Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can I hire an expert just to rebut my ex’s expert in a divorce? Canter v. Canter

2026 UT App 168No. 20241180-CADecided Nov 5, 2026Family LawAffirmed/Reversed in part

Holding

A party who bears the burden of proof on alimony may designate a rebuttal expert under Utah R. Civ. P. 26(a)(4)(C)(iii) without first designating a case-in-chief expert, and a trial court that orders each party to bear its own fees must adjust for one party’s payment of fees from undivided marital funds or explicitly make a supported fee award.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals upheld the child support and alimony awards against the former husband but sided with the former wife on attorney fees and sent that issue back.

  • In a divorce, a spouse asking for alimony who hires no accountant at first may still disclose one later to answer the other side’s accountant, as long as that expert only responds to the other expert.
  • Alimony needs are measured item by item against the marriage’s standard of living, not by cutting the couple’s past spending in half.
  • If a court says each side pays its own lawyers, it cannot leave one spouse quietly paying part of the other’s fees out of shared money.

What happened?

Chad and Jane Canter were married more than twenty-four years. After a bench trial (a trial before a judge, without a jury), the trial court ordered Chad to pay Jane $2,448 a month in child support and $8,623 a month in alimony (ongoing support for a former spouse). It also ordered each side to pay its own lawyers.

Both sides appealed. Chad challenged the support awards. Jane, in a cross-appeal (her own appeal of other parts of the ruling), challenged how the fee order actually worked out.

Could Jane’s accountant testify?

Yes. Jane first disclosed only a real estate appraiser as an expert. After Chad disclosed his own forensic accountant, Jane hired an accountant as a “rebuttal” expert, meaning one hired to answer the other side’s expert. Chad asked the court to block that testimony, arguing that Jane had to name an accountant at the start.

The Court of Appeals disagreed. Nothing in rule 26 of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure requires a first expert before a rebuttal expert. Alimony can usually be proved without any expert, and many divorcing spouses cannot afford one unless the other side hires one first. The trade-off is that a rebuttal expert may only respond to the other expert, and the trial court can decide when that expert testifies.

Were Jane’s expenses calculated correctly?

Yes. Chad’s accountant had split the couple’s past spending in half. The court explained that this is the wrong approach, because both spouses must now pay for things like housing, utilities and phone service on their own. The right way is to look at each expense item against how the couple lived during the marriage. The trial court did that, and Chad did not show that any single item was wrong.

Was Chad’s income figured correctly?

Yes. A $250,000 commission in 2021 was paid to a company Chad and Jane each owned half of. Chad wanted half of it counted as Jane’s income. The evidence showed Chad earned it for helping arrange financing, so the trial court could count all of it as his income.

Why did Jane win on attorney fees?

After trial, Jane got bank records showing that Chad had paid $85,000 to his lawyers from a marital account before it was split. Jane paid her own fees from her share. So, in effect, she paid half of that $85,000, or $42,500, of Chad’s fees, even though the court had said each side pays its own.

The Court of Appeals said those orders conflict. A court cannot shift fees to one side without saying so and making the findings the law requires.

What happens now?

The trial court must choose. It can order Chad to pay Jane $42,500, or it can openly award Chad part of his fees, which requires findings that Chad needs help and Jane can pay. Jane’s request for her own fees on appeal was denied, because she was never awarded fees in the trial court.

What should people take from this?

Expert disclosure deadlines in a divorce depend on who has to prove the issue, not on who files first. And a “pay your own fees” order must actually leave each side paying its own fees.

Bottom line

Affirmed as to child support and alimony; remanded on attorney fees (Harris, J., joined by Luthy and Oliver, JJ.). The court rejected Chad’s challenges to Jane’s rebuttal expert, her expenses and his income (¶ 63). On Jane’s cross-appeal, the bear-your-own-fees order conflicted with the refusal to account for $85,000 Chad paid his attorneys from an undivided marital account, so the court remanded for the choice described in Miner v. Miner, 2021 UT App 77, ¶ 110, 496 P.3d 242 (¶¶ 62, 64).

