Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Is life without parole for repeat child sex abuse cruel and unusual? State v. Hillman

2026 UT App 147No. 20240123-CADecided Oct 1, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Hillman’s ineffective-assistance claims failed for lack of deficient performance or lack of prejudice, and, following State v. Garcia, 2022 UT App 77, 526 P.3d 1238, the mandatory life-without-parole sentence under Utah Code section 76-5-404.3(3)(c) is not cruel and unusual under Article I, Section 9 of the Utah Constitution as applied to him.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Hillman’s two convictions and his sentence of life without parole.

  • Hillman’s convictions and his mandatory life-without-parole sentences stand.
  • The court called the prosecutor’s closing remarks improper, but held that the lawyer’s failure to object did not change the result, given the strong evidence.
  • Following its earlier decision in Garcia, the court held the mandatory sentence was not cruel and unusual as applied to Hillman.

What happened?

In 2021, 11-year-old K.B. was staying with his father. The father’s friend, Hillman, came over to watch TV. K.B. testified that after his father fell asleep, Hillman touched K.B.’s penis and made K.B. touch his. Hillman told him, “We don’t talk about this.”

The next morning Hillman called the father to ask if K.B. was all right. K.B.’s mother noticed changes in him, found that Hillman had earlier been convicted of child sexual abuse, and K.B. later told her what happened.

Hillman was charged with two counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child. Because of his 1996 convictions, the charges carried a mandatory sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.

How did the trial work?

The trial was split into two parts. A jury decided whether Hillman committed the abuse. One of his earlier victims, R.R., testified, and the jury saw Hillman’s old plea statements, which a rule of evidence allows in child molestation cases.

The jury convicted him. The judge then decided, in a second part without a jury, that he had prior sexual offense convictions and that they were serious enough to require life without parole.

What did Hillman argue on appeal?

Mostly that his trial lawyer was “ineffective,” meaning the lawyer’s work fell below a reasonable standard and that this likely changed the outcome. He pointed to the lawyer’s failure to object to the prosecutor’s closing remarks, to two photos of K.B., to R.R. reading the plea statement aloud, to the unredacted plea statements, and to the judge, not the jury, deciding the prior-conviction question. He also argued that his sentence was cruel and unusual punishment under the Utah Constitution.

What did the court decide about his lawyer?

It rejected every claim. The court said the prosecutor should not have told jurors to think of the “wake of pain” Hillman caused or that their verdict would “protect” K.B. But given the strong evidence, including K.B.’s testimony, Hillman’s odd phone call, and his undisputed prior abuse of other children in similar circumstances, an objection would not likely have changed the verdict. The same was true for the photos.

The lawyer had no reason to expect R.R. to become emotional while reading the plea statement, and choosing not to redact the plea statements fit the defense strategy of acknowledging the prior convictions. Added together, the errors the court assumed still did not shake its confidence in the verdict.

On the prior-conviction question, the court agreed a jury must decide every element of a crime. But the only evidence was the plea statements and court judgments, which no one disputed, so a jury would not likely have decided it differently.

Was the sentence cruel and unusual?

No. The court relied on its earlier decision in State v. Garcia, 2022 UT App 77, ¶ 56, 526 P.3d 1238, cert. denied, 525 P.3d 1260 (Utah 2022), which upheld the same mandatory sentence. Hillman argued his conduct was less severe than Garcia’s, but the court said it does not rank the severity of different conduct that leads to the same charge.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The convictions and the life-without-parole sentences stand.

What should people take from this?

A claim against a trial lawyer usually fails unless the lawyer’s mistakes would likely have changed the result. The court also gave prosecutors a warning: finding no harm in this case does not promise the same result in another case with improper remarks.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Orme, J., joined by Harris and Tenney, JJ.). Hillman’s ineffective-assistance claims “fail for either lack of deficient performance or lack of prejudice” (¶ 25), and his mandatory LWOP sentence under Utah Code section 76-5-404.3(3)(c) is not cruel and unusual under Article I, Section 9 of the Utah Constitution as applied to him (¶¶ 37–41). All ineffective-assistance claims were raised first on appeal and decided as a matter of law (¶ 22).

