striking a noncompliant brief is a sanction or discharge within rule 38B; ordinarily, requiring revision is not tantamount to a sanction.

Disposition

Brief struck; Milton T. Harmon discharged as appointed appellate counsel; temporary remand to the district court to appoint new counsel meeting rule 38B (¶ 7).

Takeaways

  • A brief with no argument section and no record citations may be struck on motion under rule 24(k) (¶ 2).
  • Counsel’s prior failure to obey an order to correct a deficient brief can justify discharge instead of leave to refile (¶ 5).
  • A discharge for substandard performance triggers rule 38B(e)’s three-year appointment bar, but an ordinary order to revise a brief generally does not (¶ 6 & n.1).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
State v. Smith
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2010 UT App 231
Case no.
20090775-CA
Filed
2009
Decided
August 19, 2010
Opinion type
Memorandum decision
Who appealed
Smith
Disposition
Petition Granted
At stake
Whether the defendant's appointed appellate counsel's noncompliant brief would be struck and counsel discharged and replaced

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Nephi Department · Judge Donald J. Eyre, Jr.

Parties & counsel

Smith — AppellantIndividual(s)Milton T. Harmon
State — AppelleeState of UtahMark L. ShurtleffLaura B. Dupaix

Practice Tip

When the court strikes a brief and orders a compliant one, file it; the court treated counsel's earlier failure to do so as grounds to discharge him outright in a later appeal, with rule 38B consequences (¶¶ 4–6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.