Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a DUI breath test count if I bit my nails before it? American Fork City v. Barbour

2026 UT App 107No. 20240929-CADecided Jul 16, 2026Criminal AppealsRemanded

Holding

Because a defendant’s prolonged fingernail chewing during the fifteen-minute Baker observation period required the officer to restart the clock, counsel was ineffective for not moving to suppress the breath test, and the weak remaining evidence of impairment under Utah Code § 41-6a-502(1)(b) created a reasonable probability of a different result.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with Brandon Barbour, the driver who appealed, and threw out his DUI conviction so he can have a new trial.

  • Under Utah law, an officer must watch a person for fifteen minutes before a breath test to make sure nothing goes into the person’s mouth.
  • The court held that fingernails chewed during that period are “something” in the mouth, so the officer had to restart the fifteen minutes.
  • Barbour’s DUI conviction was reversed and he gets a new trial on that charge; his other convictions were not part of this appeal.

What happened?

In May 2023, officers in American Fork pulled Brandon Barbour over after his car briefly crossed the median. His license was suspended, and an officer smelled alcohol on his breath. Barbour said he had “a shot and a beer,” and later “two shots of tequila and two beers.”

The breath-testing machine in American Fork was not working, so officers took him to Pleasant Grove. An officer watched him for more than fifteen minutes and then gave the test, which showed a blood alcohol level of .11. American Fork City, the prosecutor here, charged him with DUI, driving on a suspended license, speeding and improper lane travel.

What was the problem with the breath test?

Utah requires an officer to watch a person for the fifteen minutes right before a breath test to make sure the person puts nothing in their mouth. This is called the Baker period, after a Washington case.

The officer’s bodycam video showed Barbour biting his nails, more or less continuously, for more than two minutes during that window. He stopped less than a minute before the test. His lawyer said he expected to file a motion to suppress (a request to keep evidence out of the trial), but never filed one.

What happened at trial?

A jury convicted Barbour of DUI, driving on a suspended license and improper lane travel, and acquitted him of speeding. Barbour testified that he had been biting his nails, but his lawyer did not play the video showing it.

What did Barbour argue on appeal?

He argued that his lawyer gave him ineffective assistance, meaning the lawyer’s work fell below what the Constitution requires and it hurt his case. He said the lawyer should have tried to exclude the breath test, and should have objected to the prosecutor’s closing comments or played the video.

What did the court decide?

The court agreed with Barbour’s first argument. It said his fingernails were “something” he put in his mouth, so the officer had to restart the fifteen-minute clock. With the test being Barbour’s main problem on the DUI charge, a reasonable lawyer would have asked to exclude it, and nothing would have been lost by trying.

The court also found the mistake mattered. Without the test, the City would have had to prove Barbour was too impaired to drive safely. The court said that evidence was thin: one brief crossing of the median, no smell of alcohol during the first encounter, no testimony about slurred speech or poor balance, and no testimony about what clues of impairment the field sobriety tests showed. Relying on State v. Harvey, 2019 UT App 108, 446 P.3d 125, it found a reasonable chance of a different verdict.

Because this decided the appeal, the court did not reach Barbour’s second argument or his request to add more facts to the record.

What happens now?

The DUI conviction is reversed, and the case goes back to the district court for a new trial on that charge.

What should people take from this?

The fifteen-minute watch before a breath test matters. In this case, chewing fingernails for minutes during that window meant the clock had to start over, and failing to challenge the test cost Barbour a fair trial.

Bottom line

Reversed and remanded for a new trial on the DUI charge (Mortensen, J., joined by Luthy and Oliver, JJ.). Counsel performed deficiently by not moving to suppress the breath test, because Barbour’s fingernails were something he placed in his mouth during the Baker observation period, and the failure was prejudicial (¶¶ 17–18, 26–28).

Issue 1: Failure to move to suppress the breath test (ineffective assistance, ¶¶ 12–27): reversed

Counsel was ineffective for not moving to suppress the Intoxilyzer result. The foundation for a breath test requires that an officer observed the defendant for the fifteen minutes before the test “to ensure that the defendant introduced nothing into his or her mouth” (¶ 15, quoting State v. Vialpando, 2004 UT App 95, ¶ 14, 89 P.3d 209). The court noted that Utah courts had not addressed nail chewing and that the parties cited no non-Utah cases, but it decided the question on “a straightforward application of Baker and its Utah progeny” (¶ 16). Having watched the bodycam video, the court called it “no mere nibble” but “prolonged gnawing” for about two minutes, so the Baker clock had to restart (¶ 17).

Deficient performance: exclusion of the test was Barbour’s only realistic path to acquittal on the DUI, and the worst case of a denied motion was conviction, so it was “a battle that competent counsel would have fought” (¶ 18, citing State v. Ray, 2020 UT 12, ¶ 32, 469 P.3d 871). A pretrial motion outside the jury’s presence would not have raised any concern about drawing jurors’ attention to the evidence (¶ 18 n.7). The City’s futility argument failed because the officer did not comply with Baker (¶ 19).

Prejudice: without the test, the City could not proceed under Utah Code § 41-6a-502(1)(a) or (c), leaving subsection (b), incapacity to drive safely (¶¶ 20–21). Applying State v. Harvey, 2019 UT App 108, 446 P.3d 125, the court found the remaining evidence weak: a single brief crossing of the median, no odor of alcohol in the first encounter, no testimony of slurred speech or poor balance, no testimony describing the FST clues, an unaddressed need to use the bathroom during the FSTs, and admitted drinking that, standing alone, does not establish impairment (¶¶ 22–26). There was a reasonable probability of a different result (¶¶ 26–27).

Not reached

  • Counsel’s failure to object to the prosecutor’s closing statement that the officer complied with Baker, or to play the nail-biting video: unnecessary given the ruling on Issue 1 (¶ 12).
  • Barbour’s rule 23B motion to remand for evidence of counsel’s reasons: moot (¶ 11 n.6).

Takeaways

  • Under Vialpando, fingernails chewed during the Baker period are “something” introduced into the mouth, and the officer must restart the fifteen-minute clock (¶ 17).
  • Where exclusion of the breath test is the defense’s only realistic route to acquittal, not moving to suppress can be objectively unreasonable, and a futility defense fails when the Baker foundation was not met (¶¶ 18–19).
  • For prejudice under subsection (b), the court followed Harvey: admitted drinking and unexplained FST “clues” may not show incapacity to drive safely (¶ 26).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
American Fork City v. Barbour
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 107
Case no.
20240929-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
July 16, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Barbour
Disposition
Remanded
At stake
Barbour's DUI conviction, which rested on a breath test showing a blood alcohol concentration of .11

The panel

David N. MortensenAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Fourth District Court, American Fork Department · Judge Denise Porter

Parties & counsel

Barbour — AppellantIndividual(s)Emily AdamsRachel Phillips Ainscough
American Fork City — AppelleeState of UtahJames HansenCherylyn M. EgnerMelissa K. MellorJesse R. Drury

Practice Tip

In a per se DUI case, compare the bodycam footage of the Baker observation period with the test time; the court held that about two minutes of nail chewing required the officer to restart the fifteen-minute clock, and a pretrial motion to suppress was a battle competent counsel would have fought (¶¶ 17–18).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.