Issue 1: Rebuttal expert disclosure (mixed, ¶ 30): affirmed (no error)

Jane properly and timely disclosed her accountant as a rebuttal expert, and not designating a case-in-chief accounting expert did not bar that designation (¶ 41). Under rule 26(a)(4)(C), the governing subsections turn on who bears the burden of proof, not who files first; Jane bore it on alimony, so subsections (i) and (iii) applied, not (ii) (¶¶ 34–35, n.4). The rule’s text has no prior-expert requirement, and its “may preclude” language implies a rebuttal expert may sometimes testify in the case in chief (¶ 38). The court limited this holding to claims, like alimony, where expert testimony is not necessarily required (¶ 37), and distinguished Dierl v. Birkin, 2023 UT App 6, 525 P.3d 127 (n.6). The rebuttal expert is confined to rebutting the other expert, and the court controls timing (¶ 40).

Issue 2: Alimony: expenses and income (mixed, ¶ 31): affirmed (no error)

The trial court applied the correct alimony framework, and its income finding was not clearly erroneous (¶¶ 52, 57).

Expenses (correctness for the framework). Needs are assessed line by line in light of the marital standard of living, not by halving total marital spending (¶¶ 47, 50), citing Fox v. Fox, 2022 UT App 88, ¶ 20, 515 P.3d 481 and Clarke v. Clarke, 2023 UT App 160, ¶ 57, 542 P.3d 935. The court did that (¶ 48). Chad challenged no specific line item, and reliance in part on Jane’s testimony and financial declaration was proper (¶ 51).

Income (clear error). The implied finding that Chad earned the $250,000 2LMD commission was supported by ample evidence, so including all of it in his 2021 income was within the court’s discretion (¶¶ 55–56).

Issue 3: De facto fee award (mixed, ¶ 32): reversed and remanded

The trial court’s orders conflict: it insisted each party bear its own fees while denying an adjustment for the $85,000 Chad paid his attorneys from the undivided Zions Account (¶ 62). Under Miner v. Miner, 2021 UT App 77, ¶ 109, 496 P.3d 242, a court cannot make a fee award “sub silentio” (¶ 61). On remand the court must either order Chad to pay Jane $42,500 or explicitly award Chad partial fees with findings of need and ability to pay (¶ 62). Law of the case did not apply, because Jane’s claim to make the order effective had not been decided before (n.10).

Issue 4: Fees on appeal (none stated, ¶ 62 n.11): Jane’s request for attorney fees on appeal denied

Jane was never awarded fees below, so the general rule in Behar v. Johnson, 2024 UT App 129, ¶ 34 n.2, 557 P.3d 607 does not apply (n.11).

Takeaways

  • An alimony claimant without a case-in-chief expert may still designate a rebuttal expert, limited to rebutting the other expert (¶¶ 40–41).
  • Alimony expenses are assessed line by line, not by halving marital spending; Chad identified no specific line item as wrong (¶¶ 50–51).
  • A bear-your-own-fees order conflicted with one spouse’s payment of fees from undivided marital funds; the court must adjust or make an explicit supported award (¶ 62).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Canter v. Canter
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 168
Case no.
20241180-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
November 5, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Canter · cross-appeal by Canter
Disposition
Affirmed in part and Reversed in part
At stake
Monthly child support of $2,448 and alimony of $8,623 ordered against Chad, and Jane's claim to $42,500, half of the $85,000 in marital funds Chad used to pay his attorneys before the accounts were divided.

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Robert P. Faust

Parties & counsel

Canter — Appellant / Cross-appelleeIndividual(s)Spencer FeltonRyan RuddMeagan RuddCourtney Cooper
Canter — Appellee / Cross-appellantIndividual(s)Julie J. NelsonSkylar WalkerKayla Quam

Practice Tip

In an alimony case, a party who skipped a case-in-chief accounting expert can still designate a rebuttal accountant, but that expert's testimony will be limited to rebutting the other side's expert (¶¶ 40–41). If the other spouse paid fees from undivided marital funds, ask for the adjustment Miner v. Miner, 2021 UT App 77, ¶ 110, 496 P.3d 242, requires (¶ 62).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.