Issue 1: Failure to object to closing remarks (ineffective assistance, ¶¶ 26–28): affirmed (harmless error)

Counsel’s failure to object to or seek a curative instruction for the prosecutor’s improper remarks did not prejudice Hillman. The court called the “wake of pain” and “you’ll protect him” remarks improper (¶ 26; n.6, quoting State v. Thompson, 2014 UT App 14, ¶ 67, 318 P.3d 1221), but applied the counterfactual analysis of State v. Mason, 2024 UT App 171, ¶ 32, 562 P.3d 1158 (¶ 27). K.B.’s testimony, Hillman’s unprompted call and belly-rubbing explanation, K.B.’s changed behavior, and Hillman’s undisputed prior abuse in “remarkably similar” circumstances left no reasonable likelihood of acquittal (¶ 28). Footnote 6 cautions that no prejudice here “is no guarantee” of the same result in another case.

Issue 2: Photos of K.B. (ineffective assistance, ¶¶ 29–30): affirmed (harmless error)

Assuming counsel should have objected under rules 402 and 403, there was no prejudice. Mother testified the photos fairly depicted K.B., K.B. testified in person, and the evidence of abuse and propensity was compelling (¶ 30).

Issue 3: R.R. reading the plea statement (ineffective assistance, ¶¶ 31–32): affirmed (no error)

Counsel did not perform deficiently by failing to object in advance. R.R. had not read the statement at the evidentiary hearing, and nothing signaled an emotional reaction (¶ 32, citing State v. Green, 2023 UT 10, ¶ 104, 532 P.3d 930). Hillman did not argue counsel should have objected after R.R. “choked up” (¶ 32).

Issue 4: Redacting the plea statements (ineffective assistance, ¶¶ 33–34): affirmed (no error)

Declining the prosecutor’s offer to redact was reasonable because the defense strategy was to acknowledge the prior convictions (¶ 34).

Issue 5: Cumulative error (ineffective assistance, ¶ 34 n.7): affirmed (harmless error)

The court assumed error on the closing remarks and photos, then held their combined effect did not undermine confidence in the verdict given the strong evidence (n.7, applying State v. Martinez-Castellanos, 2018 UT 46, ¶ 39, 428 P.3d 1038, and State v. Mancia, 2026 UT App 30, ¶ 68, 587 P.3d 1018).

Issue 6: Failure to object to bifurcation (ineffective assistance, ¶¶ 35–36): affirmed (no error)

Hillman showed no prejudice from the court, rather than the jury, finding the section 76-5-404.3(2)(e) aggravating element. The court accepted that the jury must decide each element (¶ 36, citing State v. Walker, 2017 UT App 2, ¶ 20, 391 P.3d 380), but the only evidence was undisputed plea statements and certified judgments, so a jury would not likely have found otherwise (¶ 36).

Issue 7: Cruel and unusual punishment (correctness, ¶ 23): affirmed (no error)

The mandatory LWOP sentence is constitutional as applied. The court applied the “shock the moral senses” standard of State v. Lafferty, 2001 UT 19, ¶ 138, 20 P.3d 342 (¶ 38) and followed State v. Garcia, 2022 UT App 77, 526 P.3d 1238, cert. denied, 525 P.3d 1260 (Utah 2022), which rejected the same multistate, proportionality, and aggravated-murder comparison arguments (¶¶ 39–40). Hillman’s effort to distinguish Garcia by the severity of the conduct failed because the court does “not compare or rank the severity of different conduct giving rise to the same charges” (¶ 41).

Takeaways

  • A prosecutor’s improper appeal to protect the victim may still not support an ineffective-assistance reversal where the evidence, including rule 404(c) evidence, is strong (¶¶ 26–28).
  • Deficiency is judged without hindsight; counsel need not anticipate a witness’s unforeseen emotional reaction (¶ 32).
  • A judge deciding an aggravating element the jury should have decided is not prejudicial where the prior convictions are proved by undisputed documents (¶ 36).
  • As-applied challenges to the section 76-5-404.3(3)(c) LWOP sentence cannot rest on ranking the conduct against Garcia’s (¶ 41).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Hillman
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 147
Case no.
20240123-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
October 1, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Hillman
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Two convictions for aggravated sexual abuse of a child and mandatory sentences of life without the possibility of parole based on prior child sex abuse convictions

The panel

Gregory K. OrmeAuthor
Ryan M. HarrisConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Dianna M. Gibson

Parties & counsel

Hillman — AppellantIndividual(s)Erick Grange
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownJeffrey D. Mann

Practice Tip

An as-applied proportionality challenge to the section 76-5-404.3(3)(c) LWOP sentence cannot rest on arguing the client's conduct was less severe than the conduct in Garcia, because the court will not rank conduct underlying the same charge (¶ 41).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.